Open AccessPeer ReviewedPublished Monthly Since 2007 Vol. 19, Issue 12 · November 2026Media Kitinfo@guident.net

Revision of Root Canal

  • Dr. Anil DhingraProfessor & H.O.D.
  • Dr. NidhiP.G Student

Department of Conservative & Endodontics DJ College of Dental Sciences and Research, Modinagar, UP, India

Guident · Volume 7, Issue 1 (December 2013)Published December 201317 min read2 figures

ABSTRACT

Out of every 100 endodontically treated cases, 10% are failures .Every clinician encounters with a retreatment case in their dental practice. They are regularly confronted with different choices after failure of root canal treatment .As patient increasingly express a preference for retaining their natural dentition and further endodontic treatment is feasible. Many factors including microbial challenge, location of infection, and host defense plays a role in the decision whether to retreat a case non-surgically, address the problem surgically, or to extract and place an implant. The new generation of Endodontic instruments, magnification, materials, technology with the basic principles of endodontic retreatment have helped in retention of the patients natural tooth structure to form and function decreasing the need for extensively prosthetic replacement in the area of implant dentistry. A willingness and open-mindedness to hybridize various techniques may result in a more effective endodontic outcome. Surgical approach can be adopted in obstructed, calcified or non-negotiable canals.

Key Words- Retreatment, Obturation, root canal, endodontic failure

INTRODUCTION

Endodontic treatment is the best remedy for exacerbating tooth pain. During the past few decades endodontic treatment has benefited from the development of new techniques and equipment, which have improved outcome and predictability.[1]Because of all these new techniques root canal treatment is considered to have a success rate of 90%but even 10% failure each year will result in a sizeable number of failures in a population. Therefore, it is important for the clinicians to develop skills to manage endodontic failures.[2]Root canals fail due to micro leakage and bacterial infection. The precise cause of endodontic failures can be attributable to inadequacies in three-dimensional cleaning, shaping and obturation. Additionally, failures occur because of missed canals, iatrogenic events, radicular fractures, or re-infection of the root canal system when the coronal seal is lost after the completion of root canal treatment. Regardless of the etiology, the sum of all causes is leakage, bacterial contamination or re-contamination.[3]

Evolutionary Introduction and widespread adoption of the operating Microscope has enhanced vision and magnification allowing success for the untreated root canal systems, poorly obturated root canals, coronal microleakage, undetected cracked tooth, an obturation, a ledge, a perforation or an instrument fracture indicating non-healing associated with the previous treatment. There are various methods of Endodontic revision which must be carefully evaluated so a decision can be made among non-surgical retreatment, surgical retreatment or Extraction. Non-surgical treatment has shown improved outcomes with increasing recall time as compared to the surgical treatment.[4]Non-surgical treatment can thus be used as a predictable option to periapical surgery in endodontic failures.

Newer advancement like ultrasonics, newer endontic rotary retrieval files, lasersare effective methods for root canal preparation in endodontic retreatment.

During retreatment we must be prepared to manage iatrogenic events such as negotiating blocked canals, bypassing ledges, repairing perforations and sealing apical transportations.[5]

Clinician may be familiar with various techniques to remove coronal restoration and safely remove a variety of post system.

POST AND CORE REMOVAL

Several retreatment requiring removal of a post and core continue to be a challenging effort. Careful assessment of the length,diameters,design of the post and cementing agent are necessary to prevent the loss of the remaining tooth structure, root fracture or perforation during their removal.

