Open AccessPeer ReviewedPublished Monthly Since 2007 Vol. 19, Issue 12 · November 2026Media Kitinfo@guident.net

Psychology in Orthodontics: To See the Unseen

  • Dr. Mayuresh J BahetiP.G. student
  • Dr. Uday N SoniP.G. student
  • Dr. Nandlal Girijalal ToshniwalProfessor

Department of Orthodontics Rural Dental College, Pravara Institute of Medical Sciences, Loni Maharashtra, India

Guident · Volume 7, Issue 10 (September 2014)Published September 201415 min read

Abstract

The purpose of orthodontic treatment is far beyond improving a patient’s dental and facial health. Orthodontics also aims to improve one’s self-esteem and quality of life. Since facial beauty is the crucial aspect of social interaction and identity, a deformed individual has increased anxiety adjusting with his life, It also contributes to the Pathology of interaction uneasiness” with these stigmatic individuals. The orthodontist-patient relationship may have a significant impact on treatment outcome and patient satisfaction, thus improving the overall quality of care. Effective communication and an awareness of the psychological issues involved with orthodontic treatment are important in development of a healthy orthodontist-patient relationship which in turn may offer some influence in the various treatment variables, the extent of which is currently unknown. With that in mind, the orthodontist’s role appears to encompass more of a psychologist/counselor function at times, rather than solely as a practitioner treating malocclusions. The aim of this article is to review the literature, identifying the psychological aspects that are relevant to clinical orthodontics, highlighting the potential dynamic role an orthodontist plays both as the treating practitioner and a counselor to the patient.

Key words:Psychology, Motivation, Orthodontics

Orthodontists, of all dental specialties, had to deal with the most complex psychosocial issues because most orthodontic patients were children and adolescents who were working out conflicts with authority figures such as parents and teachers as well as the orthodontists, who like other doctors, were perceived to be in charge.1The successful outcome of orthodontic treatment requires not only knowledge and technical competence on the part of the treating orthodontist, but also considerable effort on the part of the patient. The behaviors required of the patient, such as keeping appointments, maintaining oral hygiene, adhering to dietary recommendations, wearing and maintaining appliances,2are sometimes complex and may disrupt established routines or interfere with social activities. Orthodontist actually shared the burden with the parents for motivating their children to comply with the requirements of the orthodontic treatment. With that in mind, the orthodontist’s role may appear to encompass more of a psychologist/counselor function at times, rather than solely as a practitioner treating malocclusions. Fundamental knowledge of psychology is necessary for modern orthodontics. The study of actions and reactions of individuals in social situations and the influence of such reactions on an individual is known as ‘Dialectic psychology’.3

The relationship between physical esthetic and positive social interaction has long been reported in the dental, psychological and social science literature.4These perceptions of facial esthetics influence psychological development from early childhood to adulthood. Studies in the field of social psychology indicate that physical attractiveness plays a major role in social interaction.5

The aim of this article is to review the literature, identifying the psychological aspects that are relevant to clinical orthodontics, highlighting the potential dynamic role an orthodontist plays both as the treating practitioner and a counselor to the patient and whether this relationship can potentially influence the patient in regards to a number of treatment variables.

THE ADOLESCENT ORTHODONTIC PATIENT

The teen years are formative in both physical and mental development. Teenagers are discerning their roles in life, struggling with acceptance by peers, and dealing with issues of self-esteem. Adolescence is associated with the stage of ‘ego identity vs. role confusion’ when the child develops his or her unique self-concept. At the same time as great changes are occurring in their bodies and minds. Orthodontists, more than almost any other health practitioners, should take advantage of their many office visits to be a helpful influence on adolescents during these developmental years. Given these concerns, the clinician should consider beginning treatment at an earlier stage if self- consciousness about dento-facial appearance is an issue.

MOTIVATION OF PATIENT FOR ORTHODONTIC TREATMENT

The primary factor that motivates patient or parents to seek orthodontic treatment is to improve physical appearance as a mean to enhance social acceptance and quality of life. Self-image is defined as the implication and problems associated with body ¡mage and self-concepts. Self-concept is defined as the perception of one’s own ability to master ordeal effectively with the environment, Body image has been defined as a representation of physical self in which conscious and unconscious attitudes about the body, its structure, functioning and appearance are incorporated.6The orthodontist and referring dentist should discuss any concern about the teeth and surrounding orofacial area in relation to body image, self-concept, and quality of life before deciding if and when to begin orthodontic treatment.

