Tantalum Dental Implants: An Insight
K.D Dental College & Hospital, Mathura, India
Abstract
Primary implant stability is a prerequisite for achieving and maintaining osseointegration. various methods of altering implant surface characteristics have been introduced to increase bone-anchorage. Various methods used to increase osseointegration are grit-blasting, acid-etching, surface coatings, or a combination of treatments. Recently, there has been an incorporation of porous tantalum (Ta) metal into titanium dental implants with a structure and stiffness identical to trabecular bone. Porous Tantalum Trabecular Metal (PTTM) was applied to the midsection of root-form, threaded, titanium alloy dental implants to create a three-dimensional, periimplant bone ingrowth scaffold. The porosity of Trabecular Metal Material not only significantly increases the surface available for bone formation, but also allows angiogenesis and bone formation inside the pores (osseoincorporation). The purpose of this article is toillustrate the use of porous tantalum trabecular metal in implant dentistry and describes osseoincorporation.
INTRODUCTION
It is known that edentulism is a comorbidity to several systemic and oraldiseases such as osteoporosis, hypertension, atherosclerosis, diabetes, cancer, etc. Several biological changes occur after loss of natural teeth. These include reduction in masticatory efficiency, altered neuronal/physiolocal sensation, psychological effects, alveolar bone remodeling, and changes on microflora composition. Complete and partial edentulism clearly reduces mechanical chewing function and esthetics. Edentulism and its comorbidities have a bidirectional relationship, in other words, each condition worsens the other.While current treatment modalities for edentulism, such as dental implant therapy, are aimed at improving function and esthetics for patients, the systemic and oral comorbidities of edentulism, including diabetes, osteoporosis, as well as a lack of sufficient remaining alveolar bone, challenge the immediate and long-term success of dental implant therapy.
Primary implant stability is a prerequisite for achieving and maintaining osseointegration; yet, some degree of micromotion may still occur by an osseointegrated implant during functional loading. Comprehensive reviews of in vivo studies have reported that micromotion at the bone-implant interface in the range of 50 to 150 mm may adversely affect osseointegration and remodeling at bone bone-implant interface.
To eliminate the adverse effects of implant micromovements and excessive micro-strains at the bone-implant interface, various methods of altering implant surface characteristics have been introduced to increase bone-anchorage. Techniques have included grit-blasting, acid-etching, surface coatings, or a combination of treatments.
Implants with sintered bead surfaces have been conceived to advantageously tolerate micromotion because bone growth into the surface pores would resist micromovements at the bone-implant interface. However, bone growth into sintered bead and other porous surfaces has been limited by the degree of surface porosity and pore size of the coating. In addition, porous surfaces have become compromised in vivo by soft tissue encapsulation if the implant lacked adequate mechanical and/or frictional resistance to micromotion.
Recently, there has been an incorporation of porous tantalum (Ta) metal into titanium dental implants with a structure and stiffness identicalto trabecular bone.
TANTALUM
Ta is a rare, high corrosion-resistant transitional metal element with atomic number 73. The word tantalum was coined from Tantalus, a Greek mythology figure who was eternally punished to stand in a pool of water under a tree with low hanging fruit. When Tantalus reached to get the water, the water would recede. And when he reached for the fruit, the tree branch would move higher. This “tantalizing” property of Ta was seen by the early chemists when Ta was immersed in acids. Ta, they found, was highly unreactive in almost all acids, except hydrofluoric acid and acids containing fluoride and sulfur trioxide.Ta is a member of the refractory metals group, which are widely used as components in alloys.
The Swedish chemist, Anders Gustav Ekebereg, discovered Ta in 1802.Ta is extremely inert and resistant to acid corrosion. Only hydrofluoric acid and acid solutions containing fluoride and sulfur trioxide can dissolve Ta. This inertness is ideal for fabrication of orthopedic implants. The inertness and biocompatibility of Ta is a result of Ta oxides forming on the surface of Ta – comparable to titanium and its oxides. Ta has two forms of oxide, Ta pentaoxide which is more stable and Ta dioxide. Like, Titanium Tantalum is very reactive to oxygen and the oxide layer of Ta can form on the metal surface immediately after the surface is exposed to oxygen.Ta is used as electrodes for pacemakers, devices for nerve repair, radiographic markers, and cranioplasty plates.
