Us E of Ha Ndheld Cellular Phone and Risk of Pa Rotid Gland Tumor
Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Pathology, Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Pathology, Department of Prosthodontics, Modern Dental College and Research Centre Airport road, Gandhi Nagar INDORE (MP), India
Abstract
The mobile technology has emerged into our world rapidly and meets the needs of fast paced modern societies. Hand held mobile phones are definitely the most convenient and efficient communication tool for work and social life. As the prevalence of cellular phone use has increased there have been concerns about the potential carcinogenic effects of exposure to electromagnetic fields (EMF) that are emitted by cellular phones. Although numerous epidemiological studies have examined and focused an association of cellular phone use and risk of tumors such as meningioma, glioma, acoustic neuroma, pituitary neuroma, childhood leukemia etc, currently a vague idea of harmful radiation of cellular phone and adjacent parotid gland have emerged. We have made an attempt to review the data regarding the possible hazardous effects of EMF emitted through cellular phone and parotid gland and throw some light on the less dominant sides of the subjects.
Key words – cellular phone, parotid tumors, electromagnetic radiation
INTRODUCTION
Exposure to electric and magnetic fields (EMF) emanating from handheld mobile phones are ubiquitous part of modern life. Initially it was not very obvious that these radiations have sufficient energy to damage DNA directly and are capable of initiating cancers. But recently concern about a possible danger has risen(1). Since then, burgeoning epidemiologic efforts made by various investigators corroborated the association of cellular phone and increased risk of intracranial tumors such as meningioma, glioma, acoustic neuroma, pituitary tumors, childhood leukemia, lymphomas, breast cancer, neurodegenerative disorders, cardiovascular diseases, depression etc. Wertheimer & Leeper reported moderate increase in the incidence of brain tumors, lymphoma & childhood leukemia on exposure to EMF (2) (3) (4). Also Milhams letter to the New England journal of Medicine have suggested a possible increase in deaths from leukemia among electric workers(5).
Recently few studies have made an attempt to correlate relationship of exposure to radiofrequency fields from cellular phones and epithelial gland malignancy such as parotid gland malignancy etc.(4, 1)
CELLULAR PHONE & SALIVA
Saliva is a unique & diagnostic fluid(6). Saliva is predominantly derived from parotid submandibular & sublingual glands. Salivary secretion is regulated by a reflex arch comprising afferent receptors & nerves carrying impulse induced by actions on gustation & mastication a central connection (salivation center) & an efferent part consisting of parasympathetic & sympathetic autonomic nerve bundles that separately innervate the gland. Saliva consists of 99% of water & less than 1% solids, mostly proteins & salts(7).
Recently an intriguing observation was reported that parasympathetic tone increases while sympathetic tone decreases during MPH (mobile phone) use, resulting in changes in salivary secretion & protein concentration(8).
Heavy users (group 1) are those who use their phones for more than 2 hours per day on an average. It has been found that heavy users showed 26% more parotid salivation on the dominant side compared to non dominant side(9).
CELLULAR PHONE, RADIOFREQUENCY RADIATION AND PAROTID GLAND TUMORS
Cellular phone transmits and receives radiation mainly in the frequency range of 800-1800 MHz(10)(4). Operation of mobile phone is based on electromagnetic waves specially radiofrequency radiations and microwaves. The radiation emitted is non-ionizing. Rate of exposure is defined as the rate of radiofrequency energy absorption in a weight or mass unit of biologic body. It is measured as specific absorption rate (SAR) and expressed in watts per kilogram (w/Kg)(8). In particular, head and hands have most contact with cellular phones and they absorb approximately 40% of the electromagnetic energy from cellular phones. Moreover, electromagnetic radiation decreases with distance from the source and it is well established that the parotid gland absorbs significant microwave energy from cellular phones. This absorbed energy may be associated with and/or non thermal effects(4) (11).
Heating of biological tissue is a result of microwave energy absorption by the water content of the tissue. Heating of the cells & tissues from radiofrequency exposure might have benign or adverse biologic effects. These effects reflect an imbalance in the amount of heat built up in the body & the effectiveness of mechanisms to remove it, can also be due to either elevated temperatures or increased physiologic strain from an attempt to remove heat. The sensitivity of different tissue & cells to thermal damage from both localized & whole body heating varies. International standards are designed to limit that temperature rises in tissue to less than 1° c(12) (1). The CNS, testis & lens of the eye seem to be particularly sensitive, the last due to limited capacity to dissipate heat rather than a greater sensitivity of its cells to heat induced damage. Laboratory studies suggest that adverse biologic effects can be caused by rise in temperature in tissue that exceeds 1 degree above their normal temperature (Goldstein et al 2003). In addition to absolute increase in temperature, duration of heating & thermoregulatory capacity of the body are important determinants of harmful levels of tissue heating(13). Enriched capillary bed adjacent to the parotid glands results in an increase of perfusion of blood vessels leading to increase in salivary flow rate. Horowitz and Soskolne (1978), David et al (2008) postulated that heat acclimation to the biological tissues for more than 28 days changes the ratio of weight to size in salivary gland and secretory parenchymal tissue expansion resulting in increase in salivary flow rate by at least 2.5 folds. However, Burlage (2005) et al reported no significant difference in parotid salivary flow rate(8).
