An Esthetic Surgical Approach to Preserve Socket Dimension for Future Implant Placement-an Insight
Department of Prosthodontics, K.D Dental College and Hospital, Mathura, India
INTRODUCCTION
The goal of modern dentistry is restore normal contour, function, comfort, esthetics, speech and health, regardless of atrophy, disease or injury of the stomathognathic system.1
Developing ideal sites for implant placement after tooth extraction depends on controlling the resorption and remodeling phenomena that is inevitably seen during healing of extraction sites.2
There is a 25% decrease in volume during the first year and a 40% to 60% decrease in width within the first three years after tooth loss. This resorption is primarily at the expense of the facial dimension, as the lingual contour undergoes resorption only when more advanced atrophy occurs. As a result, an 8mm wide anterior ridge may be remodel to less than 3mm within 5 years after extraction. This amount of ridge resorption leads to an esthetic compromise in implant therapy because of osseous contours that cannot properly support the overlying soft tissues. Therefore, the preservation or re-creation of natural alveolar ridge anatomy is a prerequisite for success in esthetic implant therapy. Natural hard and soft tissue contours allow both ideal implant placement and the emergence of a restoration that is harmonious with the adjacent oral tissues.1
Site preservation is an extremely important concept for the surgeon, the prosthodontist, and the patient to embrace when implant therapy is contemplated in an area of esthetic crown. The use of site preservation techniques reduces or even eliminates the need for subsequent reconstructive procedures.2
EVOLUTION OF SOCKET PRESERVATION
We have moved from the era of “pelican” (dental elevator) or pincers (forceps) described by Fauchard (1690-1761) (invented by Chauliac in the fourteenth century) to the era of atraumatic extractions by means of instruments such as periotome or physics forceps (invented by Dr. Richard Golden in 2004). Modern extraction forceps date from Tomes in 1840 with the development of the anatomical forceps, complete with a handle and beak to fit the neck of the tooth. Abulkasim (AD 1050-1122) was the first to apply a single lever (elevator) under the tooth to force it from its “bed”. It was improved by Ambroise Pare in the sixteenth century to lift out of the tooth before using the pelican.3 The evolution of dentistry from the prehistoric era to the current scenario has seen various revolutionary breakthroughs. The greatest strides in dentistry has been in the field of oral implantology accomplished in the last three decades. Until recently, implanting alloplastic materials into human jaws was considered highly experimental.4
SOCKET PRESERVATION
Socket Preservation is a procedure in which graft material or scaffold is placed in the socket of an extracted tooth at the time of extraction to preserve the alveolar ridge.
DIFFERENCE BETWEEN SOCKET PRESERVATION AND RIDGE AUGMENTATION
Socket Preservation differs from Ridge Augmentation; in Socket Preservation, the graft or scaffold is placed inside the tooth socket immediately after extraction, whereas the Ridge Augmentation grafting procedure is done to bring back the lost bone after the bone has resorbed and there is insufficient ridge height or width for further treatment procedure.
CLASSIFICATION OF EXTRACTION SOCKETS
Nicolas Elian et al proposed a new classification system. This classification is divided in to three socket types.
Type I Socket. The facial soft tissue and buccal plate of bone are at normal levels in relation to the cementoenamel junction of the pre-extracted tooth and remain intact postextraction. Type I sockets are the easiest and most predictable to treat. Most of the cases seen demonstrating excellent aesthetics with implants are Type I sockets. This is particularly true if the soft tissue profile is thick and flat as opposed to a highly scalloped, thin profile.
Type II
Socket. Facial soft tissue is present but the buccal plate is partially missing following extraction of the tooth. Type II sockets are oftentimes the most difficult to diagnose. These sockets can be very deceptive, as one may make the mistake of treating it as a Type I socket. This often leads to a less than ideal aesthetic result. The largest group of aesthetic problems comes from improper treatment of Type II sockets because of the post treatment soft tissue recession that may occur. This is particularly true when immediate implant placement is performed.5
Type III Socket. The facial soft tissue and the buccal plate of bone are both markedly reduced after tooth extraction.
Type III sockets, however, are very difficult to treat and require soft tissue augmentation with additional grafts of connective tissue, or connective tissue and bone, in a staged approach to rebuild lost tissue. These cases are associated with soft tissue recession and loss of the buccal plate on the tooth prior to extraction. Sockets in this classification require very high dental experience, skill, and time commitment for success.