Baldwin &Bamnes did research on the psychological factors motivating orthodontic treatment. They found that the mother is usually the mobilizing, deciding and determining member of the family regarding the treatment.7

FACIAL ESTHETICS AND MALOCCLUSION

The first step in understanding cooperation in orthodontic treatment lies in understanding the motivation for seeking treatment. Of course, we have long known that most people who seek orthodontic treatment do so for cosmetic reasons.8 This seems to follow from the general literature on physical attractiveness, which shows that people learn concepts of facial attractiveness early in life and that facial attractiveness is a social asset and unattractiveness, a social liability.9 Furthermore, whereas epidemiological research has suggested that at least 70% to 75% of the population could benefit from orthodontic treatment for some form of occlusal malrelations, such functional considerations are not necessarily linked to the need for treatment as it is perceived by patients. Rather, most individuals view orthodontics as a means for improving dental-facial appearance. Consequently, professional guidelines for assessing orthodontic treatment need usually incorporate some estimate of esthetic impairment. The rationale usually given for this inclusion is that esthetic impairment, through its potentially negative impact on self-esteem, or self-efficacy, could result in personal or social difficulties.

DENTAL-FACIAL APPEARANCE AND SOCIAL BEHAVIOR

Reflecting on the available data, we can theorize that self-perceptions of dental-facial appearance begin with esthetic values shared within families and based generally on social norms, but that they may be strongly influenced by peer values and specific experiences of individual children, particularly those involving social responses. This latter observation helps to explain why the relative importance of dental-facial characteristics in defining self-perceptions of attractiveness may vary considerably from one individual to another. Theories incorporating concepts of social comparison and self-efficacy suggest that individuals evaluate themselves in comparison with others in their social environment. The family provides the most relevant environment early in life, but by adolescence the peer group sets the standard. In either of these contexts, we can see the emergence of a cycle of thought, action, and social consequences. Children who perceive themselves to be attractive will reflect those perceptions in their behaviors and generally will receive confirming social responses. The comparison group may express an attractiveness norm that reflects negatively on the individual, however. This, in turn, can affect the individual's perceived sense of self-efficacy or adequacy within that group and lead to behaviors that reflect more negative beliefs about the self, thereby inviting still more negative social responses.10

PSYCHOLOGY RELATED TO COMPLIANCE

Patient compliance is a critical factor in the efficacy of orthodontic treatment. Major treatment decisions hinge on the expected level of compliance and poor cooperation usually prevents the orthodontist from realizing optimal treatment results. While undergoing orthodontic treatment, patients are expected to follow instructions daily, wear elastics and headgear, maintain ideal oral hygiene, endure discomfort, keep regular appointments, and refrain from eating many foods that can be detrimental to their appliances. The assurance of good compliance can be especially tenuous in the case of adolescents, who represent the majority of orthodontic patients.11

Millon Adolescent Personality Inventory (MAPI)12 is a professionally developed and tested personality inventory specifically designed for adolescent patients. The various evaluating factors included wearing headgear, wearing elastics, oral hygiene maintenance, keeping appointments, willingness to follow instructions, prevention of broken appliances, cooperation during appliance placement and adjustment, overall attitude and parental attitude respectively.

Motivating the adolescent patient for orthodontic treatment becomes a very important factor for the orthodontist and the clinic staff. Motivation is of two types: Internal and External. External motivation is from pressure from others, as in orthodontic treatment “to get my mother off my back.” Internal motivation is provided by an individual’s own desire for treatment to correct a defect that one perceives in oneself, not some defect pointed out by authority figures whose values are being rejected anyway. The patient must be made aware that the treatment is done ‘for’ them and not ‘to’ them.13

Internally motivated patients will act to better their environment and are in control; an internally motivated patient perceives a causal relationship between results and his or her own behavior. Externally motivated patients feel powerless and believe they have little control over events, ascribing results to luck, chance, fate, or powerful others (parents and orthodontists).14

