Open AccessPeer ReviewedPublished Monthly Since 2007 Vol. 19, Issue 12 · November 2026Media Kitinfo@guident.net

CBCT in Orthodontics: To Scan or Not to Scanmedico- Legal Implications: A Review

  • Dr. Shubhangi ManiProfessor
  • Dr. N. G. ToshniwalProfessor & Head
  • Dr. Apoorva TondeP.G. Student

Department of Orthodontics, Rural Dental College, PIMS (DU), Loni. Maharashtra

Guident · Volume 17, Issue 11 (October 2024)Published October 202415 min read2 figures

ABSTRACT

The use of cone beam computed tomography (CBCT) in orthodontics has been around since the early 2000s. The article explores how the standard of care is determined and where practitioners can find guidance when a new technology arises. This article concludes by examining ethical and regulatory issues related to the clinical use of CBCT, which can help an orthodontist determine whether a scan for a patient should be routinely used and if it should be indicated.

Keywords- CBCT, orthodontist, legal, scan, practice.

INTRODUCTION

Clinical evidence, patient preferences—which may include family, social, and cultural considerations, religious beliefs, and ability to pay, among others—and the standard of care all must be taken into account when deciding whether or not to perform a specific diagnostic or treatment procedure on a specific patient. The use of cone beam computed tomography (CBCT) in orthodontics has been around since the early 2000s. However, its use is still relatively new and not yet considered standard practice by most practitioners. There are varying opinions on its usefulness, with some advocating for its use on every patient while others believe it has limited value. The question of whether “to scan or not” is currently a pressing issue for all orthodontists. Although selection criteria based on evidence are being developed and will continue to evolve, the answer to this question is currently in a state of flux and largely unanswerable. While selection criteria are being developed, there is no clear answer currently. It is important to note that not every patient needs to be scanned, but some may benefit from the information provided. [Fig.1]

Clinical figure

Fig.1. Applications of CBCT

When an orthodontist considers whether to take a CBCT scan on a patient, they must consider the standard of care. This article does not express any opinions on whether or when a CBCT scan is necessary for orthodontic patients. Instead, it explores how the standard of care is determined and where practitioners can find guidance when a new technology arises. Additionally, it discusses what a "reasonably prudent" practitioner should do when there is no clearly defined standard. The article concludes by examining ethical and regulatory issues related to the clinical use of CBCT, which can help an orthodontist determine whether a CBCT scan is becoming the standard of care and if they should order a scan for a patient.

This review article focuses on one aspect of the legal concerns associated with the use of CBCT in clinical settings: the decision to scan a patient. However, there are many other legal and medico-legal issues to consider when using CBCT, including purchasing and owning a CBCT machine (such as the legal implications of buying one in partnership with a physician) and the responsibility of interpreting the images. There are also questions about where a radiologist interpreting the images needs to be licensed if the clinician sends a CBCT scan to an out-of-state radiologist. Additionally, dentists, including orthodontists, may seek to limit their liability for reading CBCT scans, especially if they interpret the images themselves, by asking patients to sign a waiver of liability. It is also important to consider whether a dentist's malpractice insurance will cover them if they own a machine and take CBCT scans, interpreting them for other dentists.

STANDARD OF CARE:

Why is the standard of care relevant or important?

In the healthcare field, the standard of care plays a crucial role in guiding medical professionals when it comes to treatment and diagnostic procedures for their patients. It is not only important in malpractice cases, but also in daily practice, as it helps providers determine the right course of action and facilitates informed consent discussions. Without this standard, doctors would have a hard time deciding on the most suitable diagnostic and treatment options for their patients. Additionally, the standard of care has an impact on insurance coverage for medical expenses, which is significant for both patients and providers.

What is the process for a procedure to become the standard of care?

It is common for medical professionals to mistakenly assume that the standard of care is a legal requirement established by the court or their malpractice insurance. In this article, we will explore the concept of the standard of care by addressing a few key questions. Who determines the standard of care? And how can an orthodontist determine if a procedure, such as CBCT, is considered standard. Additionally, no private organization or group has the legal authority to establish the standard of care or create a formal process for introducing new procedures. In the past, it was proposed that the National Center for Health Care Technology (NCHCT) could take on a role similar to the FDA for medical procedures.

After going through an investigational phase, a medical procedure may either be widely accepted and become the standard of care or fall into disuse. The decision to make a procedure a part of regular medical care may come from respected institutions offering it or from the endorsement of highly regarded practitioners. Additionally, the cost of a procedure may be covered by third-party payers such as Medicare or Medicaid, which can lead to it becoming a widely accepted standard of care. Private payers may also choose to cover a procedure if Medicare and Medicaid do so.

