Ethics in Dental Outreach Programs-Need of the Day in Civilized Life, Law Floats in a Sea of Ethics-Earl Warren
Seema Dental College & Hospital, Rishikesh, India
Professions emerge and evolve over time, usually as a result of scientific advancement. Thus, artisans become artists and craftsmen become professionals. No different is the case of Dentistry. As healthcare workers and responsible citizens, we must provide the best of care and awareness about general and dental health to the masses. Our actions, no matter how sincere our intentions, must meet with social norms of fairness and beneficence.
Twenty years ago, there was little formal intellectual work that considered ethical questions in medicine. What ethical discussion existed was more or less limited to questions about physicians’ practices and how they were interrelated: should physicians extend professional courtesy? Should they conceal from a patient their disagreement with a colleague’s diagnosis? One of the most important reasons for the growth in concerns over ethics is rooted in the tremendous technological advances that, with great cost, offer prolonged or improved life quality. With high-tech enhancements come questions about who gets the care, who pays for it, and how those decisions are made. 1, 2
In the mid 1800’s, some dentists made overstated claims about the benefits of treatment. The efforts to organize dentistry were based on a desire to protect the public from unscrupulous practitioners whose practices were not based on latest scientific knowledge and accepted principles. The prohibitions against advertising traced to codes of ethics developed by barristers in medieval England, were a direct effort on the part of the profession to control outrageous advertising practices and thereby make the profession more trustworthy.
The professionalization process has positive and negative outcomes which might be referred to as the paradox of professionalism in contemporary society. On one hand professionalization enables standard setting that protects the public – a positive outcome. On the other hand, it creates a kind of monopoly that tends to increase cost and reduce access to care – a negative outcome. Society has conferred powers and privileges on dentistry commensurate with the level of power and privilege reserved for the most highly professionalized occupations, thereby implying that society views the provision of dental care as essential for its health and welfare.
The recent growth of ethics literature in dentistry has been significant but is nearly 15 years behind medicine in terms of its analysis of dentally related ethical problems. However the silver lining is that , there is a rising interest in ethics in dental education. As many as 80% of American dental schools3 and all dental hygiene schools 4 now have courses in professional ethics.
According to WHO, the provision of oral health care services is very little in rural parts of India, further complexity is lent by the great variation that occurs across this population on social parameters such as income and education. 5 Despite this, even the most basic oral health education and simple interventions for pain relief and emergency care for acute infection and trauma is unavailable to the vast majority of population, especially the rural and urban poor. In addition, the recent growth in the economy and the advances in healthcare technology have widened the gap between the rich and the poor, exacerbating the inequity in access to oral health care in particular and health care in general. Despite the deleterious consequences of untreated oral pathology, inappropriate utilization of dental services remains a major problem. 6
Utilization of health care is a complex phenomenon and multifaceted human behavior. Various theories and conceptual models have been proposed to explain this phenomenon. The determinants of oral health care can be classified as predisposing (socio-demographic factors like age, sex, occupation, and social network), enabling (transportation, income, and information), and need (perceived health or professionally assessed illness) factors. 7
If due to any reasons the patients cannot reach us, we must try to reach them. Outreach is an activity of providing services to populations who might not otherwise have access stationary, but mobile; in other words they are meeting those in need of outreach services at the locations where those in need are. In addition to delivering services, outreach has an educational role, raising the awareness of existing services. Outreach is often meant to fill in the gap in the services provided by mainstream (often, governmental) services, and is often carried out by non-profit, nongovernmental organizations. This is a major element differentiating outreach from public relations. Compared to traditional service providers, outreach services are provided closer to individuals residence, are voluntary, and have fewer, if any, enforceable obligations. But this is rapidly changing. Maybe the time has come that Outreach programmes will be held to the same professional standards as conventional healthcare services.
Ethical considerations are extremely important in community interventions. Laws are only as good as the people enforcing them. We must be guided by our Ethics and bound by the Laws. A program that itself behaves unethically or allows its staff to do so is both ignoring its mission and risking its credibility and effectiveness in the community. outreach programmes, not tempered by high ethical principles are bound to fail and may lead to long- term effects which are contrary to the social benefit.
Because ethical issues are not always cut and dried, community programs should work out their own ethical guidelines and policies before questions actually arise. If you can agree on standards for primary ethical issues -- confidentiality, consent, disclosure, competence, conflict of interest, grossly unethical behavior, and the overall ethical stance and actions of the program and create policies which will help you uphold those standards, you are on your way to community respect and outstanding service delivery. Before undertaking any treatment consent of the patients should be sought. This is true even for outreach programs.
One way to think about ethical obligations of dental professionals is through a popular approach focussing on three basic principles which are to show respect for persons, avoid causing harm and act justly. These are often referred to as principlism. These principles should not be viewed as absolute but rather as important principles to respect and follow in making decisions about ethical issues.