COMPLIANCE WITH ORAL HYGIENE

Orthodontist-patient relationships can enhance treatment outcomes by encouraging the patient to cooperate in following prescribed instructions related to appliance wear and maintenance of oral hygiene. (2) Successful orthodontic treatment requires active cooperation from the patient throughout the necessary lengthy orthodontic procedures.15 Patient compliance makes it possible to achieve treatment objectives in a minimum treatment time. Improved cooperation by the patient can also result in a reduction of expenses involved in orthodontic treatment. The efficiency of care and improved oral hygiene can minimize damage to the periodontal tissues, limit the deleterious effects of decalcification,and even rampant caries.16 With a noncompliant patient, it is necessary to compromise treatment methods and treatment objectives. Therefore standards of orthodontic care can be immensely improved with greater patient adherence.

Several studies have aimed to examine the influence interpersonal relationships have on compliance.2Mehra reported that the most common methods to improve patient compliance were to verbally praise the patient, educate the patient about the consequences of poor compliance, discuss treatment goals with the patient, educate the patient about the proper use of elastics, discuss the results of poor cooperation with the patient, and educate the patient regarding the proper use of adjunctive appliances.17 These items demonstrate that communication with the patient about the need for compliance was of paramount importance in improving patient compliance. The study also stresses the need to involve the patients in their own treatment. Educating patients and giving them more autonomy over their treatment can decrease anxiety, which in turn might increase adherent behavior. Also, the patient may feel that he or she is a more active participant in the treatment and that a team approach is applied where doctor and patient are striving together to achieve the same treatment outcomes. This notion is further supported by the studies of Fields, Milgormand Rubinwho found that patient compliance was improved by involving the patients in their own treatment.18,19 Nanda &Kier have also shown that a positive orthodontist-patient relationship resulted in an increase in the level of compliance by the patient.2Sinha et al found that specific orthodontist behaviors were significantly correlated with patient compliance, and that the most important behavior was politeness toward the patient. The doctor’s expression of concern about the well-being of the patient was also found to be significant in predicting patient compliance. Verbal communication, a calm and confident manner, and reassurance, were also found to increase patient compliance. The authors conclude by highlighting that the orthodontist can influence patient cooperation by trying to establish a good rapport with the patient.20

PAIN, DISCOMFORT, AND PSYCHOLOGICAL ADJUSTMENT TO TREATMENT

Individual psychological susceptibility is likely to be a significant factor for the intensity of discomfort caused by physical effects of an orthodontic appliance on oral tissues. Pain experience does not seem to be directly related to the magnitude of force exerted by different arch wires, rather, it may depend on the age and the psychological well-being of the patient.21 Psychological research has shown that the experience of pain and discomfort is influenced by personal values and expectations such as prospects of self-efficacy, treatment outcomes, and patients’ attitudes towards treatment22 Of relevance to orthodontics are the patients’ attitudes toward dental aesthetics, perceived severity of malocclusion, and expectations fromtreatment in the sense of an anticipated orthodontic self-efficacy.23,24 Patients’ behavior during orthodontic treatment seems to be related to perceived severity of malocclusion and to personal control orientation (LOC).25 Patients who have an internal locus of control are known to adapt faster, have less pain during orthodontic treatment, and tend to cooperate during orthodontic treatment.25

Pain from the appliance and the intrusion of treatment into the patient’s daily social life were seen as major causes of the discontinuance. Undesirable psychological effects of therapy do not appear to be a problem in adult orthodontic patients. In a survey of 33 adult patients between 18 and 58 years of age, Tayer& Burek,26 found that nearly 74% of adults indicated that they had initial fears concerning peer reaction to their treatment. However, the authors concluded that fixed appliance therapy for the adult patient, although initially embarrassing, was soon accepted and that negative concerns and fears were short lived. Similar findings were reported by Baum.27 Brown & Moerenhout21 found that adolescents generally reported a high level of pain after all phases of orthodontic treatment (in comparison to preadolescents and adults). This finding is consistent with a number of studies that have concluded that there is an age-dependent difference in the perception of pain, i.e. younger patients appear to perceive less pain than older patients. Brown &Moerenhout21 suggest that the higher level of pain reported by the adolescent group did not appear to be due to a difference in treatment characteristics or to differences in the use of analgesics. It is possible, however, that levels of reported pain were confounded with, or masked by, other affective reactions to treatment. Reported pain can often be a somatizationof either anxiety or depression. In this situation, reported pain may be the patient’s attempt to translate feelings of anxiety or depression into a physical physiologic problem.

