Attitude of School Going Children Towards Inclusive Education a Questionnaire Study
Department of Pediatric & Preventive Dentistry, A.B Shetty Memorial Institute of Dental Sciences Nitte (deemed to be) University, Derlakatte, Mangalore, Karnataka
ABSTRACT
Inclusive education brings about normal and special children under the same roof thereby promoting the social wellbeing of children with special health care needs. As pediatric dentists, it is essential to understand the attitude of school-going children towards their peers, especially those with special health care needs so as to ensure quality health care delivery in the same environment to both the groups of children. This study was conducted in an attempt to analyse the awareness and attitude of children of different age groups, towards their peers with disabilities studying in the same government school in the city of Mangaluru, Karnataka, India. The results indicated a better acceptance of children with SHCN by their peers. Harnessing this indiscriminate attitude among SG children will not only help improve the quality of life of children with SHCN, but also lead to improvement in moral behaviour and conduct of SG children, instilling compassion and empathy in them.
Introduction
Inclusive education has gained momentum in the past decade. It is an approach wherein both the normal and special children are educated under the same roof. Earlier the focus was towards educating children with disabilities and learning difficulties in special schools, which was believed to improve their academic progress. However, this marginalization and exclusion resulted in an inferiority complex among not only these children, but also their parents. This paved way for inclusive education, which aims at integrated development of special and normal children through mainstream schooling.1 Although inclusive education is anticipated to increase the possibility of friendship among normal and special children, in certain scenarios, special children face difficulties in obtaining acceptance and friendship, the reason however being unclear. The consequence of such lack of acceptance might lead to difficulties in participating in group activities, declining academic records, behavioural problems, dropping out of school, or in the worst situation, depression and other mental health issues, all of which have a direct impact on their perception of dental treatment. It is believed that several factors play a role in this process such as the attitudes of teachers and students, the class size, and type of disability to name a few.2 As pediatric dentists, it is essential to understand the attitude of school-going children towards their peers, especially those with special health care needs so as to ensure quality health care delivery in the same environment to both the groups of children. This study was conducted in an attempt to analyse the awareness and attitude of children of different age groups, towards their peers with disabilities studying in the same government school in the city of Mangaluru, Karnataka, India.
Aim
To assess the awareness and attitude of school-going children (SG) towards children with special health care needs (SHCN) in an inclusive education set-up.
Materials and Methodology
A self-administered questionnaire was distributed among the students ranging from 6-14 years of age, studying in a government school in Mangaluru which had adopted an inclusive education system. The sample comprised of 252 children, belonging to Class I - Class VII, wherein each class had enrolled a minimum of one child with SHCN. The SG children were instructed to answer the close-ended questionnaire after obtaining a written consent from their parents and teachers. The questionnaire was framed in the local vernacular language (Kannada). The children were given a total of 15 minutes to mark their response following which the questionnaire sheets were collected and statistically analysed.
Results
A total of 252 children participated in the study. 207 of 252 children were well aware that certain children in their class required special guidance and additional help in school activities. 16 children felt that there was no such separate assistance required by any child in their class and 17 children responded that they were not aware of any form of special assistance required by any child in their class. (Figure 1). Only those questionnaires were considered for further assessment wherein SG children were aware of the presence of children with SHCN in their class. Thus, the further questions were analysed from 207 questionnaires only.
The second question assessed the interaction of SG children and children with SHCN. Out of 207 children, 185 responded that they provide assistance to children with SHCN. (Figure 2).
148 of 207 children responded that they help these children (SHCN) even while playing outdoors games (Figure 3).
The fourth question assessed whether the SG children preferred sharing classroom space the SHCN group. Majority of SG children (98%) responded positively (Figure 4).
In response to whether they (SG children) like sharing their things with their peers with SHCN, 181 responded that they were willing to do the same (Figure 5).