PRODUCTION OF POROUS TANTALUM TRABECULAR METAL (PTTM)
Cobalt chromium, titanium alloys, and stainless steel have been the conventional materials used for orthopedic implants. With alterations and enhancements including surface coatings and porous designs, these materials have shown a high clinical effectiveness. Nevertheless, they still have several limitations including low volumetric porosity, relatively high modulus of elasticity and low frictional characteristics. The development of porous Ta metal has allowed for stronger,more biocompatible orthopedic, craniofacial, and dental implants. The structure of porous Ta metal affords a high volumetric porosity, a low modulus of elasticity, and relatively high frictional characteristics Even though Ta is highly biocompatible, inert, and extremely resistant to corrosion, its use in orthopedic implant devices was limited because of the difficulty in manipulating solid Ta. In his initial studies on osseointegration, Branemark identified titanium and tantalum the most suitable materials for implant manufacturing. Tantalum demonstrated a high biocompatibility and resistance to corrosion; however, the difficulty in working this material limited its useand titanium was preferred.
Replacing osseous structure traditionally uses solid materials such as titanium or porous materials such as hydroxyapatite (HA) or tricalcium phosphate (TCP). Attempts have beenmade to coat some alloys, such as chrome-cobalt or titanium alloy with HA or TCP.However, these attempts in the past failed to mimic the structure of osseous cancellous bone. Additionally, there was mechanical failure, resulting from lack of yield strength and ductility of the coating materials.
It is not until the early 1990s that PTTM was introduced PTTM, known commercially as Trabecular Metal Material is an open-cell porous biomaterial with a structure like trabecular bone by having three-dimensional dodecahedron repeats. The open-cell dodecahedron repeats are fabricated by a foam-like vitreous carbon scaffold, which forms an initial general scaffold and eventually becomes the internal skeleton of the PTTM implant device. The vitreous carbon scaffold is then placed in an air-sealed chamber. Ta coating of the scaffold is done by chemical vapor diffusion process using hydrogen and chlorine gases. The Ta is evaporated as TaCl2, and the Ta molecules are then deposited onto the scaffold. PTTM is, therefore, superior to other metal implant technologies such as titanium because it has a high degree of porosity.
The vitreous carbon skeleton comprising the trabecular framework of the implant can be altered. This means that a variety of designs of PTTM may be created, which is utilized especially in creating orthopedic implant The PTTM allows an implant surface enhancement not only for bone ongrowth but also bone ingrowth. In a study by Do-Gyoon Kim et al, investigated if a dental implant system with a midsection covered by 3-dimensionally porous tantalum material would exhibit stability comparable with a traditional threaded titanium alloy implant system and whether bone would grow into the porous section. The study concluded that implant stability did not significantly differ during 0 to 12 weeks of healing. Progressive tissue mineralization developed inside porous sections from weeks 2 to 12. Porous implants exhibited a combination of progressive osseointegration along their titanium surfaces and bone ingrowth inside their porous tantalum sections.
Also, two preclinical studies on PTTM documented bone growth inside the porous tantalum structures. In the first study, histologic analysis detected regions of contact between bone and implant increasing with time and evidence of Haversian remodeling within the pores at later stages. Mechanical tests at four weeks indicated a minimum shear fixation strength of 18.5MPa, substantially higher than that obtained with other porous materials with a lower volumetric porosity.
In the second study, 22 PTTM acetabular implants were studied in a canine model for a period of 6 months. Histology, radiography, and electron microscopy revealed stable bone-implant interfaces in all 22 implants. All histologic sectionspresented areas of bone ingrowth. The depth of bone ingrowthranged from 0.2 mm to 2 mm. The mean bone ingrowth for allsections was 16.8%. In the peripheral regions, where bone implant contact was most consistent, bone ingrowth averaged 25.1% PTTM structure allows neovascularization and new bone formation directly into the implant. This concept is known as “osseoincorporation”.