For eg. how should a dental professional respond to a patient who requests that all his or her teeth be extracted because it would save having to brush them every day. In camps conducted by dental colleges this is frequent request. The dentist has to respect the decision of the patient, drawn from the principle of respect for persons, while at the same time honouring the commitment to avoid causing harm and doing what is in the best interest of the patient. We have to educate the patients and let them make their treatment decisions, subject to ethical and legal norms.
In the context of patient doctor relationship the doctor owes a duty to take care of the patient as much as possible. Mostly these duties are created either by a contract, tort law or criminal law. In case of contract between the doctor and the patient, failure to take proper care results in breach of contract and accordingly the doctor is tortuously liable to make good the loss or damage suffered by the patient. In some other circumstances, the so called breach of duty or failure to take care may acquire the characters of criminal negligence and on sufficient proof of the same, the doctor becomes liable for criminal punishment.
Negligence is the breach of a legal duty to care. Until the advent of consumer courts/ forums, there were hardly any cases of medical negligence. Not that Medical negligence, or Infringement of patient rights is something new, it is just that these issues were not well- defined, or methods of redressal in place. Public awareness of medical and dental negligence in India is growing. Medical negligence arises from an act or omission by a medical/dental practitioner, which no reasonably-competent and careful practitioner would have committed.
On 24th December, 1986, the Government of India, to safeguard the interest of the consumer, enacted a comprehensive legislation, “The Consumer Protection Act, 1986” referred to as “The Act”. It was later amended on March 15, 2003. It was an act to provide better protection of the interests of the consumers and for that purpose to make provisions for establishment of consumer councils and other authorities for the settlement of consumers dispute and for matters connected there with. Consumer, in the medical and dental profession, is a patient who pays to get services of doctor /hospital, any person who pays for the patient, Legal heirs /representatives of such patients or Spouse, parents and children of the patient.
Service rendered at a nongovernment hospital where no charge whatsoever is made from any person availing the service and all patients (rich and poor) are given free service is outside the purview of the expression service as deï¬ÂÂned in Section 2(1) (o) of the Consumer Protection Act. But is it enough that the Law does not scrutinize us? Is avoiding Legal persecution the only goal? We must be driven by our ethics, which define us as Individuals. Outreach programmes may not be viewed differently in the eyes of the Law, but as moral citizens, we must take even greater care that patients’ rights or indeed, their sentiments, are well looked after.
If the service provided is categorized as free at a hospital/institutional policy, the patient cannot be considered to be a consumer and cannot take recourse of the CPA for addressing grievances. Doctors are not liable for their services individually or vicariously if they do not charge fees.
On the other hand, where some or several services in a hospital are rendered for a fee, the patient is considered to be a consumer and can seek refuge in the CPA. Civil liability extends both to negligence in diagnosis and in respect of treatment. The Supreme Court’s view is debatable since hospitals may render some forms of services free for reasons other than the inability of a patient to pay, e.g., a particular service may be made available free on account of it incurring minimal or no material cost.
More importantly, it is questionable as to why the CPA itself excludes services rendered free outside of its purview, considering that socially and economically backward segments of society would normally avail such beneï¬ÂÂts, and these segments probably require the greatest protection. Outreach Programmes, whose primary goal is to persuade patients to visit the Parent Institution, where they maybe subjected to paid, or even experimental treatment, are an example of the most Unethical of practices.
The foremost question which comes to the mind of the doctors is that why does the medical profession need to be included in the Consumer Protection Act? This necessity arose because the existing laws of the land which provide for action in cases of medical negligence under the Law of Tort and Indian Penal Code have some well documented problems. These include the following: Delay, which, in medical negligence cases, tends to be greater., The cost of bringing an action, which is notoriously high in relation to the sums recovered in damages. limited access to the courts. Hence necessity to provide for an alternate system which would be easily accessible, speed and cheap, gave birth to the Consumer Protection Act.
Though outreach programs where we strive to provide free health benefits to the society does not fall within the umbrella of Consumer Protection Act. May be this is a positive aspect but all the same there should be provisions where patients who have suffered any kind of trauma at the hands of medical practitioners in the name of charity can go and complain. Hospitals or any organization taking part in the outreach program can be charged with negligence for transmission of infection including HIV, HBsAg, etc. if any patient develops such infection during the course of treatment and it is proved that the same has occurred on account of lapse on part of the doctors at the outreach program.
Many outreach programs are undertaken for research purposes and ethical problems continue in health research. In particular, a focus on individual ethics has left some communities vulnerable to risks such as research conducted to advance academic careers at the expense of communities; wasting resources by selecting community-inappropriate methodologies; communities feeling over researched, coerced, or misled researchers stigmatizing communities by releasing sensitive data without prior consultation; and communities feeling further marginalized by research.
Finally, a particularly damaging effect of traditional research is that researchers often do not give back to communities. Most egregiously, ï¬ÂÂndings are not shared with community members. More commonly, researchers do little to build capacity within communities. Some scholars have referred to this phenomenon as” helicopter research” a term derived from the practice of researchers flying into and out of First Nations_ communities—arriving with surveys, taking data, and giving little, if anything, back. 8
Health researchers who want to conduct research in communities should ï¬ÂÂrst create an active partnership with community members. This partnership should include discussion of the need for the research, processes for protection from harms, plans for dissemination of results in ways that are meaningful to the communities, and plans for the community to beneï¬ÂÂt from the research. Health researchers should be prepared to target their research to topics that are a priority for these communities, or be prepared to justify the focus of their research so that it is acceptable to the communities.
