Biological, Biomechanical, and Toxicological Considerations of Orthodontic Ligation: A Narrative Review of Stainless Steel and Elastomeric Systems
Department of Orthodontics, Rural Dental College, PIMS (DU), Loni. Maharashtra
ABSTRACT
Background: Orthodontic ligation is a fundamental component of fixed appliance therapy, influencing both the mechanical efficiency of tooth movement and the biological environment of the oral cavity. Stainless steel ligatures and elastomeric modules are the most commonly used ligation systems, each demonstrating distinct material properties and clinical implications.
Objective: To critically evaluate and synthesize existing evidence on the microbiological, biochemical, biomechanical, and toxicological differences between stainless steel ligatures and elastomeric modules.
Methods: A narrative review of 14 studies published between 1991 and 2025 was conducted. The included studies comprised randomized clinical trials, split-mouth studies, systematic reviews, and in vitro investigations assessing microbial colonization, salivary parameters, frictional resistance, and material degradation associated with orthodontic ligation.
Results: Elastomeric modules were associated with increased plaque accumulation and higher levels of cariogenic microorganisms, including Streptococcus mutans.1,2 A reduction in salivary pH has also been reported, suggesting a shift toward an acidogenic environment.3 In vitro studies consistently demonstrated greater resistance to sliding with elastomeric modules compared to stainless steel ligatures, particularly under wet conditions.2,4,5 Evidence of trace element release from elastomeric materials has been observed, although typically within acceptable safety limits.6 Despite these findings, clinical alignment efficiency appeared comparable in certain phases of treatment.
Conclusion: Stainless steel ligatures demonstrate advantages in mechanical efficiency and biological compatibility, whereas elastomeric modules offer clinical convenience. The overall clinical outcome is multifactorial, and neither method can be considered universally superior.
Keywords: Orthodontic ligation, Stainless steel ligatures, Elastomeric modules, Resistance to sliding, Biofilm formation, Orthodontic friction, Material degradation.
INTRODUCTION
The success of fixed orthodontic treatment relies on the correct transmission of forces between the archwire and the bracket, with ligation fixing the wire and affecting both mechanical and biological responses.
Stainless steel (SS) ligatures are composed of a chromium-nickel-iron alloy. Passivation of SS leads to the formation of a stable surface layer of Cr2 O3 that is resistant to corrosion and protein adsorption. In contrast, elastomeric modules (EM) of polyurethane are susceptible to hydrolytic degradation and surface modifications favoring bacterial adhesion. SS ligatures provide strength, corrosion resistance, and precise archwire control, whereas EMs are widely used for ease of placement, reduced chairside time, and patient comfort. However, elastomeric materials degrade in the oral environment. Studies indicate increased plaque accumulation, altered salivary parameters, and higher frictional resistance with EMs.1-5
An integrated understanding is still lacking; this narrative review combines microbiological, biomechanical, and toxicological perspectives to clarify the clinical implications of different ligation methods.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Study Design
A narrative review of 14 studies (1991–2025) was conducted. Databases searched included PubMed, Scopus, and Google Scholar using predefined keywords. Studies included clinical trials, split-mouth designs, systematic reviews, and in vitro investigations.
No formal risk-of-bias assessment was performed due to the narrative nature of the review.
Inclusion Criteria
- Comparative evaluation of stainless steel ligatures and elastomeric modules
- Assessment of microbiological, biochemical, biomechanical, or toxicological outcomes
- Studies relevant to fixed orthodontic appliances
Exclusion Criteria
- Non-comparative studies
- Studies lacking methodological clarity
- Studies unrelated to orthodontic ligation
Data Synthesis
The included studies were analyzed qualitatively and categorized into 3 domains:
- Microbiological and biochemical effects
- Biomechanical behavior
- Toxicological considerations
Microbiological and Biochemical Effects
- Plaque Accumulation and Surface Characteristics
The material of the ligation system strongly influences bacterial adhesion. Stainless steel ligatures have a smooth, stable surface due to a passive chromium oxide layer, which limits corrosion and surface irregularities. In contrast, elastomeric modules, made of polyurethane, undergo hydrolytic degradation in the oral environment. Scanning electron microscopy studies show clear surface deterioration of elastomeric modules after intraoral use.
