Open AccessPeer ReviewedPublished Monthly Since 2007 Vol. 19, Issue 12 · November 2026Media Kitinfo@guident.net

Ethical and Legal Responsibility for Patient Care- Part 2

  • Dr. Prerna KaushikConsultant Prothodontist

ASSOCIATE DENTIST AT GLOBAL RESEARCH GROUP, NEW DELHI CONSULTANT MAX HEALTHCARE, NEW DELHI

Guident · Volume 11, Issue 7 (June 2018)Published June 20186 min read

Most clinicians believe that their record keeping is adequate. In reality, a discrepancy exists between clinicians’ perception of dental record adequacy and recommended structure and guidelines. This has been shown to be true when examining evidence from studies carried out in various parts of the world. It was found that fundamental clinical entries that could have an impact on basic dental care provision were missing from many records. The frequency of recording for patients whose treatment was funded under government regulations was significantly worse than for patients whose treatment was privately funded. In a study by Osbourne et al. to determine Minnesota clinicians’ perception of the adequacy of their dental record documentation, 85% clinicians felt their record documentation was adequate while in reality, 9-87% of the time information was found to be absent when compared with the American Dental Association (ADA) criteria.

These shortcomings observed in several studies can be reduced significantly by following the universally accepted record keeping format – SOAP. SOAP is an acronym for-

SUBJECTIVE DATA

This section contains information about the reason for visit to the clinician, which includes the patient's chief complaint/s and symptoms.

OBJECTIVE FINDING

This section records all the findings obtained from the clinical examination and diagnostic tests in an unbiased manner.

ASSESMENT

Diagnostic and therapeutic judgment is reached based on subjective data and objective findings.

PLANS

In this stage, the assessment is converted into action. Herein, the various treatment options along with their pros and cons, economic and time considerations, home care instructions, appropriate use of prescribed medication and consequences of unwillingness to undergo treatment are explained to the patient so that he/she can make an informed decision regarding their course of treatment.

Ethics guides the moral consciousness of the health care profession, and confidentiality is one of its core principles. The relationship of a clinician and patient is based on trust. Every dental record is therefore made under the basic premise that the health information of the patient would be kept confidential not only by the clinician but also by every member of the dental team. This information should be protected from any unauthorized use or disclosure even to family members except when required by law or where the patient has given their express consent, ideally in writing. All dental records should be stored in a safe place and never left unattended. If an electronic system is used for entering patient records, then it should have a login and password to access data. Backup of all records should be performed on a removable medium that will enable data recovery in the event of a systems failure. A breach of confidentiality occurs when private information that the clinician has learned within the patient is divulged to a third party without the patients consent or a court order.

Garbin et al. found that although clinicians declared to be aware of professional confidentiality, nearly half of the respondents acted unethically by talking about the clinical cases of their patients to their friends or spouses. Violation of professional ethics, no matter how minor, will result in problems to both the clinician and the patient.

The clinician is usually the legal owner of the records. The records should never be released by the clinician unless by the express wish of the patient. There are several exceptions to this rule:

  1. When referring cases to another clinician either for consultation or treatment
  2. When demanded by the court in cases of medicolegal issues, occupation-related or road traffic accidents requiring compensation – the original records should be submitted. It is essential to keep a photocopy of the same
  3. On request of the legal disciples.
  4. When asked for by income tax authorities or insurance companies.

A clinician leaving or selling a practice should ideally give patients advance written notice about the change of ownership. If the outgoing clinician is unable to do so, the incoming clinician should notify patients that he or she is now the new owner of the practice and is therefore in possession of their records.

All the original records of the patient are the sole property and responsibility of the treating clinician and should be in his custody. If the patient moves to a different dental practice, a copy of the records should be transferred to the new practitioner. A minimum fee can be charged by the clinician for copying of the records provided the patient is made aware of the charges.

At the end of the retention period, records must be disposed of in a manner that protects patient confidentiality and maintains physical security of the information. Methods include:1) The records can be returned to the individual or dealt with in accordance with patient's instructions,2) Controlled physical destruction of records such as shredding or incineration,3)Confidential transfer to another agency that will provide appropriate services to destroy the information, 4)The process used to destroy electronic records must render them unreadable and eliminate the possible reconstruction of the records in whole or in part and 5)For secure cast and model destruction, all identifying information on casts and models must be removed prior to disposal.