TECHNIQUES
- Traditional Socket Preservation Technique
- Layer Technique
- Guided Bone Regeneration/Sandwich Technique
- Guided Bone Regeneration with immediate implant placement
- BioCol Technique
- Socket Plug Technique
As far as the coverage of the graft is concerned, primary soft tissue coverage with or without a membrane, sealing of the socket with or without membrane, sealing of the socket with a free gingival graft or a connective tissue graft and placement of a collagen plug for socket occlusion have been proposed. Barrier membranes have been employed showing good results in ridge preservation in a manner similar to GBR. The main drawback associated with this technique is that it requires primary soft tissue closure. Flap advancement for primary closure causes repositioning of the mucogingival junction, displacement of the keratinized mucosa towards the crestal region and increases the postoperative swelling and discomfort.
Furthermore, if the membrane undergoes secondary exposure there is a risk for infection of the graft and jeopardizes the outcome of the preservation procedure. The ‘socket seal surgery’ technique, a ridge preservation technique that does not require flap advancement was introduced to counter these procedure-inherent drawbacks.
A classification concerning the purpose for the application of a ridge preservation technique was proposed by BK Bartee. This classification is based on the resorbability pattern of the bone graft that will be handpicked for each case. Three categories were identified as follows:
Long-term ridge preservation: In this case the technique is used either for pontic site development or in order to improve the stability of removable appliances. Non-resorbable materials are used for this indication and as a result the placement of implants in these sites is not favored.
Medium-term or transitional ridge preservation: Slowly resorbable bone grafts used in ridge preservation allow for the preservation of the alveolar ridge for a protracted period of time whilst enabling the placement of an osseointegrated implant in the site after an initial healing period, even in the presence of some unresorbed graft particles. Transitional ridge preservation is indicated in cases where it is still undetermined whether the patient is going to restore the edentulism with an implant, or in cases where the patient has chosen to have an implant placed but will be unable to return and place the implant for a substantial amount of time.6
Short-term ridge preservation: The objective of this technique is to maintain the postextraction alveolar dimensions during the initial healing phase in order to allow for the placement of an implant in the shortest possible time frame.6
Although a barrier membrane is employed in socket grafting procedures, the point that needs to be emphasised is that this does not constitute Guided Bone Regeneration (GBR). GBR by contrast requires the use of non-resorbable barriers (ePTFE) or resrobable barrier with much longer resorption times (e.g. Biomend, Bioguide, Resolute Adapt Gore-Tex). These types of membrane always require complete primary closure with full soft tissue coverage. Thus a GTR barrier membrane may be required when labial bone loss is identified prior to tooth extraction. Whenever a socket has one or more bony walls missing or damaged, it will be necessary to contemplate Guided Bone Regeneration (GBR). This is a completely different procedure with different objectives and should not be confused with extraction socket grafting for site preservation.7
Following tooth removal, the socket is thoroughly curetted of all soft tissue debris. Bleeding should be stimulated from the osseous base if absent. The key for maximum bone fill is adequate bleeding from the bone, since blood contains fundamental proteins and growth factors for bone healing. (Becker et al. 1996) Profuse bleeding can be achieved by scraping the walls of the socket with either curettes or rotary instruments. This procedure also triggers the regional acceleratory phenomena (RAP), which is known to stimulate new bone formation and graft incorporation (Trevision et al. 2002, Melson 1999).8
The RAP (Regional acceleratory phenomena) is the local response to a noxious stimulus and describes a process by which tissue forms faster than the normal regional regeneration process. By enhancing the various healing stages, this phenomenon makes the healing process occur two to ten times faster than normal physiologic healing. The RAP begins within a few days of injury, typically peaks at 1 to 2 months, usually lasts 4 months in bone, and may take 6 to more than 24 months to subside. Bone grafting surgery and internal fixation procedures also procedures also produce an RAP. When bone graft augmentation is required on both the buccal and lingual aspects, the RAP is created on both sides of the ridge.1
After removing a tooth, the dental implant team faces the formidable challenge of creating a prosthetic restoration that is in harmony with the surrounding natural dentition. To consistently meet this challenge, the implant team and the patient must appreciate the importance of site preservation.2
CLINICAL GOALS OF SOCKET PRESERVATION
(i) to enable installation and stability of a dental implant,
(ii) to reduce loss of alveolar bone volume,
(iii) to reduce need for additional bone grafting procedures,
(iv) to enable the generated tissues to provide implant osseointegration,
(v) to improve the esthetic outcome of the final prosthesis,
(vi) to regenerate bone faster allowing earlier implantation and restoration.9
STEPS - THE WAY TO GO ABOUT IT
Atraumatic tooth extraction- The key to successful site preservation is minimizing trauma to the hard and soft tissues around the tooth being extracted. In order to achieve this, it is necessary to adopt the appropriate technique and instrumentation. The use of a periotome and luxator is critical to achieving atraumatic tooth extractions. The surgical approach involves intrasulcular incisions around the tooth to be extracted. Either no flap or a minimal flap is raised around the neck of the tooth. This helps give access for the periotome and luxator. The periotome is used to sever some of the periodontal ligament around the coronal aspect of the tooth. The periotome should NOT be used as an elevator.