MANUFACTURING OF PTTM DENTAL IMPLANTS
The PTTM material is added to the middle section of the titanium multithreaded self-tapping endosseous dental implant. The apical and cervical sections of this PTTM-enhanced titanium dental implant retain the screw-type design with a rough surface created by grit blasting with HA or HA particles. The titanium alloy and the PTTM components of the implant are manufactured separately. The cervical portion and the middle core of the titanium alloys are milled in one piece. Similarly, the apical portion is milled separately. The PTTM sleeve, ~2 mm cylinder, is composed of 2%vitreous carbon core scaffold and 98% Ta coating. The PTTM sleeve is then placed into the middle titanium alloy core, and the core is then laser welded to the apical portion
Advantages of PTTM-enhanced titanium dental implants
ADVANTAGE OF PTM-ENHANCED TITANIUM DENTAL IMPLANTS
The PTTM-enhanced titanium dental implants theoretically provide several advantages over other implant designs. The PTTM portion of the implant has an open-cell dodecahedron repeat structure that allows for rapid endothelial budding and ingrowth through the expanded structure in response to the angiogenic and anabolic growth factor gradient produced within the scaffold by the metal surface interacting with the initial blood clot.
The dimensions of the open structure are designed to accommodate rapid endothelial neovascularization that is critical to permit subsequent osteoblast precursor recruitment and osteoblastic cell differentiation, growth, and matrix secretion. This healing granulation tissue promotes new osseous tissue formation and bone ingrowth shown to be suitable for withstanding immediate and early loading in orthopedic implants Similar to titanium, the Ta layer of PTTM, when oxidized, is highly unreactive, and therefore, biocompatible in the body. Ta does not exhibit toxicity to surrounding cells, nor does it inhibit local cell growth, that is, osseous ingrowth of surrounding bone. An in vitro study, comparing titanium, Ta and chromium in osteoblastic differentiation using human mesenchymal stem cells, suggests that tantalum has similar biocompatibility to titanium.
While titanium allows faster cell proliferation, Ta enhances osteoblastic differentiation process The trabecular structure of the porous Ta metal in PTTM enhanced titanium dental implants can also improve osseointegration simply by increasing bone-implant interface area in the three-dimensional manner promoting angiogenesis and mimicking natural osseous structure. The porous metal structure exhibited by the implants is exceedingly similar to that of natural spongy bone and appears to be one the reasons why osseous ingrowth occurs so readily. The open cell structure of PTTM is superior to other surface treatment methods that attempt to produce porosity of the implant but does not achieve complete porosity. Pore size can also be altered with PTTM to match the surrounding bone.
However, the commercially available PTTM has a standardized pore size thought to be an optimal dimension for promoting osseoincorporation. In addition to the advantage of trabecular makeup, PTTM exhibits an elastic modulus like bone and is mechanically superior to other alloys used in dental implants.PTTM allows for elastic deformation and load distribution.
Also, bone resorption is less likely since the stress is distributed throughout the structure to the surrounding bone.BraunerEdoardoet al compared osteointegration and marginal bone loss of immediately loaded tantalum trabecular metal and tapered screw-vent dental Implants, both tantalum trabecular metal and tapered screw-vent dental implants showed satisfying levels of osteointegration and marginal bone loss; however, statistical analysis revealed a value significantly lower of marginal bone loss for tantalum trabecular metal. Thus, it may be deduced that when implants are immediately loaded, the average loss of marginal bone around the tantalum trabecular metal implants is lower than that of the tapered screw-vent implants.
Finally, the PTTM enhanced titanium dental implants retain most if not all the advantages of the root-form endosseous self-tapping implants in terms of primary stability, ability to be removed and grafted when it fails, and prosthetic/ restorative simplicity. The advantages of high biocompatibility, similar porous structure to natural bone, and excellent mechanical properties of PTTM-enhanced titanium dental implants may give them an advantage over other dental implants, particularly for patients through enhancement of osseointegration, or osseoincorporation.
POTENTIAL PROBLEMS WITH PTTM-ENHANCED TITANIUM DENTAL IMPLANTS
While PTTM implants have been used widely and successfully as orthopedic implants, the application of PTTM in the oral cavity remains limited until now. The major concern for this type of implant is perhaps the uniqueness of the oral environment. Unlike most orthopedic surgical sites, the oral cavity is a complex unsterile field, which can harbor over 500 different bacterial species.
Various microorganisms live in the oral cavity. The interactions of the host tissue, saliva, and microorganisms can make it difficult to predict how PTTM implants would react to this complex environment. Tantalum is like titanium in that it is highly biocompatible and corrosion resistant, the interactions with oral fluid, oral microbes, and biofilm of the PTTM portion are not known. The concern can extend into the case of periimplantitis and how we may treat it in the case of PTTM-enhanced titanium dental implant.