Ultrasonics reduces the risk of developing cracks in the root when compared to other post removal systems. Ultrasound typically supplemented by pulling or trephinin devices is the most universally useful method for coronal disassembly. Ultrasonics(US) involves the initial removal of restorative materials and luting cement around the post, followed by application of the tip of an ultrasonic instrument to the post .Ultrasonic energy is transferred through the post and break down the cement until the post loosens. This method of post removal minimizes loss of tooth structure and decreases the risk of tooth damage. Synergistically, a piezoelectric generator in conjunction with a specific ultrasonic instrument may be utilized to transfer energy and potentially dislodge a post.[6]

Rotosonics is a straightforward method to potentially loosen and remove a fully exposed post. The Regular Tip Roto-Probur(Ellman International; Hewlett, New York) is a highspeed, friction grip bur whose six faces are joined by six edges and when rotated one revolution, its edges produce six vibrations per revolution. When the instrument is rotated at 200,000 RPM, it produces 1.2 million vibrations per minute or 20,000 vibrations per second. This instrument provides an inexpensive method to remove certain posts. The bur is kept in intimate contact with the obstruction and is generally carried counterclockwise around the post.[7]

Certain posts resist removal even after ultrasonic efforts using the “10-Minute Rule”. As such, clinicians need a safe and efficient fall-back position to liberate these posts.[3] Many post removal system are available e.g. Ruddle post removal system (Sybron Endo ) for the retrieval for such posts.[4]

Many of these devices, such as the Masserann kit (Micromega; Besançon,France) and the Post Puller (Brasseler USA; Savannah,Georgia) have had limited success because they frequently require the excessive removal of tooth structure, which predisposes to ledges, perforations or root fractures. The Gonon post extractor (EFDM-Pneumat; Bourge, France) represents a definite improvement over the Masserann and the Post Puller devices in that it is less invasive and has enjoyed good success, but regretfully, for a variety of reasons, by a limited number of clinicians. As such, the Post Removal System (PRS) kit (SybronEndo; Orange, California) was developed to provide significant improvements in simplicity, versatility and sizing during post removal procedures.[5]

CALCIFICATION

During retreatment Calcification of the canals is often encountered. Enhanced magnification and illumination are required to be able to visualize the calcified area. Ultrasonic tips are restricted to straight portion of canal to remove the calcified barrier.[6]

BROKEN INSTRUMENTS

During the root canal procedure, risk of instrument breakage/fracture exists. The breakage of the instrument provokes the considerable stress to the clinician. Many clinicians associate a “broken instrument” with a separated file, but the term could also apply to a sectioned silver point, a segment of a lentulo, a gates glidden drill, a portion of a carrier-based obturator, or any other device obstructing the canal.[7]

Management of a broken instrument requires an orthograde or a surgical approach. The three orthograde approaches are (a) attempt to remove the instrument; (b) attempt to bypass the instrument; and (c) prepare and obturate to the fractured segment.[8]In cases, removal of broken instruments from the root canal is difficult and often hopeless.[9] To date, no standardized procedure for the safe removal of fractured instruments exists, although various techniques and devices have been suggested.[10] These techniques have shown only limited success, while often causing considerable damage to the remaining root.(11)Complications as a result of these techniques include excessive loss of root canal dentin, ledging, perforation, and extrusion of the fractured instrument fragment through the apex. Therefore, many techniques cannot be used in narrow and curved canals. [12] Over the years, different techniques have been proposed for the removal of separated instruments from root canals. [11]Recent advances in endodontics have led to the development of techniques and devices designed specifically for the safe removal of fractured instruments from deep within narrow curved root canals.[13] Ruddle proposed a technique for the removal of broken instruments using Gates Glidden drills (size 3 or 4) to prepare a circumferential “staging platform” at the coronal aspect of the obstruction Attention must be paid during preparation of a staging platform, because a size 3 or 4 Gates Glidden may perforate or weaken root, for instance the mesial and distal root of mandibular molars, the distobuccal and mesiobuccal roots of maxillary molars and central and lateral mandibular incisors.[14] Their use seems safe in central and lateral maxillary incisors, maxillary and mandibular canines and mandibular premolars.[15,16]The literature is controversial with regard to maxillary premolars because of their particular anatomy.[17,18,19]

LASER IN RETREATMENT

Nd:YAP laser is a dental laser with a 1340 nm wavelength. Nd:YAP laser is a apparatus in which Yttrium aluminum perovskite is a synthetic crystal serving as a matrix for the neodyme ions . The wavelength is 1340 nm , and the absorption spectrum in water is 20 times the Nd:YAG laser spectrum(LokkiCo,Vienne, France) The laser beam is carried by a 2OOto 300 µm fiberoptic and is suitable for endodontic therapy. We used the Nd:YAP laser in an in vitro experiment to study its effectiveness in endodontic retreatment. Temperature measurements and

