Caries Prevention
Department of Conservative Dentistry and Endodontics, Department of Conservative Dentistry and Endodontics, Department of Oral Pathology and Microbiology, Yenepoya Dental College, Mangalore, India
Abstract
Primary goal of caries prevention program should be to reduce the numbers of cariogenic bacteria. Prevention should start with a consideration of overall resistance of the patient to infection by the cariogenic bacteria. Caries control methods are operative procedures used both to stop the advance of individual lesion and to prevent the spread of pathogenic bacteria to the other tooth surface and in this sense, they are preventive procedures. These operative procedures remove irreversibly damaged tooth structure and the associated
pathogenic bacteria in the site.
INTRODUCTION
The general health of patient, fluoride exposure, history and function of immune system and salivary glands have a significant impact on patient caries risk, however the patient may have little control over these factors.1 On the other hand, patient usually is capable of controlling other factors such as diet, oral hygiene, use of antimicrobial agents and dental care.
Preventive treatment methods are designed to limit tooth demineralization caused by cariogenic bacteria, and thereb preventing cavitated lesions. These include;
- Limiting pathogen growth and metabolism.
- Increasing the resistance of tooth surface to demineralization.
GENERAL HEALTH 1
Patients’ general health has a significant impact on overall caries risk. Declining health signals the need for increased preventive measures, including more frequent recalls. Every patient has a very effective surveillance and destruction system for foreign bacteria. The effectiveness of patients’ immunologic system is highly dependent on overall health status. Patient undergoing radiation or chemotherapy treatment have significantly decreased immune competence and are at the risk for increased rate of caries.
Medically compromised patients should be examined for changes in the following:
- Plaque index
- Salivary flow
- Oral mucosa
- Gingiva
- Teeth
Early signs of increased risk include:
- Increased plaque
- Puffy bleeding gingiva
- Dry mouth with red glossy mucosa
- Demineralization of teeth
During acute and chronic systemic illness, decreased salivary flow is very common and is responsible for dramatic increase in plaque. Ambulatory patients with chronic illnesses often take multiple medications, which may significantly reduce salivary flow. Saliva should be tested for both flow and buffering capacities when changes are detected from an oral examination.
FLUORIDE EXPOSURE 2
In trace amounts Fluoride increases the resistance of tooth structure to demineralization and is therefore a particularly important consideration for caries prevention. When fluoride is available at the time of tooth demineralization cycle, it is a major factor in decreasing the caries activity.
The availability of fluoride to reduce caries risk is primarily achievedby:
- Fluoride in diet
- Fluoridated community water system
- Mouth rinses
- Tooth pastes
- Professional topical application
The optimal fluoride level for public H2O supplies is about 1 part per million (1 ppm).
At 0.1 ppm and below, the preventive effect is lost and caries rate is higher for such populations lacking sufficient fluoride exposure.
Excessive fluoride exposure (10 ppm or more) results in fluorosis, a brownish discoloration of enamel termed MOTTLED ENAMEL.
Fluoride exerts their anticaries effects by 3 different mechanisms:
- Presence of fluoride ions greatly enhances the precipitation into tooth structure of fluorapatite from calcium and phosphate ions present in saliva. This insoluble precipitate replaces the soluble salts containing Manganese and Carbonate that were lost because of bacterial mediated demineralization. This exchange process results in enamel becoming more acid resistant.
- Incipient non cavitated carious lesion is remineralised by the same process.
- Fluoride has antimicrobial activity in low concentration, fluoride ions inhibits the enzymatic production of glucosyltransferase.
Glucosyltransferase prevents glucose from forming extracellular polysaccharide and this reduces bacterial adhesion and slows ecological succession. Intracellular polysaccharide formation is also inhibited, preventing storage of carbohydrates by limiting microbial metabolism between host meals.
In high concentrations (12,000 ppm) used in topical fluoride treatments, fluoride ions are directly toxic to some oral microorganisms including streptococci mutans (MS). Suppression of growth of MS following a single topical fluoride treatment may last several weeks.