Nationwide INTERPHONE study (2008) evaluated the possible adverse effects of cellular phone and parotid gland tumors. The study defined –
“Regular users”- as making or receiving more than one call per week for at least 6 months.
Ipsilateral Exposure – as the phone use on the same side as the tumor
Contra lateral exposure – as phone use on the opposite side(14)(15).
The study showed significantly elevated odds ratios for ipsilateral regular use for 5 to 10 years suggesting definite dose-response association. Nevertheless, three earlier reports which probably had no long term data concluded that there was no elevated risk of parotid gland tumor from cellular phone use(4),(14). [ Auvinen 2002,Hardell 2004,Lonn 2006,Sadetzki 2008 ] .These and few other studies concluded that the electromagnetic fields emitted from cellular phones do not have energy to break chemical bonds or damage DNA and hence unlikely to act in the initiation of tumor. If at all radiofrequency radiation acts as a tumor promoter, a clinical effect could be expected more rapidly(14). Thus there is no direct link between RF(radiofrequency) exposure & genotoxic effects such as DNA mutations, DNA strand breaks or other genetic lesions(13). The national data quote that the stray low frequency electromagnetic fields (up to 50-60 Hz) associated with the generation; distribution & use of electricity in home & office are no significant cause of cancer(16).Conversely Chinese researchers and Israeli population has documented highest rates of cancer ever in cell phone study. They have found that long term, heavy users have rates of malignant parotid gland tumors especially mucoepidermoid carcinoma 7 to 13 times higher than might otherwise be expected(17). Few researchers quote that excessive mobile phone use results in functional and volumetric changes in parotid gland due to radiofrequency radiation and heat generation leading to elevated risk of parotid gland tumor (9).
Dr Siegal Sadetzki, the principal investigator of a 2008 study, testified at a V. S. Senate hearing that cell phones were identified as a contributor to salivary gland tumors. The report states that your risk of getting a parotid tumor on the same side that you use for listening to the mobile phone increased by-
- 34% if you are a regular cell phone user & have used mobile phone for 5 yrs.
- 58% if you had more than about 5,500 calls in your lifetime.
- 49% if you have spoken on the phone for more than 266.3 hrs during your life time(18).
During this review we have observed that those studies that could not correlate the association of cellular phone use and parotid gland tumor had the following limitations—
1. The appropriate exposure system was unknown and there were no substantiated biological mechanisms or animal models from which to impute it(4).
2. Amount of exposure is extremely complex, imperceptible, vary from person to person, place to place and hence difficult to account (1).
3. Relatively small size of sample
4. Relatively short latency periods were studied. Increased risk of malignancy was found only among those who were heavy users of mobile for more than 10 years(14).
It is important to realize that as long as your cell phone is on, it emits radiation intermittently even when you are not actually making a call. So carrying a cell phone on your body may be for more than 15hrs or so & keeping your body near to the continuous radiation exposure is actually hazardous to health.(18)
On May 31, 2011 the World Health Organization (WHO) International agency for Research on cancer (IARC) issued a report admitting cell phones might indeed cause cancer, classifying radiofrequency electromagnetic fields as “Possibly Carcinogenic to humans” (Class IIB). The conclusion means that there could be some risk & therefore we need to keep a close watch for a link between cell phone & cancer risks till further research is explored(18).
Experts in the area of biological effects of EMF believe there’s no doubt that cell phones & related gadgets are capable of causing not only cancers but contributing to a wide variety of other conditions like depression, headache, diabetes, heart irregularities, impaired fertility etc. Martin Blank, explained that DNA with its ‘Coil of Coils’ structure is especially vulnerable to EMF of all kinds. DNA possess two structural characteristics of fractal antennas, electronic conduction & self symmetry which contribute to greater reactivity of DNA to EMF that other tissues making long term consequences of repeated microwave exposure to our genetic materials is of greater concern(18).