Irradiation parameters were first defined. Then Nd: YAP laser irradiation was used, alone or in combination with hand instruments, to remove various canal sealers and broken instruments. Clinical parameters were monitored and scanning electron microscopic observations were conducted. When used at 200 mJ-with a pulse duration of 150 ms, an exposure time of 1 s and a frequency of 10 Hz-Nd:YAP laser preserved the dentinal walls of the root canal and enabled root canal retreatment without thermic elevation harming periodontal tissue. lt is concluded that, in combination with hand instruments, the Nd: YAP laser is an effective device for root canal preparation in endodontic retreatment .Whereasthe manual retrieval technique works most successfully on fragments broken in the coronal third of the root, the Nd:YAP laser fibrooptic with a 200Clinical figureClinical figure m diameter can work in the apical third . The Nd:YAP laser can also be used when a fragment of the broken instrument is firmly blocked inside the canal and cannot be dislodged by an ultrasonic method. Similarly , laser can be considered for a broken silver cone , which cannot be reached or grasped with peetspinter forceps.[20] The Laser carried through an optic fiber of an adequate diameter can destroy the sealer by staying in contact with it without affecting the dentinal walls. Hand instrumentation eliminates the carbonized part of the sealer and enlarges the canal laterally without any vertical progression. To allow this progression, fiberoptic has to stay in contact with the filling material.[21]

REMOVAL OF GUTTAPERCHA

It is very important to remove sealer and Guttapercha during retreatment to uncover remnants of necrotic tissue or bacteria within the root canal system by through chemico mechanical preparation. Various studies have been used NiTi rotary instruments and hand K files to identify the optimal required technique. Loosened GuttaPercha can either pulled out by a Hedstroem file of suitable size or using Rotary files. A well condensed GuttaPercha filling must be first softened with heat, ultrasonic tips or solvents aiding in retrieval of the mass by specially designed Rotary files or hand files. Heat transfer devices like the system B, Endotec hand Spreader, EndoTwinn,E andQ Master, ‘Touch N Heat’(Sybron Endo), DownPack, Plugger (Hu-Friedy ) can be used.[2]

TECHNIQUE

To improve efficiency and safety a new concept Anatomic Endodontic Technology (AET Ultradent Product) has been introduced. The system is composed of two type of flexible stainless steel instruments. In this retreatment technology the coronal 2mm of the canals were enlarged with size 4 and 5 Gates –Glidden drills. A small amount of 0.1 ml chloroform is placed in the canal to soften the guttapercha. The canal is then negotiated with size 20 to 25 K hand files. Their flexible ends do not cut at the tip.[22]

The removal of obturating material from the apical 2mm was done with 2.5% taper especially designed hand files (sizes 10,20,30K files ) cutting only at the tip. The final apical enlargement is performed with sizes 1 and 2 shaping files. Chloroform id added as needed. Between the change of instruments canals were irrigated with saline. Retreatment was considered complete when size shaping file fit loosely in the canal at full working length.

Result showed no remaining obturation material in the coronal and middle thirds where as in the apical third significant remains of G.P and sealer remained.[22]

Different specially designed instruments along with their set of NiTi rotary instruments used as retreatment instruments are as follows:

1.Pro Taper Universal Retreatment Kit consists of three instruments which are

D1 File is a 30/0.09 NiTi (marked with one white ring) of 16mm in length used for removal of filling material from the coronal third of the root canal.

D2 File: is a 25/0.08 NiTi file (marked with two white rings) of 18mm in length used for removal of filling material from the middle third of the root canal.