All of the various methods for fluoride exposures are effective to some degree Clinician’s goal are to choose the most effective combination of each patient. The choice must be based on patient’s age, caries experience, general health and oral hygiene.
Topical application of fluoride should be done semiannually for children and adults who are at high risk of caries development. Acidulated phosphate fluoride (APF) is most effective and least objectionable topical agent. APF is available in thixotropic gels and has a long shelf life.
Stannous fluoride (8%) (SnF) has a bitter taste, may burn mucosa and have short shelf life. Tin in SnF may stain teeth. Topical fluoride agents should be applied according to manufacturer’s recommendations.
Self administered fluoride rinses have an additive effect (about 20% reduction) when used in conjunction with topical or systemic fluoride treatment. Fluoride rinses are indicated in high risk patients and those patients exhibiting a recent increase in caries activity.
Two varieties of fluoride rinses have similar effectiveness:
- High dose (0.2% F) low frequency rinses are best used in supervised weekly rinsing programs based in public schools.
- Low dose (0.05% F) high frequency rinses are best used by individual patients at home.
The high risk or caries active patients should be advised to use the rinse daily. The optimal application time is in the evening. The rinse should be forced between teeth many times and then expectorated, not swallowed. Eating and drinking should be avoided after the rinse.
Various fluoride varnishes and gels are available and successful in preventing caries. Varnishes provide a high uptake of fluoride ion into enamel. Yet provide a lower dosage of fluoride than gels or rinses. They are effectively bactericidal and caries preventing agents.
The general technique for fluoride varnish use is:
- Clinician applies a thin layer of fluoride varnish directly on tooth surface.
- Application time is several minutes.
- Patients are to avoid eating for several hours and then avoid brushinguntil the next morning.
Because fluoride varnish sets when contacting moisture, thorough isolation is not required. Main disadvantage of fluoride varnish isthat a temporary change in tooth color may occur.
Fluoride varnish deposits large amount of fluoride on enamel surface, especially on a demineralized enamel surface. The high concentration of surface fluoride also may provide a reservoir for fluoride, which promotes remineralization. The use of fluoride varnish as a caries preventing agent should be expanded because it has advantages over other topical fluoride vehicles in terms of safety, ease of application and fluoride concentration at the enamel surface.
IMMUNIZATION 3
Bacteria passing through the mouth into stomach and intestinescome in contact with specialized lymphoid tissue located in Peyer’s patches along the intestinal walls. Certain T and B cells in Peyer’s patches become sensitized to the new bacteria. The sensitized T and B cells migrate through lymphatic system to blood stream and eventually settle in glandular tissues including the salivary glands in the oral cavity. Therefore these sensitized cells produce IgA class immunoglobulins that are secreted in saliva. These IgA antibodies are capable of clumping of oral bacteria.
This prevents adherence to the teeth and other oral structures and they are more easily cleared from mouth by swallowing. For patients with high concentration of M.Streptococci, agglutinating IgA may have an important anticaries effect. This immunologic occurrence promotes the possibility of further vaccination against caries.
SALIVARY FUNCTIONING
Saliva is very important in prevention of caries. While xerostomia may occur because of aging; it is more commonly as a result of medication. Lack of saliva may greatly increase the incidence of caries. Saliva stimulants (gums, paraffin waxes or saliva substitutes) also may be prescribed for patients with impaired salivary functioning.
ANTIMICROBIAL AGENTS
A variety of antimicrobial agents help prevent caries. In rare cases, antibiotics might be considered, but the systemic effects must be considered.
Chlorhexidine varnish enhances remineralization and decreases streptococci mutans presence. Chlorhexidine is prescribed for home use at bed time as a 30 second rinse. Used at this time when the salivary flow rate is decreased. The agent has a better opportunity to interact with MS organisms while tenaciously adhering to oral structures. It is used for approximately 2 weeks, and results in reduction of MS counts to below caries potential. This decrease is sustained for 12-26 weeks.