Based on the largest group of benign parotid gland tumor patients reported to date, a number of complementary analyses suggest a positive association between cellular phone use and PGTs
Results from a single epidemiologic study do not, however, form a strong enough basis to assume causality and additional investigations of this association, with longer latency periods and large numbers of heavy users, are needed to confirm. Until more evidence becomes available, we believe that the precautionary approach currently adopted by most scientific committees and applied by many governments should continue to be used.
REFERENCE
- Ahlbom, E Cardis, A Green, M Linet, D Savitz and A Swerdlow (2001) Review of the epiderminologic literature on EMF and health. Environmental Health Perspectives 109, 911-933.
- PK Verkasalo, E Pukkala, MY Hongisto, JE Valjus, PJ Jarvinen, KV Heikkila, M Koskenvuo (1993) Risk of cancer in Finish children living close to power lines. BMJ 307, 895-899.
- J Schuz, JP Grigat, K Brinkmann and J Michaelis (2001) Childhood acute leukaemia and residential 16.7 Hz magnetic fields in Germany. British Journal of Cancer 84(5), 697-699.
- Y. Duan, HZ Zhang, RF Bu (2011) Correlation between cellular phone use and epithelial parotid gland malignancies. Int. J. Oral Maxillofac. Surg. doi:10.1016/j.ijom.2011.03.007,available online at http:// www.sciencedirect.com
- DP Loomis, DA Savitz (1990) Mortality from brain cancer and leukaemia among electrical workers. British Journal of Industrial Medicine 47,633-638.
- Streckfus CF, Bigler LR. Saliva as a diagnostic fluid. Oral Disease 2002 (8):69-76.
- AM Pedersen, A Bardow, S Beier Jensen, BN auntofte (2002) Saliva and gastrointestinal functions of taste, mastication swallowing and digestion. Oral Diseases 8,117-12 9.
- O Goldwein, DJ Aframian (2010) The influence of handheld mobile phones on human parotid gland secretion. Oral Disease 16, 146-150.
- Rob Goszkowski (2012) Heavy cell phone use increases the rate of saliva and flow, as well as the volume of parotid glands.OOO 114,200-206.
- Myung SK et al (2009) Mobile phone use and risk of tumours-A Meta – Analysis. J of clinical Oncology 27(33), 5565-5572.
- http// e360.yale.edu/feature/are_cell_phones_safe_the_verdict
- Wood AW (2006) How dangerous are mobile phones, transmission masts and electricity pylons? Arch Dis Child 91(4),361-366.
- Ahlbom A (2004) Epidemiology of health effects of radiofrequency exposure. Environ Health Perspect 112(17),1741=1754.
- S Sadetzki, A Chetrit, AJ Hakaki, E Cardis, Y Deutch, S Duvdevani, A Zultani, L Novikov, L Freedman, M Wolf (2008) Cellular phone use and risk of benign and malignant parotid gland tumors – A nationwide case- control study. Am. J. Epidemiol 167(4) , 457-467.
- Czerninski Rakefet,Zini Avi,Sgan-Cohen.Risk of Parotid Malignant Tumors in Israel (1970-2006).E.J.of Epidemiology 22(9), 647-664.DOI:10.1007/s10654-007-9152-z
- Jackson JD (1992) Are the stray 60-Hz electromagnetic fields associated with the distribution and use of electric power a significant cause of cancer? Proc.Natl.Acad.Sci. 89, 3508-3510.
- file:///E:/Cellular%20phone/Microwave %20News%20%20%20Chinese%20Put%20Cancer%20of%20the%20Parotid%20Gland%20on%20Center%20Stage.htm http// microwave news.com/Duan.Zhang.html.
- http// Articles.mercola.com/…/emf_safety_tips.aspx_United states.
Disclaimer from Guident
The views and opinions expressed in articles published in Guident are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the editors, the editorial board or the publisher, Ivory India. Guident does not endorse any product, technique or treatment described. Clinical content is intended for qualified dental and medical professionals and is not a substitute for individual clinical judgement. Guident, its editors and the publisher accept no liability for any consequence arising from the use of information published in the journal.
How to cite this article
Dr. Kalpana A. Patidar, Dr. Sangeeta P. Wanjari, Dr. Atul Patidar. Us E of Ha Ndheld Cellular Phone and Risk of Pa Rotid Gland Tumor. Guident. 2013 Apr;6(6). Available from: https://ivoryindia.in/articles/general/us-e-of-ha-ndheld-cellular-phone-and-risk-of-pa-rotid-gland-tumor.html