Keeton and Associates (1984) stated, "It is not the midpoint but the minimal common skill," in elucidating the court's intention. The Brune court added the phrase "Taking into account the advances in the profession" to its enunciated standard. The latter is a statement that says you can't always do things the way you were taught to—you have to stay up with the times, which is extremely pertinent to the use of CBCT in orthodontics.

NEW PROCEDURES

Practice parameters

When it comes to new technologies like CBCT, professional guidelines known as practice parameters are especially important to consider. These guidelines can take on even greater significance when there is little evidence of what the "average qualified practitioner" is doing. Currently, some orthodontists take CBCT scans on all or just about all patients, while others use them rarely. This variability in usage is consistent with findings for even well-established diagnostic and treatment methods, which also show significant variation in their use within the same geographic area.

The orthodontist is left wondering what exactly the standard of care is because it is based on what the typical trained practitioner does. Ironically, this predicament is partially the profession's fault because it accepts the court's ideas that the standard should be defined by what the average trained practitioner does rather than by some other, perhaps more objective and measurable standard. In addition to this drawback for practitioners, the standard also has the disadvantage of being so vague and varied as to provide juries broad discretion in imposing culpability (Havighurst, 1991). Regarding whether and how much they do, different jurisdictions admit practising parameters as evidence in different ways.

Some courts have used them as "two-way streets," allowing both the plaintiff and the defendant to utilize them, while others are more inclined to let the plaintiff use them as swords rather than the defendant as a shield (Hyams et al., 1996). In the latter scenario, if a practitioner violates the rules, the plaintiff may present that evidence to the jury, but the practitioner may not be able to argue that he or she complied with the recommendations. Therefore, a court may permit a violation of the rules to be used as all or part of the evidence of negligence. If it adheres to the earlier norm, the plaintiff's demonstration that the practitioner violated the rules would be conclusive.

This specifically refers to who and what organisations are involved in creating the rules and whose input they are receiving. Two published sets of dental guidelines provide an example of the importance of the process in ensuring that the guidelines are accepted by practitioners. An oral surgeon harshly attacked the American Academy of Oral and Maxillofacial Radiology's (AAOMR; Tyndall & Brooks, 2000) unilateral position paper on the necessity of pre-operative cone beam scanning prior to implant placement (Larson, 2001). A study like this will "find its way to an enhanced standing with relation to creating a standard of care," according to the concern expressed in the criticism, which was based on a variety of factors.

Guidelines for the use of CBCT in orthodontics were being developed by the AAOMR and the American Association of Orthodontists (AAO). The AAOMR accepted a set of guidelines that the working group members from each organisation agreed upon, but the AAO did not accept them, as was stated at the AAOMR's annual meeting in Savannah, Georgia, in November 2012. Consequently, orthodontists regrettably lack a set of rules to refer to at this time. This setback should motivate working orthodontists to step up their efforts to develop practice guidelines. A group that represents the members it seeks to influence, in this case the AAO, is best suited to carry out this task.

WHAT TO DO? PRACTICAL CONSIDERATIONS-

What should an orthodontist do after all is said and done? When CBCT has been in use for a while, it will be clear what the right indications are; in the meantime, practitioners can ask other practitioners what they do, go to continuing education classes, listen to specialists, and read publications to learn more. Practice criteria, if and when they become accessible, would be beneficial in the absence of evidence regarding what the typically qualified practitioner is doing, a scenario encountered by orthodontists in the immediate to short term. A legal ruling must be made before determining how much courts will abide by any guidelines that may be issued.

Other factors influence the adoption of technologies and an orthodontist's decision on whether to adopt a new one. Although generally of enormous benefit to society, the commercial side of dentistry also acts as a motivator for practitioners to adopt new technologies even if they have not been demonstrated to be clinically or financially advantageous, just because other dentists have done so. The practitioners believe that if they do not adapt the technology, patients would believe that they are out of touch, which is a flaw in the business element of dentistry.

When it comes to the malpractice system, utilizing technology is less likely to lead to a lawsuit compared to not using it. This is why there is a tendency to use CBCT and other technologies, as it is driven in part by the medico-legal climate. However, orthodontists should also be cautious before using CBCT routinely, as the same medico-legal system has certain elements that must be considered.

Practitioners who insist that all orthodontic patients should get a CBCT because it may show undiagnosed pathology, even that unrelated to orthodontic diagnosis and treatment, are conflating a diagnostic test with a screening procedure. As defined by Grimes and Schulz (2002), screening is testing seemingly healthy people to find those at increased risk of having a disease or disorder. A diagnostic test is utilized to verify a suspected medical condition based on the signs and symptoms presented by a patient. [Fig.2.]