The influence that psychological well-being has on pain perception, discomfort and psychological adjustment to orthodontic treatment further highlights the important psychologist/ counselor role an orthodontist may play in the orthodontist-patient relationship. Sinha et al20found that certain orthodontists’ behaviors appeared to influence more than one dependent variable like patient satisfaction, comfort and adjustment/compliance with treatment. The behaviors that were important in influencing patient satisfaction and cooperation/ adjustment were politeness and verbal communication, showing that the orthodontist was interested in the patient’s concern and alleviating anxiety.

PATIENT SATISFACTION

Patients generally think that the doctor-patient interaction should be comfortable and warm with a doctor who is technically competent and provides adequate information about the problem and procedures he/she will perform.28 Several reports in the literature have suggested that when these expectations are not met, the patients feel disappointed, less satisfied, fail to keep appointments, and do not comply with prescribed instructions which may ultimately result with a poor orthodontic result.28 Anderson et al.29 reported that the more the adolescents had focused on the post-orthodontic treatment aesthetics and functioning, and the more theywere energized by thinking about their post-treatment possible selves before the treatment, the more satisfied the adolescents and their parents were with the treatment outcomes. The authors advocate enhanced communication between the orthodontist and the adolescents and their parents, to energize and further motivate their patient to visualize their post-treatment possible selves before treatment. Oland et al.30 found that the pretreatment motivation for seeking surgicalorthodontic treatment significantly influenced the overall satisfaction after treatment, which was also correlated with the post-treatment psychosocial status of the patients. The patients who weighted oral function motives greatest (over aesthetics) expressed the lowest degree of treatment satisfaction.

The authors also stress the need for a comprehensive pretreatment analysis of the patients to determine both the psychological status of the patients and their motives for treatment, aided by communication by the treating practitioner and the patients. Sinha et al.20 study showed strong correlations between perceived orthodontists behaviors and patient satisfaction. Eight behaviors in particular were found to be more influential in affecting satisfaction. The most important itemwas found to be the doctor’s polite and courteous behavior toward the patient. Other verbal communication behaviors like information given, reassurance, and concern were also important. The doctor’s calm and confident attitude and an unhurried approach to treatment appeared to increase patient satisfaction. Further, correlations performed between patient satisfaction and a total score for the orthodontist behavior instrument showed that these two scores strongly correlated. This suggests that the orthodontist’s behaviors, in general, have a strong influence on the patient’s satisfaction. Also, correlations between patient satisfaction and patient adherence showed that patient satisfaction is important for ensuring patient adherence in orthodontic treatment.

CONCLUSION

Orthodontists are in a relatively unique position in that they mostly tend to treat/see their patients on a systematic, recurrent basis. The orthodontist should attempt to establish a warm, supportive relationship that offers a sense of involvement and concern. Since orthodontists tend to primarily treat adolescent and preadolescent patients during critical stages of their psychological development, the doctor-patient relationships in orthodontics and the treatment they provide may thus, influence a number of variables related directly to treatment. So, orthodontists might render “psychological first-aid” to the teenager.

As All our patients will not finish treatment successfully. This is always not our fault. Lack of patient co-operation and vagaries of growth sometimes mitigate against success. It is an alert orthodontist who recognizes the emotional reactions of the patient and treats not only malocclusion but psychological fears and frustrations as well. The principle of knowing as much as possible about the patient, his family and his environment is a must that all practitioners should keep in mind, for dentistry, like medicine, recognizes that therapy is not really successful unless the whole patient is treated. Thus, apart from recent advances in orthodontics on a daily basis, we must not forget to understand the psychology of the patients as a part of the basic protocol in clinical practice.