The initial use of a periotome also helps create a better access point for the subsequent use of the luxator. The luxator is used to widen the PDL space and get some mobility of the tooth root being extracted. In many instances, the careful use of the luxator, gradually working it circumferentially around the tooth, will result in the extraction of the tooth, which then simply needs to be removed from the mouth with forceps.
Teeth with a severe coronal fracture extending subgingivally or teeth with multiple roots may require additional efforts to ensure an atraumatic extraction. Typically, this involves carefully sectioning the remains of the tooth and removing it in sections. The judicious use of a straight handpiece with a tungsten carbide tapered fissure bur or round bur sectioning roots but avoiding any contact with the surrounding bone of the socket. By sectioning the tooth root and carefully removing root fragments, there is a reduced risk of trauma to the surrounding alveolar bone, which may otherwise result in fracture of the labial/ buccal plate of bone.10
Use of Physics Forceps for tooth Extraction -Physics Forceps were invented by Dr. Richard Golden in 2004, and have subsequently evolved to their current patented ‘beak and bumper’ design.
The Physics Forceps is based on first-class level mechanics to atraumatically extract a tooth from its socket. One handle of the device is connected to a “bumper,” which acts as a fulcrum during the extraction.
This “bumper” is usually placed on the facial aspect of the dental alveolus, typically at the mucogingival junction. The beak of the extractor is positioned most often on the lingual or palatal root of the tooth and into the gingival sulcus.
Unlike conventional forceps, only one point of contact is made on the tooth being extracted.
Together the “beak and bumper” design acts as a simple first-class lever. A squeezing motion should not used with these forceps. By contrast, the handles are actually rotated as one unit using a steady yet gentle rotational force with wrist movement only.11
Steps involved in the application of Physics Forceps
(1) separation of the gingival attachment from the tooth (e.g. using a periotome);
(2)placement of the ‘beak’ onto a secure palatal/lingual application point (root surface);
(3) placement of the ‘bumper’ (with single-use plastic sleeve attached) onto the buccal aspect of the alveolus at the level of the mucogingival junction (this acts as a fulcrum; braces and protects the buccal plate);
(4) application of a steady slow rotational force (facilitates creep in the periodontium) using only wrist movement for 30–40 seconds;
(5) occlusal elevation of the tooth a few millimetres from its socket;
(6) delivery of the tooth using a haemostat/rongeurs/conventional forceps. Lower molars (dependent on root morphology) may need sectioning to allow for a more predictable extraction.11
If considering immediate implant placement, the clinician should consider reducing the buccal aspect of the tooth to be extracted a couple of millimeters with a surgical bur subgingivally, or consider using a periotome before using the Physics Forceps.11
SOCKET DEBRIDEMENT
Once the tooth root has been extracted, it is imperative to thoroughly debride the socket walls. This is best undertaken with a surgical spoon curette.
This part of the procedure should not be rushed; each area within the extraction socket needs to be curetted and all remnant periodontal ligament tissues removed from the socket walls. This has the added advantage of inducing some bleeding (increased vascularity) into the socket.