DIET 1
Dietary sucrose has two important detrimental effects on plaque:
1. Frequent ingestion of foods containing sucrose provides a stronger potential for colonization by MS, enhancing the caries potential of the plaque.
2. Mature plaque exposed frequently to sucrose rapidly metabolizes into organic acids, resulting in profound and prolonged drop in plaque pH.
Caries activity is most strongly stimulated by the frequency rather than quantity of sucrose ingested. However, for an individual patient, dietary modification can be effective if the patient is
properly motivated and supervised. Evidence of new caries activity in adolescent and adult patients indicates the need for dietary counseling.
Goals of dietary counseling should be to identify the sources of sucrose in diet and reduce frequency of sucrose ingestion.
ORAL HYGIENE
Plaque free tooth surfaces do not decay. Daily removal of plaque by dental flossing, tooth brushing and rinsing is the single best procedure for preventing both caries and periodontal disease.
Xylitol Gums
Xylitol is a five carbon sugar obtained from birch trees. It keeps the sucrose molecule from binding with MS. Furthermore MS cannot metabolize Xylitol. Thus Xylitol reduces MS by altering their metabolic path ways and enhances remineralization and helps arrest dentinal caries. It is usually recommended that a patient chew a piece of Xylitol gum after eating or snacking for 5-30 minutes. Chewing any sugar free gum after meals reduces the acidogenicity of plaque because chewing stimulates salivary flow which improves the buffering of pH drop that occurs after eating.
PIT AND FISSURE SEALANTS 4,5
Fluoride treatments are very effective in preventing smooth surface caries. They are less effective in preventing pit and fissure caries. The 1988 to 1991 NHANES III Survey revealed that occlusal surfaces in children’s teeth were five times more likely to be the site of caries than proximal surfaces and twice as likely as facial or lingual surfaces. Thus preventive measures for pit and fissure caries is important. Pit and fissure sealants were specially designed for this purpose and have been demonstrated to be effective. Sealants have 3 important preventive effects:
- Sealants mechanically fill pits and fissures with an acid resistant resin.
- Pit and fissures are filled sealant deny MS and other microorganism their preferred habitat.
- Sealants render pit and fissures are easier to clean by tooth brushing and mastication.
Genetic Modalities in Caries PREVENTION 6
The use of genetic engineering to prevent caries has led to the dawn of new era in caries prevention. A gene is a segment of DNA having a limited number of nucleotide pairs in a unique sequence. Each living being in this universe contains specific number and set of genes. These genes are coded by triplet bases called CODON.
Earlier this triplet codon was considered as a secret blue print of that species. Now with recent DNA recombinant technique we are in a clear position to edit the text of our genetic code. Various approaches taken are genetic engineering and gene therapy.
Gene
This is the fundamental physical and functional unit of heredity. A gene is an ordered sequence of nucleotides located in a particular position on a particular chromosome that encodes a specific functional product.
Genetic Code:
The sequence of nucleotides coded in triplets or codons, along the mRNA, that determines the sequence of amino acids in protein synthesis. The DNA sequence of a gene can be used to predict the mRNA sequence. In turn, genetic code can be used to predict amino acid sequence.
Genetically modified Organisms
A new bug against caries:
The human mouth is home to billions of bacteria belonging to more than 300 species, but one species is the major cause of tooth decay. The culprit is streptococcus mutans, a spherical bacterium that thrives on the organic film that coats tooth surface and produces an enzyme called LACTATE DEHYDROGENASE. This enzyme
converts sugars into lactic acid, a corrosive chemical that gradually dissolves the protective enamel coating on teeth.
Arming new bacteria to battle with cavity promoting bacteria could offer a new way to prevent tooth decay hence they are called genetically modified “Good” bacteria.
In the experiments with cells and rats, scientists found that a type of good bacteria called LACTOBACILLUS ZEAE, which could be genetically modified to produce antibodies to attach themselves to the surface of streptococcus Mutans. These antibodies grabbed free floating S.mutans in saliva and gave them a “KISS TO DEATH”.
