Ethical and Legal Responsibility for Patient Care- Part 1
New Delhi Consultant Max Healthcare, New Delhi
The dental profession has an ethical and legal responsibility for patient care. A properly maintained patient record is a very important aspect of this patient care. In general, a “record” can be defined as information generated in the course of an organization’s official transactions and one that is documented to act as a source of reference and a tool by which an organization is governed. The dental record is the official office document that records all diagnostic information, clinical notes, treatment performed and patient-related communications that occur in the dental office, including instructions for home care and consent to treatment. The dental record is hence a legal document owned by the clinician, which contains subjective and objective information about the patient.
A properly maintained dental record renders several uses. Good records enable monitoring of the patients’ state of oral health and can also to aid motivation in preventive oral healthcare practices. It is helpful in monitoring the success/failure of any treatment carried out.
A detailed and accurate dental record is essential as it serves the clinicians own best interests in the event of a malpractice suit. A complete record also enables communication with another practitioner who may be required to provide care to the patient in the absence of the primary clinician. They are essential for dental audit, which is a vital part of quality control. A dental audit critically analyses every aspect of dental care.
It begins from initial entry of patient information to assessing competence of the dental professional to diagnose, treat, use resources and practice evidence-based dentistry. All these factors influence the quality of life as assessed by the patient and the professional. Records can be used in the management and planning of health care facilities and services, for health care research and the production of health care statistics. Finally, a person's dental record can play a vital role in forensic dentistry in identification, detection and solution of a crime, in civil proceedings or in natural or manmade disaster situations.
A dental record repertoire of a patient could consist of regularly updated dental charts wherein the clinician records all the oral and perioral hard and soft changes taking place over time. Additionally, radiographs, photographs, casts, impressions and dentures could also be a part of the patient record. Practicing clinicians can become valuable members of the dental identification process by developing and maintaining good records that would be invaluable in regard to the identification of human remains solitary or mass fatalities, biting injuries and child abuse. Identification of the deceased helps families to get a sense of closure and come to terms with their loss. It helps the police apprehend the perpetrators of the crime and build a strong legal case against them.
As the dental practitioner is solely accountable for complete and accurate patient records, there are certain basic criteria that need to be followed in writing a dental record.
A. PATIENT RECORD
1.All entries should be either recorded in ink and not in pencil legibly or recorded in an electronic format.
2.The date of every patient visit should be entered in a chronological order
3.omplete recording of all items in the patient's case history form, which includes
- General patient information – age, gender, birth date, place of employment, contact information that includes telephone numbers and address and any referring party
- Chief complaint, past dental, medical, family, drug histories and allergies need to be updated regularly and, in case of children, the immunization status.
- Specific questions related to women regarding pregnancy and lactation
- Clinical and radiographic findings, diagnosis, proposed treatment and prognosis
- Copies of test results, instructions for home care, patient follow-up and recall examinations, fees charged and referrals.
4.Due to paucity of time, the clinician may not be able to personally record all the details in the patient's record. Some entries may be delegated to office staff. For example, the receptionist can record telephone calls, prescription changes and appointments. The dental assistant records the patient's comments, concerns and disposition; vital signs; medical history; radiographs and other diagnostic tools taken and used; and instructions given to the patient, etc. The clinician can then add clinical impressions, treatments performed and any pertinent information. It should be remembered that the clinician is ultimately responsible for the patient's chart.
5.All diagnostic aids, which include radiographs, study models, photographs etc., should be properly labeled and dated
6.Established terminology, symbols and abbreviations should only be used in order to avoid misunderstandings between different members of the dental team
7.All entries should be signed or initialled by the treating clinician
8.Informed consent forms with patient signature for invasive procedures, sedation etc., should be taken
9.Signature of the patient is also necessary if the patient refuses to undergo a treatment even though the clinician feels is essential for the health of the patient. Registering informed refusal is as important as noting down the patient's informed consent
10.Record should be objective in nature. It should contain only facts relating to the case and professional opinions in notations and not subjective interpretations for which the clinician is not trained. It should not contain any derogatory remarks regarding the patient
11.Any mistakes in the records should be corrected with a single line drawn through the incorrect material in an honest, open manner. Deliberate obliteration or alterations of the record after the fact should not be made under any circumstances
12.All communications with the patient, including emergency telephonic consultations, should be recorded
13.If a patient is dissatisfied, all communications should be recorded including the problem, the attempt to deal with the problem and the solution to the problem
14.If a patient wishes to discontinue treatment, a note of it should be made in the patient's record along with the reason
15.Classify all patient files into either active or inactive. Active files hold the records of patients who are at present having their dental care provided by the practice. Inactive patients are considered to be those who have not returned to the dental practice for 24 months.
The most common types of errors committed in record keeping are: (1) not recording the treatment plan, (2) not documenting health history clearly or failure to update it regularly and (3) failure to document informed consent or informed refusal.
B. BUSINESS RECORD
It should include details of billing with date and amount, copies of claims forms submitted by the patient, information related to name, address, nature of the laboratory services used and laboratory charges, scheduling of appointments, etc. This information should not be kept along with the patient clinical record.
C. DRUG RECORD
Clinicians prescribe certain drugs for a number of conditions related to the oral cavity. Although the number of these drugs is limited, the use of these drugs has important implications and extreme care should be taken upon prescribing to make the best use of these drugs and prevent their side-effects.
A drug record of the patient should include:-
- The date and method of prescription/administration/dispensing of drug
- Name, strength, quantity and form of drug
- Directions for use of drug
- Condition being treated and/or dental treatment provided
- Prescription pads should never be pre-signed and should be kept out of reach of patients to avoid potential misuse.
A study by Dar-Odeh et al. on the analysis of clinical records of dental patients attending the Jordan University Hospital found that drug prescriptions and local anesthetic injections were poorly documented by the investigated group of dental specialists.
Disclaimer from Guident
The views and opinions expressed in articles published in Guident are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the editors, the editorial board or the publisher, Ivory India. Guident does not endorse any product, technique or treatment described. Clinical content is intended for qualified dental and medical professionals and is not a substitute for individual clinical judgement. Guident, its editors and the publisher accept no liability for any consequence arising from the use of information published in the journal.
How to cite this article
Dr.Prerna Kaushik Associate Dentist at health Research Group. Ethical and Legal Responsibility for Patient Care- Part 1. Guident. 2018 May;11(6). Available from: https://ivoryindia.in/articles/general/ethical-and-legal-responsibility-for-patient-care-part-1.html