Clinical figure

Fig.2. A small subset of the possible images that can be assembled from a single volumetric cone beam X-ray data

An orthodontist who fails to take a CBCT and who faces legal action for that reason may find a safe harbour if he or she follows any established guidelines when they do not call for a CBCT in the particular patient’s circumstances. This may change in the future based on what the "average qualified orthodontist" does, but for the time being, the best recommendation is to abide by the rules if and when they are published. Of course, one almost certain way for an orthodontist who scans every patient to avoid legal liability for reading a scan is to engage the services of a medical or oral and maxillofacial radiologist to report on each scan.

Ethical concerns One ethical issue is the financial incentive that the acquisition of a CBCT machine creates for a practitioner. In this regard, the history of CBCT in implant dentistry is instructive. There have been and still are dentists who perform CBCT scans on each patient's implant sites. While some of them have their own CBCT machines nearly from the first implant they placed, others direct patients to imaging facilities.

These dentists have been consistent in their practice; for every implant placed, the patient gets a CBCT scan or, prior to the availability of CBCT, a medical CT scan. Other implant dentists have picked and chose which patients they send to imaging facilities for CBCT or medical scans. They believe that a CBCT is only necessary for a proposed implant in a very tiny percentage of situations. Later on, some of these dentists bought CBCT scanners. From the day they installed the machine, they suddenly discovered that every implant patient needed a CBCT scan.

Research has consistently shown that doctors who own their own X-ray equipment and can refer patients for radiologic procedures tend to use it more frequently than those who refer their patients to other facilities. This trend has also been observed among dentists who perform implant imaging. To maintain credibility, it is important for the orthodontic profession to be aware of this trend occurring within their specialty. Additionally, there are ethical and practical concerns regarding whether CBCT (cone beam computed tomography) improves orthodontic treatment outcomes and who is best equipped to evaluate them. While not every treatment needs to be evaluated in a randomized control trial, CBCT and orthodontics require such studies for accurate evaluation.

In order to determine whether CBCT should be the standard of care and for which patients, a formal clinical trial should be conducted. This approach would be more acceptable to patients and regulatory authorities than anything less. While CBCT is still in its early stages in orthodontics, there are certain clinical situations where most practitioners would agree that its use is justified. However, beyond these limited indications, the use of CBCT on every patient should await appropriate evidence based on sound research. Unless CBCT can produce better results and more accurate diagnoses, it is difficult to justify its routine use in orthodontics from both ethical and practical perspectives. To determine who is best positioned to determine the efficacy of CBCT in orthodontics, it is worth examining the literature related to surgery in patients with Down Syndrome.

Patients with Down Syndrome may experience functional problems that require surgery on their faces, but most of the procedures are done for cosmetic reasons. This is similar to orthodontic treatment, which is also often sought for cosmetic purposes. However, the success of cosmetic treatment is subjective. To illustrate this point, studies on plastic surgery for patients with Down Syndrome show that while there is no definitive result, there is a strong trend in which surgeons believe the surgery has greater benefits than parents.

According to studies, individuals who are not related to the child, such as teachers and friends, are less likely to believe that surgery provides significant benefits (Pueschel et al., 1986). In another study, parents of children who underwent surgery did not report much evidence of positive impacts on their children's physical, personal, and social functioning compared to parents of children who did not undergo surgery (Kravetz et al., 1992). Therefore, the decision of whether to opt for a CBCT scan, considering the financial cost and radiation burden, should be made by the patients or their parents. It is important to consider regulatory and legal concerns as the use of CBCT scans on every orthodontic patient may lead to state or federal regulations on their use, particularly with respect to children, and possibly on the purchase and ownership of machines.

Therefore, it is important for the profession to use CBCT judiciously to maintain independence and avoid governmental interference. Additionally, it is useful to look at how professional organizations in other countries are approaching CBCT use in orthodontics. For example, the British Orthodontic Society recommends caution when using CBCT and calls for more research, as current literature advocating its routine use is primarily anecdotal.

CONCLUSION

At present, CBCT is not considered the standard of care for orthodontics. It would be advantageous for the AAO to establish practice criteria, either independently or in collaboration with the AAOMR, to assist orthodontists in making decisions when evidence is lacking. By conducting clinical trials that compare the outcomes of orthodontic treatment between patients diagnosed with CBCT and those diagnosed with traditional orthodontic radiographs, the profession can better determine whether CBCT should be routinely used in orthodontics. Since it is highly unlikely that an orthodontist who regularly uses CBCT will face malpractice charges, their decision to use it ultimately depends on their personal belief that it benefits their patients.