LACTOBACILLUS laden foods and supplements – commonly referred to as PROBIOTICS have grown increasing popularity because they are believed to promote good gastrointestinal health.
Taking a different approach HILLMAN of Florida has created an effector strain of Strep. Mutans called BCS3-L1 that lacks the lactate dehydrogenase gene and is incapable of producing lactic acid this effector strain was also designed to produce elevated amounts of novel peptide antibiotic called Mutacin 1140 that kills conventional S.mutans without harming other bacteria, ensuring that it will dominate its disease causing cousins.
National Institute of Dental and Craniofacial Research director Dr.LAWRENCE prefers the concept of replacing S.mutans with a species engineered to rebuild tooth surface. Some microorganism produce acids, but other produce bases and these bases provide a milieu that favors remineralization. Strains of S.mutans are engineered to increase the production of enzyme UREASE, which converts urea into NH3 to create conditions conductive to enamel remineralization
GENETICALLY MODIFIED FOODS
These are the transgenic crops that contain genes known for their desirable qualities like high yield, disease resistance, early and uniform maturity etc. The food thus harvested is called genetically modified foods.
“AN APPLE A DAY MAY SOON KEEP THE DENTIST AWAY”
Scientists are genetically engineering fruits to protect against tooth decay. Eating a genetically modified apple or bowl of strawberries a day could protect teeth from the microbes that cause decay. Scientists developed a GM fruit to release a bacteria beating vaccine in every mouthful. The vaccine, a protein called P1025, tricks S.mutans, the main cause of tooth decay. A gene for a peptide protein is added to strawberries and apples by BIOTECHNOLOGISTS. The antagonist peptide works against the specific enzyme system glucosyltransferase of S.mutans. It stops the microbes from binding to the tooth, preventing caries for up to 80 days without using antibiotics.
NEW CAVITY CLASSIFICATION
The three sites of carious lesions:7 (Mount and Hume in 1997)
Carious lesions occur in 3 sites on the crown or root of a tooth; that is, those areas subject to accumulation of plaque.
Site1: Pits, fissures and enamel defects on occlusal surfaces of posterior teeth or other smooth surfaces.
Site2: The contact areas between any two teeth, anteriors or posteriors.
Site3: Cervical one third of the crown or following gingival recession, the exposed root.
It is regarded as logical to classify lesions by these sites and then to grade them by size according to extent of progress. The classification applies equally to both anterior and posterior teeth.
Four Sizes of Carious Lesion:
Taking into account the progress of the carious lesion described above. It is possible to consider restoration in four sizes, regardless of the site of origin of the lesion.
Size1: Minimal involvement of dentine just beyond treatment by remineralisation alone.
Size2: Moderate involvement of dentine following cavity preparation remaining enamel is sound, well supported by dentine and not likely to fail under normal occlusal load. The tooth is sufficiently strong to support restoration.
Size3: Cavity is enlarged beyond moderate involvement. Remaining tooth structure is weakened that cusps or incisal edges are split or likely to fail if exposed to occlusal load. The cavity needs to be further enlarged so that the restoration can be designed to provide support to the remaining tooth structure.
Size4: Extensive caries and bulk loss of tooth structure has already occurred.
MINIMAL INTERVENTION Operative Dentistry is dependent on following factors:8
- The demineralization - remineralization cycle.
- Adhesion in restorative dentistry
- Biomimetic restorative material
DEMINERALIZATION - REMINERALIZATION CYCLE 9
Over the last 30 years, there has been considerable increase in the knowledge and understanding of progress of caries through tooth structure. It is now clear that in a normal healthy mouth there is a continuous cycle of demineralization and remineralization of the surface of tooth. If the acidity on the surface of tooth falls below 5.5 there will be release of calcium and phosphate ions and these will be taken up into the surrounding saliva leaving behind, a demineralised collagen frame work.
Because the saliva is already a supersaturated solution of these ions there is constant potential for their return to the tooth structure. Thus once the ambient pH rises above pH 5.5 any early lesion caries or erosion will begin to remineralise and heal. However, if the acidity remains high for prolonged periods of time surface integrity may be lost to the extent of cavitation. Thereafter it will be difficult or impossible for the patient to keep the area free from further plaque accumulation.