Sawhney et al. 14 describe a “scaffolding effect,” where elastomeric modules act as protected niches for acidogenic bacteria. This is supported by Condò et al.5, who used SEM and spectrophotometry to quantify “bacterial slime,” showing that EMs—even low-friction variants like Slide™—develop surface features that promote plaque retention more than metallic ligatures.
The slime layer (absorbance >0.5 OD in EM groups) acts as a barrier, limiting the buffering action of saliva. As a result, a localized acidic micro-niche forms, with pH dropping below the critical 5.5 level, contributing to the high incidence of white spot lesions reported by Sawhney [14].Clinical studies consistently show higher levels of Streptococcus mutans and Lactobacilli with elastomeric ligation compared to stainless steel ligatures1,2, both of which are closely linked to dental caries and white spot lesions.
Salivary Changes and Acidogenic Potential
Ligation methods may also affect salivary composition. Elastomeric modules have been associated with reduced salivary pH3, increasing the risk of enamel demineralization once the critical threshold for hydroxyapatite dissolution is crossed.However, salivary changes are multifactorial, influenced by oral hygiene, diet, and salivary flow. Thus, while ligation contributes, it is not the sole factor.
BIOMECHANICAL CONSIDERATIONS
Resistance to Sliding and Frictional Behavior
Orthodontic tooth movement involves complex interactions between the bracket, archwire, and ligation system. The ligation method influences this interaction by altering the normal force exerted on the archwire. Resistance to Sliding (RS) is the sum of three distinct physical components:
- Classical Friction (FR): Surface-to-surface contact between the wire and bracket.
- Binding (BI): Resistance created when the archwire flexes and contacts the corners of the bracket slot.
- Notching (NO): Permanent deformation of the wire at the bracket corner.
The choice of ligation material (SS vs. EM) primarily influences the Classical Friction component by modulating the "Normal Force" (Fn) applied to the wire. According to the formula FR = µ x Fn (where µ is the coefficient of friction), the high elasticity and compressive nature of elastomeric modules (EM) significantly elevate Fn compared to the passive or low-tension engagement of stainless steel (SS) ligatures.
A primary knowledge gap addressed here is why "Low-Friction" elastomers fail to match SS ligatures in vivo. Khasara et al.8 and the review by Sawhney 14 highlight Hygroscopic Expansion. Polyurethane is a polymer that absorbs moisture. When an EM is immersed in saliva, it undergoes a volume increase. In the confined space of a bracket tie-wing, this expansion results in an increased "clamping force" on the archwire. Stainless steel, being a non-absorbent metallic alloy, maintains a constant Fn, thereby preserving the "play" in the slot necessary for efficient sliding.
Elastomeric modules apply a continuous elastic force that presses the archwire into the bracket slot, increasing resistance to sliding. While, stainless steel ligatures can be adjusted for minimal or maximal engagement, offering better control over frictional forces.
Experimental Evidence
In vitro studies using universal testing machines consistently show higher frictional forces with elastomeric modules than with SS ligatures2,4,5, especially under wet conditions simulating the oral environment.
Clinical Relevance
An important observation is the “Alignment Paradox” described by Javaid and Gul12 and Hussain.13 Despite clear mechanical advantages of SS ligatures in laboratory settings, clinical alignment time in mild crowding often shows no significant difference. This suggests that the biological ceiling of bone remodeling—driven by osteoclast and osteoblast activity—limits the effect of mechanical superiority in simpler cases. However, during complex retraction or space closure, where friction is critical, the advantages of SS ligatures may become more evident. This highlights the role of biological factors such as periodontal ligament response and bone remodeling in compensating for mechanical differences.
Toxicological Considerations
Olszewska et al.1, using Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry (ICP-MS), reported that elastomeric modules can release trace elements like cadmium, lead, and tin under simulated conditions.6 Although within acceptable limits, long-term exposure remains a concern. Stainless steel ligatures show minimal ion release, indicating greater chemical stability.