D3 File: is a 20/0.07 NiTi file marked with three white rings) of 22mm in length used for removal of filling material from apical third of root canal (Dental tribune).[23]

2.R- Endo (Micro-Mega )

Instruments are made up from a round blank, and their cross-section is characterized by three equally spaced cutting edges. The instruments neither have radial lands nor active tip. Instruments are recommended to used at a speed of 300-400 rpm along with gutta-percha solvent. It contains six files named as Rm, Re, R1,R2, R3 and Rs. Rm File: is a stainless steel 25/.04 hand instrument with a 17mm length and a 12mm working tip .File is used in a quarter –turn motion and to dig or break the hard layer of filling material. This instrument allows the cetring and alignment of the next instrument. Re File is a 25/.12 NiTi file with a 15 mm working length and 10 mm cutting tip. It is used for eliminating the possible interference or dentine overhang and flaring the access space in order to increase the solvent quantity. The short length of this instrument allows removal of only 2-3mm of filling material from the coronal third.[23]

R1 File: is a 25/.08 NiTi file with a 15 mm working length and 8mm cutting tip. Designed for removal of filling material from the coronal –third.[23]

R2 File: is a 25/.06NiTi file with a 19mm working length 12mm cutting tip. It is designed for removal of filling material from the middle- third of the root canal. [23]

R3 File: is a 25/.04 NiTi file with a 25mm working length and 16 mm cutting tip cutting tip. This is to be used in the last for removal of filling material from the middle-third of the root canal. [23]

Rs File: is a 30/.04 NiTi file with a 15mm working length and 10 mm cutting tip. Is is designed to be used in cases that require further enlargement of apical diameter of the root canal.[23]

3.Mtwo Retreatment Kit (Sweden and Martina)M two instruments have an S-shaped cross-section ,an S-shaped cross-section , an increasing pitch length in the apical-coronal direction. Mtwo R 15/.05 and MtwoR25/.05, designed to reach the apex . They also have the advantage of shaping the root canal in an under prepared tooth, simultaneously.[23]

SOLVENTS

Dell Nina et al. reported that chloroform, xylene, eucalyptol, turpentine, ether, acetone and benzene softened gutta-percha after 30 minutes. Xylene was the most efficient and acetone and turpentine had the slowest action.(organic solvent) All instruments may facilitate the removal of most of the root filling, however some remnants of G.P require the use of a solvent. AH Plus is highly soluble in chloroform. Use of solvents particularly deep in the canal is safer and more effective than heat.[24]

ULTRASONICS

The combination of ultrasonic instruments with magnification and illumination provided by a clinical operating microscope is important, creating a specific protocol for gutta-percha removal during endodontic retreatment. Removal of guttapercha or other material has always been very long and exhausting .Now a days this operation is greatly simplified because of the thin tips that are available easily enter the canal obturation material enabling its removal. Various tips are available in the market by different manufactures. Piezoelectric unit have some advantages compared with earlier magnetostrictive units because they offer more cycles per second, 40 versus 24KHz. The tips of these unit work in a linear, back-and –forth, “piston –like” motion, which is ideal for endodontists. Lea et al demonstrated that the position of nodes and antinodes of an unconstrained and unloaded endosonic file activated by a 30- KHZ piezon generator was along the file length (25).As a result the file vibration displacement amplitude does not increase linearly with increasing generator power .This applies in particular when troughing for hidden canals or when removing post and separated instruments In addition ,this motion is ideal in surgical endodontics when creating a preparation for a retrograde filling . (26)

Application of US in retreatment cases- Finding calcified canals, Removal of intracanal obstructions (separated instruments , root canal posts , silver points , and fractured metallic posts), Increased action of irrigating solutions, Ultrasonic condensation of gutta- percha, Placement of MTA, Surgical endodontics: Root -end cavity preparation and refinement and placement of root-end obturation material in root canal preparations, access refinement and removal of attached pulp stone.[27]