Fluorides play an important role in demineralization - remineralization cycle. If demineralization takes place in presence of free fluoride ions, the remineralization stage will be facilitated to the extent that fluorapatite rather than hydroxyapatite will be laid down within the surface of lesion which has several advantages.
First, the critical pH of fluorapatite 4.5 which means that it is notably more resistant to further demineralization than the original hydroxyapatite. That is, addition of fluoride to tooth surface will increase resistance to further caries attack.
Second advantage, is that fluoride is bacteriostatic so that species such as streptococcus mutans fail to thrive in its presence. It also modifies the surface energy of the enamel to the extent that plaque will not be so firmly attached to it.
Finally fluoride helps to buffer the pH of plaque on surface of tooth or any restorative material that can release it.
This cycle is significant and remineralization is available through all stages of development of cavity. In early stages, when only the enamel is involved, attaining remineralization is simply a matter of plaque removal through normal oral hygiene methods in conjunction with the introduction of free fluoride ions by either topical or systemic methods. Demineralised enamel is relatively fragile and the lesions subject to masticatory stresses such as occlusal lesion may breakdown readily. However in a proximal lesion that is not subject to so much damage the enamel may not be cavitated even when dentin is involved in demineralization process. Such a lesion can also be reversed and healed. Once the lesion has advanced to surface cavitation and dentin is involved the content of the cavity can be divided roughly into 2 layers:
- Infected layer - on the outer surface of cavity, tooth structure in this layer is completely denatured and laden with microorganisms.
- Affected layer - Relatively sterile, softened demineralised inner layer to some degree depending on the speed and the aggression of the disease process, but it will still contain the original collagen framework that is capable of remineralization. Full control of caries requires elimination of both infected layer and the cavitation that is allowing bacterial plaque to be retained.
In the absence of bacterial plaque the demineralization cannot progress in this context it is important to note that affected layer at the base of cavity is relatively sterile. In the past the surgical approach to control of caries dictated the removal of all tooth structure that appeared to be involved in disease. This principle included the removal of affected layer, on the assumption that it was part of the problem. It is now been demonstrated that this layer can be remineralised as well provided that it is sealed under a biomimetic restorative material. Therefore it is suggested that demineralised layer in affected dentine be regarded as precarious rather than actively caries. This layer should be retained and remineralised under most circumstances thereby reducing the iatrogenic loss of tooth structure.
CONCLUSION
The knowledge of functional properties of saliva as well as those of its separate components may permit a better assessment of dental caries susceptibility. The pH-raising effects are more easily explained by the buffering action of the stimulated saliva than by clearance of carbohydrates. Fluoride in saliva may promote remineralization and inhibit demineralization. Future research is needed to characterize more fully salivary components and their interactions and how these affect the caries process.
REFERENCES
1. Edward J. Swift, Harald O. Heymann, Theodore M. Roberson. Sturdevant’s art and science of operative dentistry. 4th Ed. St. Louis: Mosby : 2002
2. Jenkins G. N, Murray J. J, Rugg – Gunn A. J. Fluorides in caries prevention. 3rd Edition. Varghese Pub; 1999.
3. Russell M. W. Potential for vaccines in the prevention of caries lesions. J. Op. Dent. 6 : 51 – 60
Disclaimer from Guident
The views and opinions expressed in articles published in Guident are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the editors, the editorial board or the publisher, Ivory India. Guident does not endorse any product, technique or treatment described. Clinical content is intended for qualified dental and medical professionals and is not a substitute for individual clinical judgement. Guident, its editors and the publisher accept no liability for any consequence arising from the use of information published in the journal.
How to cite this article
Dr. Gary Ignatius, Dr. Amarnath Shenoy, Dr. Shruti D Nayak. Caries Prevention. Guident. 2013 May;6(7). Available from: https://ivoryindia.in/articles/endodontics/caries-prevention.html










