Influence of Soft Tissue Sloughing on Bone Grafting Outcome
ASSOCIATE DENTIST AT GLOBAL HEALTH RESEARCH GROUP, NEW DELHI, CONSULTANT MAX HEALTHCARE, NEW DELHI
An implant with successful osseointegration can fail if the final prosthesis doses not provide the optimal required esthetics. Failure to achieve proper esthetics could be due to several reasons, some of which are untreatable. The esthetic outcome of an implant-supported restoration is affected by four main factors (Abdelsalam Elaskary, 2009):
(1)implant placement,
(2)soft tissue management,
(3)bone grafting considerations, and
(4)prosthetic considerations
Bone and soft tissue deficiency before implant placement can be a challenge to many clinicians since extensive bone grafting remains a delicate procedure, because of the slow and difficult integration of the grafted material into the physiological architecture. Advances in biomaterials and clinical techniques have facilitated significant expansion in the indications for dental implant therapy and have shown promising outcomes. However, complications associated with grafting procedures do occur. (Jingjing Li, Wang HL 2008)
These complications challenge clinicians in their ability of identifying etiologies and providing proper and timely management of these problems and hopefully instituting protocols to minimize their occurrence in the future. (Schlegel KA, Sindet-Pedersen S 2000)
Soft or hard tissue loss is a detrimental factor for the success of dental implants. Krekeler et al (Krekeler G, Schilli W, Diemer J. 1985) suggested a relationship between implant failure and the absence of an adequate band of keratinized mucosa surrounding the abutment. This relationship was based on the ability of the keratinized mucosa to withstand bacterial insult and ingression.
Tonetti and Schmid (Tonetti MS, Schmid 1994), stated that the late failures that occur as a result of peri-implantitis (infectious etiology) occur because of defective function of the soft tissues. Therefore, the marginal peri-abutment tissues should constitute a functional barrier between the oral environment and the host bone by sealing off the osseous fixture site from noxious agents and thermal and mechanical trauma.
On the contrary, Strub et al. (Strub J Gaberthuel T, Grunder U 1991) stated that the keratinized mucosa or dental plaque does not seem to be related to implant failure but that its presence might facilitate the patient’s hygienic procedures. However, in the aesthetic zone, the relationship between the available keratinized mucosa and the overall success of the implant supported prosthesis is of great value.
The most common soft tissue complication would be the soft tissue marginal recession or discrepancy, which might be influenced by many factors such as: (Abdelsalam Elaskary, 2009)
1) Biocompatibility of the trans-mucosal components, as the adhesion of the junctional epithelium and connective tissue is possible only on highly biocompatible materials.
2) Repeated removal and placement of the abutment leads to cell tear and biological width disruption, because the repeated unscrewing the abutment mechanically disrupts the cellular attachment mechanism and might lead to apical migration of the cells.
3) Loosening of the Implant interface connection forms a gap that harbors bacteria that can invade the surrounding tissues, the further long term screw losing activates bone loss and apical tissue migration.
4) A muscle pull on the implant site might lead to a continuous steady gingival recession as it happens around natural teeth.
5) The location of the implant-abutment connection in relation to the gingival level, as it is suggested that when the location of the implant–abutment connection above the gingival level, the gingival recession and its inflammatory gingival response is highly reduced.
6) Shear loading beyond reasonable limits can destroy the marginal bone crest leading to non-interlocking implant surfaces which subsequently leads to gingival recession.
7) The location of the smooth collar of the implant in relation to the bone level might induce bone resorption due to the less bone affinity to smooth surfaces which might lead to the possible migration of the attachment apparatus.
8) The continuous pressure induced from a removable prosthesis might lead to gingival recession.
9) Premature delivery of the final prosthesis (min two months) has proven to lead to post insertion gingival recession as the soft tissue should reach a stable remodeling status prior to final crown insertion.
10) The amount of osseous contouring in the second stage surgery might stimulate further bone resorption that initiates gingival recession.