DISCUSSION

A successful endodontic treatment requires the complete elimination of all debris from the root canal; this is conventionally performed using hand or mechanical instrumentation with chemical irrigation. Studies (28) have shown that endodontic instruments produce organic and mineral debris and are unable to remove them totally. Friedman et al compared four techniques that used combinations of hand or ultrasonic instrumentation with heat and chloroform and concluded that neither technique removed all debris and no removal technique was superior. In endodontic retreatment, these procedures are often tedious and time consuming. One of the main difficulties is the removal of insufficient root canal filling or obstacles. The common endodontic rule is that instruments should not be forced inside the canal. Fracture of root canal instruments is not an uncommon incident : evaluations of endodontic recall radiographs have indicated that the frequency of remaining fragments ranges from 2to 6%.[29]

Flare ups are more frequent in retreated teeth requiring minimal extrusion of debris and micro-organisms beyond the apical foramen. Technique using irrigants to flush debris from the canal and the use of a crown down preparation technique preventing forcing material and micro-organisms apically are preferred. As in decision making process cost benefit should be weighed against alternative options. The use of most suitable ultrasonic tips with good cutting ability at high power is increasingly being considered more suitable.[30,31]

Different hand and rotary instruments have been used for retreatment. Oliveira and colleagues concluded that epiphany /Resilon could be removed faster and with less residual filling material when K3 files or profile 0.06 combined with heat and chloroform were used.

After Cleaning and shaping an optional step is to use an ErCr YSGG Laser (Biolase Technology) to perform a final disinfection. Laser can penetrate deep into the dentinal tubules of root.[32]

CONCLUSION

Patient’s today expect to retain their natural dentition for life time. Dentists today are challenged to save teeth that in another era would have been extracted without question. Advances in endodontics retreatment allow practitioners to meet this challenge more predictably than ever before. The practitioner’s ability to accurately assess the restorative, endodontic, and periodontal outcomes will result in successful retreatment plans. Clinical application of a thorough knowledge of canal anatomy and meticulous attention to treatment detail are essential to minimizing failure and need for subsequent endodontic retreatment.