Discussion
Of the 207 children that were aware of children with SHCN in their class, the percentage of positive response was higher in children belonging to the older age group (Class V, VI, VII) as compared to the children in the younger age group (Class I, II, III, IV). This clearly indicates that the level of awareness is higher in children belonging to the older age group. This is accordance with the results of a survey conducted by Clunies-Ross G in 1986 assessing the attitudes of primary school students in Australia.3
Assessing the empathy of SG children towards their peers with SHCN, a larger number of children belonging to older age group responded positively. This showed that the children intended to interact with and befriend children with SHCN. A similar observation was made by Roberts CM and Smith PR in 1999 among children between 8 – 12 years of age.4 Another study in Nigeria also postulated similar findings of a positive attitude of students towards peers with disabilities in an inclusive school.5 However, this was in contrast to the findings of a study performed among Chinese students. A slightly negative attitude towards inclusive education was stated by Malinen O and Savolainen in 2008.6
The fact that the SG children help children with SHCN even in outdoor activities confirms that the empathising behaviour is not just limited to the classroom activities. This can boost the confidence and motivate the child with SHCN to perform better and help overcome their limitations.5
A clear majority (98%) with respect to preference of inclusive education among SG children indicates that children do not discriminate between peers with any form of disability. A study by Bunch G and Valeo A in 2004 observed that students had made friends with and liked the presence of their peers with disabilities in their classroom.7
A high percentage (87.43%) of positive responses with respect to willingness to share personal item with disabled peers affirms the previously established fact that there is no discrimination made by SG children studying in an inclusive educational system. This could instil a positive attitude in children with SHCN and propel them to perform better in all aspects, academic as well as extra-curricular activities.5
Conclusion
Success of inclusive education is greatly determined by the acceptance of children with SHCN by the otherwise healthy children. Our survey clearly indicates a better acceptance of children with SHCN by their peers. Children do not consider their peers with disabilities as any different from them. The differences are brought about by society. Harnessing this indiscriminate attitude among SG children will not only help improve the quality of life of children with SHCN, but also lead to improvement in moral behaviour and conduct of SG children, instilling compassion and empathy in them.
Future recommendations
This pilot study was conducted in a single government school in Dakshin Kannada and further extensive surveys in various regions of the state and country would facilitate a better understanding of the attitudes of children studying in inclusive education systems.
References
- Sanjeev K, Kumar K. Inclusive education in India. Electronic Journal of inclusive education.
- De Boer A, Pijl SJ, Minnaert A. Students’ attitudes towards peers with disabilities: A review of the literature. International Journal of Disability, Development and education Dec 2012; 59 (4): 379-92.
- Clunies-Ross G. Use of peer attitudes toward the handicapped scale in Australia: grade differences in the scores of primary school students. Australia and New Zealand Journal of Development Disabilities. 1986;12 (4): 257-61.
- Roberts CM, Smith PR. Attitudes and behaviour of children toward peers with disabilities. International Journal of Disability, Development and Education. 1999;46(1):35-50.
- Olaleye A, Ogundele O, Deji S, Ajayi O, Olaleye O, Adeyanju T. Attitudes of students towards peers with disability in an inclusive school in Nigeria. Diasbility, CBR and Inclusive Development. 2012; 23 (3): 65-75.
- Malinen O, Savolainen H. Inclusion in the east: Chinese students’ attitudes towards inclusive education. Int J Spec Educ. 2008;23(3):1-9.
- Bunch G, Valeo A. Student attitudes toward peers with disabilities in inclusive and special education schools. Disability & Society. 2004;19(1):61-76.
Disclaimer from Guident
The views and opinions expressed in articles published in Guident are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the editors, the editorial board or the publisher, Ivory India. Guident does not endorse any product, technique or treatment described. Clinical content is intended for qualified dental and medical professionals and is not a substitute for individual clinical judgement. Guident, its editors and the publisher accept no liability for any consequence arising from the use of information published in the journal.
How to cite this article
Dr. Amitha M. Hegde Sr., Dr. Geethanjali G, Dr. Priyal P. Sheth. Attitude of School Going Children Towards Inclusive Education a Questionnaire Study. Guident. 2020 Mar;13(4). Available from: https://ivoryindia.in/articles/pedodontics/attitude-of-school-going-children-towards-inclusive-education-a-questionnaire-study.html