It is researcher’s opinion that if the peri-implant bone loss extends into the PTTM portion of the implant, removal of the implant will be needed. Moreover, implant removal, grafting and subsequently a new implant placement may be indicated as a treatment of choice for peri-implantitis for this type of implants. Finally, a mechanical concern has been raised around PTTM-enhanced titanium dental implants. Due to implant manufacturing, the connection between the relatively small titanium core/ PTTM in the middle third portion and the apical titanium portion may be prone to fracture. These implants are however recommended for bone that are relatively soft (type 3 or 4). The fracture of implants during insertion may therefore not be a major issue in soft bone.
CONCLUSION
Development of PTTM-enhanced titanium dental implants combined conventional titanium implant design and instrumentation with PTTM technology. This theoretically allows for true enhancement of osseointegration in a three-dimensional manner, which may be a major break-through compared with the current focus on titanium implant surface technologies. Based on clinical studies, this type of implant may be indicated in poor healing situations, immediate/early loading of implants, and missing osseous structure requiring simultaneous implant placement and bone grafting. The uniqueness of the oral cavity, the host-oral microbial interaction, is a concern. The extent and aggression of peri-implantitis in this type of implant is not known. Prospective longitudinal studies are clearly needed, as well as a focus on biomaterial research in humans in the oral cavity.
REFERENCES
- SompopBencharit, Warren C. Byrd, Sandra Altarawneh, Bashir Hosseini, Austin Leong, Glenn Reside, Thiago Morelli, Steven OffenbacherDevelopment and Applications of Porous Tantalum Trabecular Metal-Enhanced Titanium Dental Implants. Clinical Implant Dentistry and Related Research, Volume 16, Number 6, 2014
- Do-Gyoon Kim, Sarandeep S. Huja, Boon Ching Tee, Peter E. Larsen, Kelly S. Kennedy, Hua-Hong Chien, JinWhan Lee, and Hai Bo Wen, Bone Ingrowth and Initial Stability of Titanium and Porous Tantalum Dental Implants: A Pilot Canine Study. Implant dentistry; volume 22, number 4 2013
- BraunerEdoardo, Jamshir Sara, Di Carlo Stefano, Pagnoni Mario, Guarino Giorgio, Pompa Giorgio, Immediate Implant Loading: A Comparison of Trabecular Metal andTapered Screw-Vent Dental Implants.OHDM- Vol. 14- No.2-April, 2015
- SompopBencharit, Warren C. Byrd, Bashir Hosseini, Immediate placement of a porous-tantalum, trabecular metal-enhanced titanium dental implant with demineralized bone matrix into a socket with deficient buccal bone: A clinical report; J Prosthet Dent. 2015 Apr; 113(4): 262–269.
- Levine B, Della Valle DJ, Jacobs JJ. Applications of porous tantalum in total hip arthroplasty. J Am AcadOrthop Surg. 2006; 14:646–655.
- Bobyn JD, Stackpool GJ, Hacking SA, Tanzer M, Krygier J. Characteristics of bone ingrowth and interface mechanics of a new porous tantalum biomaterial. J Bone Joint Surg Br. 1999; 81: 907–914.
- Bobyn JD, TohKK,Hacking SA, Tanzer M, Krygier JJ. Tissue response to porous tantalum acetabular cups: a canine model.J Arthroplasty. 1999; 14: 347–354.
- Schlee M1, van der Schoor WP, van der Schoor AR. Immediate Loading of Trabecular Metal-Enhanced Titanium Dental Implants: Interim Results from an International Proof-of-Principle Study. Clin Implant Dent Relat Res. 2013 Jul 30.
Disclaimer from Guident
The views and opinions expressed in articles published in Guident are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the editors, the editorial board or the publisher, Ivory India. Guident does not endorse any product, technique or treatment described. Clinical content is intended for qualified dental and medical professionals and is not a substitute for individual clinical judgement. Guident, its editors and the publisher accept no liability for any consequence arising from the use of information published in the journal.
How to cite this article
Dr. Neelansh Sikri, Dr. Manpreet Kaur and Dr. Manesh Lahori Department of Prosthodontics. Tantalum Dental Implants: An Insight. Guident. 2016 Oct;9(11). Available from: https://ivoryindia.in/articles/implantology/tantalum-dental-implants-an-insight.html