REFERENCES

  1. Miller ES, Larson LL. A theory of Psycho-orthodontics with practical application to office techniques. Angle orthod. 1979; 49: p. 85-91.
  2. Nanda RS, Kierl MJ. Prediction of cooperation in orthodontic treatment. AmJ Orthod Dentofiac Orthop. 1992; 102: p. 15-21.
  3. Giddon D. B. Psychologic Problems of Physically Handicapped. IDJ. 1975; 25: p. 576-581.
  4. Brandhorst O. W. WHI Orthodonbcs Become a Part of Contemplated Govt. Health Programmes for Children? JD. Educ. 1946; 10: p. 138-143.
  5. Heidi Kerosuo, Hannu Hausen, Telleno Laine and William C. Shaw. The Influence of Incisai Malocclusion on the Social Attractiveness of ‘bung Adults in Finland. Eur.J. Orthod. 1995; 17: p. 505-512.
  6. George Stricker. Psychological Issues PertainIng to Malocclusion. Am. J. Orthod. 1970; 58(3): p. 276-283.
  7. Baldwin D. C., Barnes M. L. Psychological factors motivating Orthodontic treatment. I.A.D.R. 1965; 44: p. 461.
  8. Dion KK. Young children’s stereotyping of tacial attractiveness. Dev Psychol. 1973; 9: p. 183-188.
  9. Jago JD. Epidemiology of dental occlusion: A critical approach. J Publ Health Dent. 1974; 34: p. 80-93.
  10. Albino JE, Tedesco LA. Esthetic need for orthodontic treatment: Current Controversies in Orthodontics. B M, editor. Chicago, IL: Quintessence; 1991.
  11. Tung A and Kiyak H. Psychological influences on the timing of orthodontic treatment. Am J Orthod Dentofac Orthop. 1998; 113(1): p. 29-39.
  12. Southard K, Tolley E, Arheart K, Hackett-Renner C and Southard T. Application of Millon Adolescent Personality Inventory in evaluating orthodontic compliance. Am J Orthod Dentofac Orthop. 1991; 100: p. 553-61.
  13. Proffit WR, Fields HW, Sarver DM. Contemporary Orthodontics. 4th ed. Missouri,: Elsevier; 2007.
  14. Egolf R, BeGole E and Upshaw H. Factors associated with orthodontic compliance with intraoral elastic and headgear wear. Am J Orthod Dentofac Orthop. 1990; 97: p. 336-48.
  15. Story RI. Psychological issues in orthodontic practice. Am J Orthod. 1966; 52: p. 584–98.
  16. Zachrisson BU. Cause and prevention of injuries to teeth and supporting structures during orthodontic treatment. Am J Orthod. 1976; 69: p. 285–300.
  17. Mehra T, Nanda RS, Sinha PK. Orthodontists’ assessment and management of patient compliance. Angle Orthod. 1998; 68: p. 115–22.
  18. Fields RS. Influencing patient cooperation. J Clin Orthod. 1980; 14: p. 417–21.
  19. Rubin RM. Recognition and empowerment: an effective approach to enlisting patient cooperation. J Clin Orthod. 1995; 29: p. 24–6.
  20. Sinha PK, Nanda RS, McNeil DW. Perceived orthodontist behaviors that predict patient satisfaction, orthodontistpatient relationship, and patient adherence in orthodontic treatment. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 1996; 110: p.370–7.

Disclaimer from Guident

The views and opinions expressed in articles published in Guident are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the editors, the editorial board or the publisher, Ivory India. Guident does not endorse any product, technique or treatment described. Clinical content is intended for qualified dental and medical professionals and is not a substitute for individual clinical judgement. Guident, its editors and the publisher accept no liability for any consequence arising from the use of information published in the journal.

How to cite this article

Dr. Mayuresh J Baheti, Dr. Uday N Soni, Dr. Nandlal Girijalal Toshniwal. Psychology in Orthodontics: To See the Unseen. Guident. 2014 Sep;7(10). Available from: https://ivoryindia.in/articles/orthodontics/psychology-in-orthodontics-to-see-the-unseen.html

Related articles

More in Orthodontics

All 135 articles
Vol. 7, Issue 10 · September 2014

Standard Edgewise Simplified

With the advent of pre-adjusted appliance mechanotherapy, the standard edgewise appliance therapy is being sparingly used. This case report demonstrates the treatment of bimaxillary…

Dr. Siddharth Mehta

Call for papers

Publish your clinical work in Guident

Original research, case reports and review articles are welcomed from clinicians and researchers worldwide. Every submission is assessed by the editorial board.