11) The geometry of the implant diameter in relation to the size of the abutment used that might influence bone levels via platform switching.
12) The use of alcohol disinfectants for the healing abutments might lead to cell death or the periimplant tissues and to further recession.
The success of a soft tissue graft depends on(Sullivan, H., Atkins, J.,1968):
A. The survival of the connective tissue
B. Establishment of blood supply to the graft during the vascularization stage
C. Fibrous attachment of the graft to the recipient bed
D. The survival of the keratinized epithelium
Sloughing of the epithelium occurs in most cases, but the extent to which the connective tissue withstands the transfer to the new location determines the fate of the graft. (Sullivan, H., Atkins, J.,1968)
Fibrous organization of the interface between the graft and the recipient bed occurs within 2 to several days.
The epithelium undergoes degeneration and sloughing, with complete necrosis occurring in some areas. It is replaced by new epithelium from the borders of the recipient site. A thin layer of new epithelium is present by the fourth day, with rete pegs developing by the seventh day.
The fact that heterotopically placed grafts maintain their structure (keratinized epithelium), even after the grafted epithelium has become necrotic and has been replaced by neighboring areas of nonkeratinized epithelium, suggests that there exists a genetic predetermination of the specific character of the oral mucosa that is dependent on stimuli that originate in the connective tissue. This is the basis for the technique that uses grafts composed only of connective tissue obtained from areas where it is covered by keratinized epithelium. (Sullivan, H., Atkins, J.,1968)
Bone grafting has become an essential part of implant dentistry. Implant-associated bone grafting are becoming more and more popular, but complications related to bone grafting are several and their prevention is of the utmost importance.
Use of membrane for guided bone regeneration (GBR) to contain and allow for the environment necessary for graft maturation is paramount. Though the use of membrane for GBR also runs a risk of flap sloughing, more commonly with non-resorbable membranes than with resorbable and exposure not only of the membrane but also of the micro screws holding it into place leading to bacterial contamination and infection. (del Castillo RA 2000)
Without complete soft tissue coverage over the socket or complete seal of the sinus membrane perforation, contamination or loss of graft materials placed can also occur. This can lead to premature membrane and graft removal.
A tension-free flap closure is essential so exposure of membrane or fixation screws can be prevented. The development of a tension free flap for an advancement type primary closure is not without its challenges. Anatomic considerations as in the mandibular premolar area due to the presence of the mental foramen and neuro-vascular bundle (NVB), esthetic considerations as in the anterior maxilla, existing inadequate soft tissue architecture either from recession and/or thin biotype might not allow for split thickness flap development or lead to inadvertent perforation of the gingival or mucosa can compromise the surgical results. (del Castillo RA 2000)
Reduction of keratinized tissue at the facial aspect with primary closure may also be a potential complication. However, this can be avoided by careful treatment planning in advance to allow the socket to heal for 6 to 8 weeks before grafting.
Newly formed keratinized tissue growing over the socket will then provide necessary primary closure without sacrificing the facial width of keratinized tissue. This approach to manage the inadequate amount of keratinized tissue delays the planned prosthetic rehabilitation.
Use of platelet concentrates like platelet rich plasma (PRP) mixed into the hard tissue replacement graft and PRF for mucosal healing aims to improve this process of integration by accelerating bone and mucosal healing.
PRF is a healing biomaterial that concentrates in a single autologous fibrin membrane, most platelets, leukocytes, and cytokines from blood harvest at the time of surgery, without artificial biochemical modification (no anticoagulant and no bovine thrombin) and without the need for pre-donation and costly processing or the use of homologous blood products.
Whether used as a membrane or as fragments, PRF allows a significant postoperative protection of the surgical site and seems to accelerate the integration, remodeling and healing of the soft tissue and it provides a very high quality of gingival maturation. This fibrin biomaterial represents a new opportunity to improve both the maturation and the final esthetic result of the peri-implant soft tissue.