Mistakes occur in every profession, as they do in life. It is probably every individual’s duty to avoid errors and foresee the potential for mistake but, on occasions, it simply may become unavoidable. Unfortunately, in the health profession mistakes could result in serious consequences for the patient and, in turn, lead to the doctor/dentist being penalised.
The dentist has a duty to warn the patient of risks inherent in the treatment procedure. Following examination, the dentist should carefully decide what line of treatment to adopt. It may be unwise for a practitioner to state that she/he will perform a cure or undertake to use the highest possible degree of skill. A dentist who has acted in accordance with a practice accepted as proper by a reasonable body of practitioners cannot be considered negligent merely because there is a body of opinion that takes a contrary view.
While desirable for a dentist to possess the highest made answerable degree of skills, she/he need not possess such skills - it is sufficient that the practitioner exercises the ordinary skill of an ordinary competent person exercising that particular art and science. Hence, in case of health professionals, negligence means failure to act in accordance with the standards of a reasonably competent health professional of the same ï¬ÂÂeld.
Until the advent of consumer courts/ forums, there were hardly any cases of medical negligence. Not that Medical negligence, or Infringement of patient rights is something new, it is just that these issues were not well- defined, or methods of redressal in place. Public awareness of medical and dental negligence in India is growing. Medical negligence arises from an act or omission by a medical/dental practitioner, which no reasonably-competent and careful practitioner would have committed.
Though outreach programs where we strive to provide free health benefits to the society does not fall within the umbrella of Consumer Protection Act. May be this is a positive aspect but all the same there should be provisions where patients who have suffered any kind of trauma at the hands of medical practitioners in the name of charity can go and complain. Hospitals or any organization taking part in the outreach program can be charged with negligence for transmission of infection including HIV, HBsAg, etc. if any patient develops such infection during the course of treatment and it is proved that the same has occurred on account of lapse on part of the doctors at the outreach program.
In summation, the potential for civil lawsuits against dentists is very real. Aggrieved patients can seek redress in the CPA when negligence exists on part of the dentist. This constitutes civil liability and can result in monetary compensation to the patient, the consumer, for deï¬ÂÂcient services of the dentist. However, the onus is on the patient to prove that the doctor was negligent and that the injury was a consequence of the doctor’s negligence.
The potential for criminal liability of dentists is relatively low - in the event of death occurring during the course of dental treatment, proof of gross negligence alone will hold against the dental practitioner. Nevertheless, even in the absence of such proof, the dentist can still be held accountable in civil law under the CPA and is liable to pay compensation.
Public awareness of medical and dental negligence in India is growing. Hospital managements are increasingly facing complaints regarding facilities, standards of treatment and correctness of diagnostic methods. Therefore we need to update our understanding on Consumer Protection Act and its amendments to be on a legally safer side. May be the most apt conclusion would be beware or be aware.
REFERENCES
- Odom JG. Recognizing and resolving ethical dilemmas in dentistry. Med Law 1985;4: 543-549.
- Beauchamp TL, Walters L, eds. Contemporary Issues in Bioethics. 3rd ed. Belmont, Calif: Wadsworth; 1982:655.
- Odom JG. The status of dental ethics instruction. J Dent Educ 1988;52:306-308. 10. Jong A, Heine CS.
- The teaching of ethics in the dental hygiene curriculum. J Dent Educ 1982; 46:699-702.
- Reisine S. A path analysis of the utilization of dental services. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 1987;15: 119-24
- Nanda Kishor KM. Public health implications of oral health -inequity in India. J Adv Dent Res 2010;I
- Pizzaro V, Ferrer M. The utilization of dental care services according to health insurance coverage in catalonia spain. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 2009;37:78-84.
- Flicker S, travers R, Guta A,esearch: recommendations for Institutional Review Boards . Journal of Urban Health 2007; 84 (4): 478-493
Disclaimer from Guident
The views and opinions expressed in articles published in Guident are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the editors, the editorial board or the publisher, Ivory India. Guident does not endorse any product, technique or treatment described. Clinical content is intended for qualified dental and medical professionals and is not a substitute for individual clinical judgement. Guident, its editors and the publisher accept no liability for any consequence arising from the use of information published in the journal.
How to cite this article
Dr. Himanshu Aeran, Dr. Sujata Saxena, Dr. Gagan Sharma Department of Prosthodontics. Ethics in Dental Outreach Programs-Need of the Day in Civilized Life, Law Floats in a Sea of Ethics-Earl Warren. Guident. 2015 Dec;9(1). Available from: https://ivoryindia.in/articles/general/ethics-in-dental-outreach-programs-need-of-the-day-in-civilized-life-law-floats-in-a-sea-of-ethics-earl-warren.html