REFERENCES

  1. Friedland, B. (2014). To Scan or Not to Scan: Medico-Legal Implications. In Cone Beam Computed Tomography in Orthodontics: Indications, Insights, and Innovations, S.D. Kapila (Ed.).
  2. Baumrind, S., Carlson, S., Beers, A., et al. (2003) Using three-dimensional imaging to assess treatment outcomes in orthodontics: a progress report from the University of the Pacific. Orthodontics and Craniofacial Research, 6 (Suppl 1), 132–142.
  3. Venkatesh E, Elluru SV. Cone beam computed tomography: basics and applications in dentistry. J Istanb Univ Fac Dent. 2017 Dec 2;51(3 Suppl 1):S102-S121.
  4. Cramm, T., Hartz, A.J., & Green, M.D. (2002) Ascertaining customary care in malpractice cases: asking those who know. Wake Forest Law Review, 37 (3), 699–756.
  5. Burdenn, D.J. & Holmes, A. (1994) The need for orthodontic treatment in the child population of the United Kingdom. European Journal of Orthodontics, 16 (5), 395–399.
  6. Cabana, M.D., Rand, C.S., Powe, N.R., et al. (1999) Why don't physicians follow clinical practice guidelines? A framework for improvement. Journal of the American Medical Association, 282 (15), 1458–1465.
  7. Grogan, C.M., Feldman, R.D., Nyman, J.A., et al. (1994) How will we use clinical guidelines? The experience of medicare carriers. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, 19 (1), 7–26.
  8. Field, M.J. & Lohr, K.N. (1990) Clinical Practice Guidelines: Directions for a New Program. The National Academies Press, Washington DC.
  9. Friedland, B. (2009) Medico-legal issues related to conebeam CT. Seminars in Orthodontics, 15, 77–84.
  10. Genuis, S.J. (2005) The proliferation of clinical practice guidelines: professional development or medicine-by-numbers? Journal of the American Board of Family Medicine, 18 (5), 419–425.
  11. Grimes, D. & Schulz, K.F. (2002) Uses and abuses of screening tests. Lancet, 359 (9309), 881–884.
  12. Hyams, A.L., Shapiro, D.W., & Brennan, T.A. (1996) Medical practice guidelines in malpractice litigation: an early retrospective. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, 21, 289–313.
  13. Isaacson, K.G., Thom, A.R., Horner, K., et al. (2008) Orthodontic radiographs: guidelines, 3rd ed. European Journal of Orthodontics, 30, 669–670.
  14. Kau, C.H., Richmond, S., Palomo, J.M., et al. (2005) Three-dimensional cone beam computerized tomography in orthodontics. Journal of Orthodontics, 32 (4), 282–293.
  15. Larson, P.E. (2001) Oral and maxillofacial radiology parameters of care (letter to the editor). Oral Surgery, Oral Medicine, Oral Pathology, Oral Radiology, and Endodontology, 92 (5), 480–481.View
  16. Levin, D.C. & Rao, V.M. (2004) Turf wars in radiology: the overutilization of imaging resulting from self-referral. Journal of the American College of Radiology, 1 (3), 169–172.View
  17. Necheles, T. (1982) Standards of medical care: how does an innovative medical procedure become accepted? Law, Medicine & Health Care, 10 (1), 15–18.View
  18. Nordstrom, D. (2009) Radiographic exposure guidelines. American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics, 134 (5), 597–598.
  19. Royal College of Dental Surgeons of Ontario (2011) Standard of Practice: dental CT scanners. April 2011.
  20. Sukovic, P. (2003) Cone beam computed tomography in craniofacial imaging. Orthodontics & Craniofacial Research, 6 (Suppl 1), 31–36.
  21. Tyndall, D.A. & Brooks, S.L. (2000) Selection criteria for dental implant site imaging: a position paper of the American Academy of Oral and Maxillofacial Radiology. Oral Surgery, Oral Medicine, Oral Pathology, Oral Radiology, and Endodontology, 89 (5), 630–637.

Disclaimer from Guident

The views and opinions expressed in articles published in Guident are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the editors, the editorial board or the publisher, Ivory India. Guident does not endorse any product, technique or treatment described. Clinical content is intended for qualified dental and medical professionals and is not a substitute for individual clinical judgement. Guident, its editors and the publisher accept no liability for any consequence arising from the use of information published in the journal.

How to cite this article

Dr. Shubhangi Mani, Dr. N. G. Toshniwal, Dr. Apoorva Tonde. CBCT in Orthodontics: To Scan or Not to Scanmedico- Legal Implications: A Review. Guident. 2024 Oct;17(11). Available from: https://ivoryindia.in/articles/orthodontics/cbct-in-orthodontics-to-scan-or-not-to-scanmedico-legal-implications-a-review.html

Related articles

More in Orthodontics

All 135 articles
Vol. 17, Issue 7 · June 2024

Intraoral Scanners in Orthodontics

An intraoral scanner is a portable device used to directly create digital imprint data of the oral cavity. The scanning software interprets the data to build a real-time 3D model that is…

Dr. Faiz Warsi

Call for papers

Publish your clinical work in Guident

Original research, case reports and review articles are welcomed from clinicians and researchers worldwide. Every submission is assessed by the editorial board.