REFERENCES

  1. Plotino G, Pameijer C, Grande N and Somma F. Ultrasonics in endodontics: a review of the literature. J Endod 2007; 33(2):81-95
  2. Bindal D. Endodontic non-surgical retreatment techniques –A review. SRM J Res Dent Sci 2012;3(1):32-40
  3. Ruddle C J. Nonsurgical retreatment of endodontic failures: treatment concepts and failures. Advanced endodontics 2001:1-9
  4. Torabinejad M, Corr R, Handysides R, Shabahang S. Outcomes of nonsurgical retreatment and endodontic surgery: a systematic review. J Endod 2009;35(7):930-937
  5. Ruddle C J. Endodontic overfills: Good? Bad? Ugly? Dent today 1997; 13(2):1-5
  6. Althshul JM, Marshal, Marshal G, Morgan LA,Baumgartner JC.Comparison of dentinal crack incidence and of post removal time resulting from post removal by ultrasonic or mechanical force. J.Endod 1997;23: 683-687
  7. Ingle J, Bakland L, Baumgartner C. J. Ingle’s endodontic’s. 6th ed BC Decker Inc. Ontario,2008,pg 1088-1161
  8. Ward JR, Parashos P, Messer HH. Evaluation of an ultrasonic technique to remove fractured rotary nickel-titanium endodontic instruments from root canals: an experimental study. J Endod 2003;29:756–63
  9. Hulsmann M, Removal of silver cones and fractured instruments using the canal finder system .JEndod 1990;16:596-600
  10. Hulsmann M, Peters O & Dummer M.H P. Mechanical preparation of root canals: shaping goals, techniques and means. Endodontic Topics 2005;10:30–76
  11. Hulsmann M, Schinkel I. Influence of several factors on the success or failure of removal of fractured instruments from the root canal. Endod Dent Traumatol 1999;15:252– 8.
  12. Souter NJ, Messer HH. Complications associated with fractured file removal using an ultrasonic technique. J Endod 2005;31:450 –452.
  13. Ruddle CJ. Micro-endodontic non-surgical retreatment. Dent Clin North Am1997;41:429 –54.
  14. Wu MK, van der Sluis LW, Wesselink PR. The risk of furcal perforation in mandibular molars using Gates-Glidden drills with anticurvature pressure. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral RadiolEndod 2005;99:378–82.
  15. Tilk MA, Lommel TJ, Gerstein H. A study of mandibular and maxillary root widths to determine dowel size. J Endod 1979;5:79-82
  16. R, Tamse A. Residual dentin thickness in mandibular premolars prepared withGates Glidden and ParaPost drills. J Prosthet Dent 2000;83:617–23.
  17. Pilo R, Corcino G, Tamse A. Residual dentin thickness in mandibular premolarsprepared with hand and rotatory instruments. J Endod 1998;24:401– 4.
  18. Tamsa A, Katz A, Pilo R. Furcation groove of buccal root of maxillary first premolars: a morphometric study .J Endod 2000;26:359-63
  19. RaidenG,CostaL, KossS,Hernandez JL, Acenolaza V. Residual thickness of root in first maxillary premolars with post space preparation .J Endod1999;25:502-5
  20. Farge P, Nahas P, Bonin P: In Vitro study of Nd :YAP Laser in Endodontic retreatment J Endod1998 ; 24(5):24-28
  21. MiserendinoL J, Levy GC, Rizoiul M.Effectso f Nd:YAGlasero n the permeabi l i toyfrootcanalw al ldentin.J Endodon1 995;21:83-87
  22. F. Riitano. Anatomic Endodontic Technology (AET) – a crown-down root canal preparation technique: basic concepts, operative procedure and instruments. Int Endod J 2005; 38: 575–587
  23. Toricatoru A, Iliescu A, Precup L. The Comparative Analysis Of Manual And Rotary Techniques For Gutta-Percha And Sealer Removal. Rom J oral Rehab 2012; 4(4):17-21
  24. Martos J, Gastal MT, Sommer L, Lund RGL, Del Pino FAB, Osinaga PWR. Dissolving efficacy of organic solvents on root canal sealers. Clin Oral Invest. 2006;10:50-54
  25. Lea SC, WalmsleyAD, Lumley PJ, Landini G. A new insight into the oscillation characteristics of endosonic files used in dentistry .Phys Med Biol 2004;49:95-102
  26. Stock CJ. Current status of the use of ultrasound in endodontics. Int Dent J 1991;41:175-82
  27. Walmsely AD. Application of ultrasound in dentistry.Ultrasound Med Biol 1988;14:7-14
  28. Fairbourn D, Mc Walter G, Montgomery S. the effect of four preparation techniques on the amount of apically extruded debris. J Endod 1987; 13:102-107
  29. Friedman S, Stabholz A, Tamse A. Endodontic retreatment- case selection and technique. Part 3. Retreatment technique. J Endod 1990; 16:543-549
  30. Siqueira JF Jr. Microbial causes of endodontic flare ups. Int Endod J 2003;36:453-456
  31. Mozo S, Llena C and Leopoldo F. Review of ultrasonic irrigation in endodontics: increasing action of irrigating solutions. Med Oral Patol Oral Cir Bucal. 2012; 17(3): 512–516.
  32. Oliveira DP, Barbizam JV, Trope M. Comparison between gutta-percha and resilon removal using two different techniques in endodontic retreatment. J Endod 2006;32:362-364

Disclaimer from Guident

The views and opinions expressed in articles published in Guident are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the editors, the editorial board or the publisher, Ivory India. Guident does not endorse any product, technique or treatment described. Clinical content is intended for qualified dental and medical professionals and is not a substitute for individual clinical judgement. Guident, its editors and the publisher accept no liability for any consequence arising from the use of information published in the journal.

How to cite this article

Dr. Anil Dhingra, Dr. Nidhi. Revision of Root Canal. Guident. 2013 Dec;7(1). Available from: https://ivoryindia.in/articles/endodontics/revision-of-root-canal.html

Related articles

More in Endodontics

All 308 articles
Call for papers

Publish your clinical work in Guident

Original research, case reports and review articles are welcomed from clinicians and researchers worldwide. Every submission is assessed by the editorial board.