The protocol: whole blood is drawn in 10-mL tubes without anticoagulant and is immediately centrifuged at around 400 g for 12 minutes. Within few minutes, the absence of anticoagulant allows the activation of the majority of the platelets contained in the sample, in contact with the tube walls, thus triggering a coagulation cascade. The fibrinogen is at first concentrated in the upper part of the tube, until the effect of the circulating thrombin transforms it into a fibrin network. The result is a fibrin clot located in the middle of the tube and soaked with acellular plasma, with a maximum number of platelets caught in the fibrin mesh.
When used as a membrane, PRF enables the protection of operative sites from outside aggression and serves as a matrix to accelerate the healing of wound edges, much like a fibrin bandage.
When mixed with the graft material, the fibrin clot functions as a biological connector between the different elements of the graft, and as a matrix which favors neo-fibrinogenesis, neo-angiogenesis, and promotion of cellular differentiation, and acceleration of the effects of growth factors on other cells, such as macrophages. The capture of stem cells, and the liquid medium found within the gel causes migration of osteoprogenitor cells to the center of the bone graft.
It has been observed and reported that soft tissue healing occurs at an accelerated rate and results in keratinized tissue formation. The molecular pool results from the release by PRGF scaffolds influence cell proliferation, release of angiogenic growth factors (VEGF, HGF), synthesis of type 1 collagen and hyaluronic acid (HA) and inflammation.
REFERENCES
1. Abdelsalam Elaskary. Aesthetic Complications. Dental implants:2009;4;26-29
2. Jingjing Li, Wang HL. Common implant-related advanced bone grafting complicatons: classification, etiology, and management. Implant Dentistry: 2008;17:389-401.
3. Schlegel KA, Sindet-Pedersen S, Hoepffner HJ. Clinical and histological findings in guided bone regeneration (GBR) around titanium dental implants with autogenous bone chips using a new resorbable membrane. J Biomed Mater Res. 2000;53:392-399.
4. Sullivan, H., Atkins, J., Free autogenous gingival grafts. I. Principles of successful grafting. Periodontics. 6:5, 1968, 856.
5. del Castillo RA. Defect morphology: Effects on regenerative predictability and membrane selection. Compend Contin Educ Dent. 2000;21:383-385, 388, 390.
6. El Askary AS, Meffert RM, Griffen T. Why do dental implants fail? Part 1. Implant Dent 1999; 8:173-85.
7. El Askary A, Meffert R, Griffin T. Why do dental implants fail? Part II. Implant Dentistry 1999;8(3):265-76
8. Dohan DM, Choukroun J, Diss A, et al. Platelet-rich fibrin (PRF): A second-generation platelet concentrate. I. Technological concepts and evolution. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod. 2006;101:e37-e44.
9. Dohan DM, Choukroun J, Diss A, et al. Platelet-rich fibrin (PRF): A second-generation platelet concentrate. II. Platelet-related biologic features. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod. 2006;101:e45-e50.
10 . Dohan DM, Choukroun J, Diss A, et al. Platelet-rich fibrin (PRF): A second-generation platelet concentrate. III. Leucocyte activation: A new feature for platelet concentrates? Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod. 2006;101:e51-e55.
11. Choukroun J, Diss A, Simonpieri A, et al. Platelet-rich fibrin (PRF): A second-generation platelet concentrate. IV. Clinical effects on tissue healing. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod. 2006;101:e56-e60.
Disclaimer from Guident
The views and opinions expressed in articles published in Guident are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the editors, the editorial board or the publisher, Ivory India. Guident does not endorse any product, technique or treatment described. Clinical content is intended for qualified dental and medical professionals and is not a substitute for individual clinical judgement. Guident, its editors and the publisher accept no liability for any consequence arising from the use of information published in the journal.
How to cite this article
Dr. Prerna Kaushik. Influence of Soft Tissue Sloughing on Bone Grafting Outcome. Guident. 2017 Dec;11(1). Available from: https://ivoryindia.in/articles/implantology/influence-of-soft-tissue-sloughing-on-bone-grafting-outcome.html