Limiting the use of colored elastomeric modules in children may reduce chronic trace element exposure. Around temporary anchorage devices, elastomers may increase plaque accumulation and peri-implant inflammation, where stainless steel ligation could be a more biologically stable option.
Discussion
This review demonstrates that ligation methods influence both biological and mechanical aspects of orthodontic treatment. Elastomeric modules are associated with increased microbial colonization, reduced salivary pH, and higher frictional resistance. Stainless steel ligatures provide superior control over mechanical forces and exhibit greater material stability.
Table 1.
|
Author (Year) |
Study Design |
Sample |
Outcome Assessed |
Key Findings |
Clinical Relevance |
|
Olszewska A (2020) |
In vitro |
Orthodontic materials |
Trace element release |
Elastomers released trace elements under simulated conditions |
Potential long-term biocompatibility concerns with elastomers |
|
Akgun OM (2014) |
Clinical study |
Miniscrew-supported patients |
Miniscrew failure |
Higher failure rates associated with elastomers |
Steel ligatures may improve anchorage stability |
|
Türkkahraman H (2005) |
Clinical study |
Orthodontic patients |
Plaque, periodontal status |
Increased plaque and decreased salivary pH with elastomers |
Higher caries and gingival inflammation risk |
|
Bhagchandani J (2015) |
Clinical study |
Orthodontic patients |
Microbial colonization |
Elastomers showed higher bacterial adhesion |
Reinforces need for strict oral hygiene |
|
Condò R (2012) |
In vitro |
Orthodontic materials |
Surface degradation |
Elastomers showed structural degradation over time |
Material breakdown may affect performance |
|
Al-Haifi HAA (2021) |
Clinical study |
Orthodontic patients |
Microbial load |
Increased microbial accumulation with elastomers |
Risk of biofilm-related complications |
|
Desai H (2019) |
Clinical study |
Orthodontic patients |
Oral hygiene parameters |
Poorer hygiene indices with elastomers |
Patient compliance becomes critical |
|
Khasara A (2024) |
Review |
Literature |
Material performance |
Variability in elastomeric material behavior |
Need for standardized material evaluation |
|
Forsberg CM (1991) |
Clinical study |
Orthodontic patients |
Microbial colonization |
Higher S. mutans with elastomers vs steel ligatures |
Strong evidence favoring steel biologically |
|
Joshi R (2021) |
Clinical study |
Miniscrew cases |
Anchorage stability |
Elastomeric chain increased miniscrew failure risk |
Steel ligatures preferred in TAD cases |
|
Chen H (2019) |
Clinical study |
Orthodontic patients |
Friction & efficiency |
Elastomers increased frictional resistance |
May slow tooth movement efficiency |
|
Javaid A (2025) |
Clinical study |
Orthodontic patients |
Periodontal health |
Increased inflammation with elastomers |
Steel ligatures safer for periodontal patients |
|
Hussain U (2024) |
Clinical study |
Orthodontic patients |
Treatment efficiency |
Comparable alignment but different biomechanics |
Choice depends on treatment stage |
|
Sawhney R (2018) |
Review |
Literature |
Microbial colonization |
Elastomers consistently show higher biofilm formation |
Confirms long-term biological concerns |
However, the clinical relevance of these findings is influenced by multiple variables. Patient compliance, oral hygiene, and treatment mechanics play significant roles in determining outcomes.
Table 2.
|
Factor |
Stainless Steel |
Elastomeric |
|
Plaque retention |
Low |
High |
|
Salivary pH |
Stable |
Decreased |
|
Friction |
Low |
High |
|
Material stability |
High |
Degrades |
|
Toxicity risk |
Minimal |
Trace element release |
The available evidence is limited by methodological variability and a predominance of in vitro studies. Long-term clinical trials remain scarce.