Lawney describes a simple ten-step procedure to ensure that your records are adequate. A modified and expanded version, appropriate to the National Health Service and UK dentistry, which has been followed in UK

  1. Use a consistent style for entries — the appearance of the record is enhanced by using the same colour and type of pen, use the same abbreviations and notations, and so on
  2. Date and explain any corrections — it may be a fatal error in a malpractice case if records appear doctored in any way. These unexplained corrections can undermine the credibility of the entire record and of the treating clinician.
  3. Use single-line crossout — this preserves the integrity of the record and shows that you have nothing to hide
  4. Do not use correction fluids — not only is this messy, but it is conspicuous and may indicate that there has been an attempt to hide information.
  5. Use ink — pencil can fade and opens up the question of whether or not the records have been altered.
  6. Write legibly — an illegible record may be as bad as no record at all. Difficult to read entries can lead to guesswork by others and this may not be favorable to you.
  7. Express concerns about patient needs — by doing this you are documenting that you have listened, empathized, understood, and acted upon the wishes of your patient. It also enables an explanation to be given should a patient’s wishes be unobtainable or unrealistic, and can help instantly diffuse a malpractice case. Use quotations to indicate patient comments as distinct from your own.
  8. Never write derogatory remarks in the record — Superfluous entries only serve to convey a feeling of unprofessionalism and may create doubts regarding the overall credibility of the remainder of the record. Negative views about patients, such as their failure to follow your advice or attend appointments, should be recorded in a dispassionate and objective manner.
  9. Document fully — there is no need to be sparse with notes, a detailed explanation is always better than one lacking information.
  10. Only use accepted abbreviations for treatments — this is helpful both in a malpractice situation and also when transferring records to a different clinician for referral, prior approval or a change in clinician.
  11. Collate documents — insurance details and other materials from third parties should be separate from those items that pertain directly to patient care.
  12. Maintain a chronological order — the use of a hole punch and metal retainer clips on the top of the record may be helpful to keep loose sheets organized.

Disclaimer from Guident

The views and opinions expressed in articles published in Guident are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the editors, the editorial board or the publisher, Ivory India. Guident does not endorse any product, technique or treatment described. Clinical content is intended for qualified dental and medical professionals and is not a substitute for individual clinical judgement. Guident, its editors and the publisher accept no liability for any consequence arising from the use of information published in the journal.

How to cite this article

Dr. Prerna Kaushik. Ethical and Legal Responsibility for Patient Care- Part 2. Guident. 2018 Jun;11(7). Available from: https://ivoryindia.in/articles/general/ethical-and-legal-responsibility-for-patient-care-part-2.html

Related articles

More in General

All 212 articles
Vol. 11, Issue 7 · June 2018

Green Dentistry: The Need for Today and Tomorrow

The colour green is an earthy shade and it represents comfort, calmness, and positivity. Growth and hope are also represented by this colour. It depicts safety of the drugs and other…

Dr. Yogeshwari Krishan

Vol. 11, Issue 8 · July 2018

Tooth Extraction and Preservation of Alveolar Ridge

PREVALENCE OF ENDENTULISM The percent of edentulous people among the US population has declined over the last century with each generation1. However, there continues to be substantial…

Dr. Aakash Shah

Vol. 11, Issue 8 · July 2018

Biomedical Waste Management Indental Setup

According to the Notification by the Ministry of Environment and Forests, Government of India; "biomedical waste (BMW)" means any waste, which is generated during the diagnosis, treatment…

Dr. Vidur Arya

Vol. 11, Issue 8 · July 2018

Tooth Extraction and Preservation of Alveolar Ridge

PREVALENCE OF ENDENTULISM The percent of edentulous people among the US population has declined over the last century with each generation 1 . However, there continues to be substantial…

Dr.Akash Shah

Call for papers

Publish your clinical work in Guident

Original research, case reports and review articles are welcomed from clinicians and researchers worldwide. Every submission is assessed by the editorial board.