PLACEMENT OF GRAFT MATERIAL
Following socket debridement, the graft material should be lightly packed into the extraction socket in an incremental fashion. A flat plastic instrument and plugger can be used to lightly condense the particulate graft to the top of the bony socket walls. Avoid heavy condensing of the graft particulate into the socket as this may compromise the vascularity within the socket and subsequent osseous healing. Also, do not overfill the extraction socket as excess graft material may be lost post operatively and may compromise soft tissue healing over the socket. Graft material should be placed into the socket to the level of the surrounding socket walls.12-13
Use of graft containment barrier- To assist with containment of the graft particles within the extraction socket, a resorbable barrier membrane is recommended. This is particularly important if there is no primary closure through a coronally advanced flap or the addition of a connective tissue graft. The principle purpose of the barrier membrane is to contain the graft material while soft tissue healing takes place over the extraction site. As epithelialization takes place within the first 2-3 weeks post extraction, it is possible to use a collagen barrier with a shorter resorption time. Thus, the materials of choice would be Colatape or the recently released Socket Repair Membrane.
SUMMARY
Studies by Lekovic et al, demonstrated that the use of barrier membranes over extraction sockets significantly decreases the loss of alveolar bone height and width and simultaneously increases the level of bone fill in the socket. When dental implants are placed in fresh extraction sockets and the sites are isolated according to the principles of guided bone regeneration, the crestal levels of bone regeneration have shown to improve significantly but are dependent on the maintenance of soft tissue coverage over the membrane.2 The key element in obtaining optimal function and esthetic is by the avoidance of postextraction bone resorption and preservation of the natural soft tissue volume and architecture. Henceforth, the rationale for combining the surgical and prosthetic site-preservation protocols is based on the understanding of the potential synergistic effects that result when surgical and prosthetic management are closely coordinated.2 The philosophy of “prosthetically-driven implant placement” requires the practitioner to first envision the final restoration in its ideal position. The position of the tooth or teeth is determined by the prosthetic demands— the factors that will place the restoration in esthetic and occlusal harmony with adjacent oral structures. Prior to surgery, the dentist needs to envision the placement of the dental implant. Once the ideal position of the implant is determined, it may be evident that the patient’s existing three-dimensional bony architecture will not completely
house the implant and that augmentation is necessary. Today, clinicians have an array of hard tissue augmentation procedures available to them to create bone where it is needed to accommodate the prosthetically driven implant.
However, the most cost-effective and time-efficient bone augmentation procedure available remains the preservation of the alveolar dimensions at the time of extraction. In other words, if you have it, don’t lose it.
REFERENCES
- Carl E. Misch Contemporary Implant Dentistry
- Anthony G Sclar.Soft Tissue and Esthetic Considerations in Implant Therapy
- Linkow Implant Dentistry Today A Multidisciplinary Approach Vol I
- Wallace W. Johnson The History of Prosthetic Dentistry J Prosthet Dent 9(5) 841-846
- Nicolas Elian, Sang-Choon Cho, Stuart Froum, Richard B. Smith, Dennis P. Tarnow A simplified socket classification and repair technique. Pract Proced Aesthet Dent. 19(2) 99-104
- George Kotsakis, Nicolas Markou, Vanessa Chrepa, Vasiliki Krompa, Anastasios Kotsakis Alveolar Ridge Preservation Utilizing the ‘Socket-Plug’ Technique
- Michael Danesh-Meyer. Management of the extraction socket: Site preservation prior to implant placement.Australasian Dental Practice March/April 2008
- Abd El Salam El Askary Fundamentals of Esthetic Implant Dentistry
- Giorgio Pagni,Gaia Pellegrini, William V. Giannobile and Giulio RasperiniPostextraction Alveolar Ridge Preservation: Biological Basis and Treatments International Journal of DentistryVolume 2012
- Adam Weiss, Avichai Stern, Harry Dym Technological advances in extraction techniques and outpatient oral surgery Dent Clin N Am 55 (2011) 501–513
More references are available on request
Disclaimer from Guident
The views and opinions expressed in articles published in Guident are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the editors, the editorial board or the publisher, Ivory India. Guident does not endorse any product, technique or treatment described. Clinical content is intended for qualified dental and medical professionals and is not a substitute for individual clinical judgement. Guident, its editors and the publisher accept no liability for any consequence arising from the use of information published in the journal.
How to cite this article
Dr. Manesh Lahori, Dr. Divya Sachdev, Dr. Deveshi Chandan. An Esthetic Surgical Approach to Preserve Socket Dimension for Future Implant Placement-an Insight. Guident. 2015 Feb;8(3). Available from: https://ivoryindia.in/articles/implantology/an-esthetic-surgical-approach-to-preserve-socket-dimension-for-future-implant-placement-an-insight.html