Critical Appraisal
Strengths
- Inclusion of multiple study designs
- Comprehensive evaluation across domains
- Broad temporal coverage
Limitations
- Predominance of in vitro data
- Limited long-term clinical evidence
- Variability in methodology
Clinical Implications
- Stainless steel ligatures may be preferred for sliding mechanics and periodontal considerations
- Elastomeric modules provide convenience and efficiency
- Oral hygiene remains critical regardless of ligation method
CONCLUSION
Both ligation methods offer distinct advantages and limitations. Stainless steel ligatures demonstrate favorable mechanical and biological properties, while elastomeric modules offer clinical convenience. Treatment outcomes depend on multiple factors, and neither method is universally superior.
REFERENCES
- Olszewska A et al. Metals and metalloids release from orthodontic elastomeric and stainless steel ligatures: In vitro risk assessment of human exposure. Biol Trace Elem Res. 2020;196:646–653.
- Akgun OM, Altug H, Karacay S, Polat GG, Duyan S, Bedir O. Effect of 2 elastomeric ligatures on microbial flora and periodontal status in orthodontic patients. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 2014;145:667–671.
- Türkkahraman H et al. Archwire ligation techniques, microbial colonization, and periodontal status in orthodontically treated patients. Angle Orthod. 2005;75(2):231–236.
- Bhagchandani J et.al . Microbial colonization around orthodontic ligature ties: An in vivo study. APOS Trends Orthod. 2015;5:201–205.
- Condò R et al, Plaque retention on elastomeric ligatures: An in vivo study. J Oral Implantol. 2012;4:92–98.
- Al-Hain et.al,Salivary pH changes under the effect of stainless steel versus elastomeric ligatures in fixed orthodontic patients: A single-center randomized controlled clinical trial. BMC Oral Health. 2021;21:544.
- Desai H et.al, Comparison of friction in sliding mechanics using different ligation methods on ceramic bracket with metal slot and epoxy resin-coated stainless steel esthetic wire: An in vitro study. J Indian Orthod Soc. 2019;53:101–108.
- Khasara A, et al. Difference in frictional resistance between ligature wire and elastic module (an in vitro study). Arab J Sci Publ. 2024;64:45–53.
- Forsberg CM, Brattström V, Malmberg E, Nord CE. Ligature wires and elastomeric rings: Two methods of ligation, and their association with microbial colonization of Streptococcus mutans and lactobacilli. Eur J Orthod. 1991;13:416–420.
- Joshi R et.al, Evaluation and comparison of the effect of elastomeric chain and stainless steel ligature wire on maxillary orthodontic miniscrew failure. Int J Appl Basic Med Res. 2021;11:100–105.
- Chen H et.al, Effect of different combinations of bracket, archwire and ligature on resistance to sliding and axial rotational control during the first stage of orthodontic treatment: An in vitro study. Korean J Orthod. 2019;49:21–31.
- Javaid A, Gul P. Comparison of alignment efficiency of steel versus elastomeric ligatures in lower anterior teeth: A randomized clinical trial. Pak J Health Sci. 2025;6(7):32–36.
- Hussain U et.al, Influence of elastomeric and steel ligatures on periodontal health during fixed appliance orthodontic treatment: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Prog Orthod. 2024;25:24.
- Sawhney R et.al , Microbial colonization on elastomeric ligatures during orthodontic therapeutics: An overview. Turk J Orthod. 2018;31:21–25.
Disclaimer from Guident
The views and opinions expressed in articles published in Guident are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the editors, the editorial board or the publisher, Ivory India. Guident does not endorse any product, technique or treatment described. Clinical content is intended for qualified dental and medical professionals and is not a substitute for individual clinical judgement. Guident, its editors and the publisher accept no liability for any consequence arising from the use of information published in the journal.
How to cite this article
Dr. Shubhangi Mani, Dr. N. G. Toshniwal, Dr. Eva Maria Saji. Biological, Biomechanical, and Toxicological Considerations of Orthodontic Ligation: A Narrative Review of Stainless Steel and Elastomeric Systems. Guident. 2026 Oct;19(11). Available from: https://ivoryindia.in/articles/orthodontics/biological-biomechanical-and-toxicological-considerations-of-orthodontic-ligation-a-narrative-review-of.html







