Soft Tissue Profile Changes Associated with Maxillary Anterior Retractionsoft Tissue Profile Changes Associated with Maxillary Anterior Retraction
A.B. Shetty Memorial Institute of Dental Science, Mangalore, India
ABSTRACT
The soft -tissue drape of the face plays an important role in the facial esthetics, speech and other physiologic functions. The orthodontist is often confronted with the need to predict soft-tissue profile changes that may result from orthodontic treatment.
The objectives of this study were to quantify the profile changes occurring in a diverse sample of orthodontic patients treated with extraction of the four first premolars and to evaluate the aesthetic consequences of these changes.
MATERIAL AND METHODS Standardized pre-treatment and post-treatment lateral cephalograms of each individual subject were obtained. 11 soft tissue, dental & skeletal measurements were traced using cephalomentric landmarks and analysed.
RESULTS:
Significant change was found in the pre-treatment and post-treament nasolabial angle, mentolabial angle, upper lip thickness and interlabial gap following maxillary incisor retraction. A definite positive correlation exist between maxillary anterior teeth retraction with upper lip change.
KEYWORDS: Soft tissue changes, Nasolabial angle, Mentolabial angle, Lip thickness, Interlabial gap.
INTRODUCTION
The soft -tissue drape of the face plays an important role in the facial esthetics, speech and other physiologic functions. Hence success of an orthodontic treatment is closely tied to the changes in the soft tissue profile of the face, and mechanotherapy directed solely toward obtaining a functional occlusion may compromise facial esthetic in some patients.1
A major motivation for seeking orthodontic treatment is a desire to improve dental and facial aesthetics. The orthodontist is often confronted with the need to predict soft-tissue profile changes that may result from orthodontic treatment. The problem arises because the contribution of many of the factors influencing the soft-tissue profile is not fully understood.
The soft tissue of the face is a mask overlying a skeletal framework that is affected by dental and osseous changes. It is variably influenced by the amount, direction, and location of forces acting on the underlying hard tissues2.
Hard tissue changes in the perioral region can affect the lip, nose, and chin areas. Changing the inclination and position of the teeth, either by protraction or retraction, directly influences the overlying soft tissue, particularly the lips2.
However, it is a debatable issue whether or not there is an exact relationship between the changes in hard and soft tissue3. Current orthodontic literature can be categorized into two major schools of thought. Some studies have reported a high degree of correlation between upper incisor and lip retraction, suggesting a close relationship between soft tissue and the underlying hard tissue 4-7. Others have found that a definite proportional change in the soft tissue does not necessarily follow changes in the dentition 8-13.
The purpose of this retrospective study was to quantify the soft tissue profile changes that take place in bimaxillary protrusion cases treated with extraction of all four 1st premolars and to evaluate the esthetic consequences of these changes.
MATERIALS AND METHODS:
Study was carried out on 85 patients visiting the Dental Colleges in and around Mangalore. The study material comprised of lateral cephalograms of these patients.
Standardized pre-treatment and post-treatment lateral cephalograms of each individual subject were obtained. Lateral cephalograms were traced on to 0.003 inch acetate paper using 0.5mm lead pencil under same illumination. A single operator performed all the tracings in a standardized manner to avoid errors due to inter operator variations. Linear measurements were made to 0.5 mm and angular measurements were made to 0.5° accuracy.
CEPHALOMETRIC ANALYSIS
The following skeletal, dental and soft-tissue landmarks were identified for the study (Fig.1).
Skeletal:
- Sella (S): Centre of the contour of sellaturica.
- Nasion (N): Most anterior point on the nasofrontal suture in the midsaggital plane.
- Point A (A): Deepest point in the midsaggital plane between anterior nasal spine and prosthion.
- Point B (B): Deepest point in the midsaggital plane between infradentale and pogonion.
SOFT TISSUE AND DENTAL
- Subnasal (Sn): The point of convergence of the nose and the upper lip.
- Upper incisor point (UIP): Most anterior point on the crown of the upper incisor.
- Lower incisor point (LIP): Most anterior point on the crown of the lower incisor.
- Labralesuperius (Ls): The most anterior point on the convexity of the upper lip.
- Labraleinferius (Li): The most anterior point on the convexity of the lower lip.
- Soft tissue pogonion (Pg’): The most anterior point of the soft tissue chin.
- Subnasale (Sn): Point at the junction of the collumella and the upper lip.
- Sulcus superior (Ss): Point of greatest concavity in the midline between labrale superior and subnasale.
- Sulcus inferior (Si): Point of greatest convexity in the midline between laberale inferior and soft-tissue pogonion.
Reference line:
PM is a vertical line marking the posterior margin of the maxilla.
SOFT TISSUE MEASUREMENTS
- Nasolabial angle: Formed by the intersection of the line originating at Sn, tangent to the lower border border of the nose, and a line from Sn to Ls
- Labiomental angle: Formed by intersection of a line drawn between Li and Si, and a line drawn between Si and Pg’.
- Linear horizontal change of labialesuperiorus: Measured horizontally from PM to Ls.
- Upper lip thickness: It is measured horizontally from a point on the outer alveolar plate 2mm below point A to the outer border of the lip.
- Vermilion lip thickness: Measured horizontally from the vermillion border of the upper lip to labial surface of the maxillary incisor.
- Lip strain: The difference between the upper lip thickness and vermillion lip thickness.
- Interlabial gap: The vertical distance between the upper and lower lips.
DENTAL & SKELETAL MEASUREMENTS
- Upper incisor inclination: The anterior angle between the long axis of the upper incisor and the palatal plane.
- Lower incisor inclination: The posterior angle between the posterior angle between the long axis of the incisor and the mandibular plane.
- Horizontal position of maxillary incisor edge: The distance from PM to UIP.
- Facial convexity: The angle between the line joining N-A and A-Pog.
RESULTS
The data was collected, tabulated and analyzed using SPSS 16.0. Test of Normality and Wilcoxons sign rank test was performed to check the significance of the values. Spearmans correlation test was carried out to find the correlation between the parameters. Simple linear regression was carried out to predict the post treatment changes.
It was found that the mean retraction of the upper incisors was 5.59mm and the mean retraction of labralesuperius was 3.26mm. The mean change in nasolabial angle was 6.45 (6.22, 6.69), indicating an increase after treatment.
The Spearman’s correlation test showed moderate correlation between the change in nasolabial angle and upper incisor retraction (r=0.51) and labralesuperius retraction (r=0.51).
According to Simple linear regression test, for every 1mm of incisor retraction, there was change of 0.390 (R2= 0.25) in the nasolabial angle. Similarly for every 1mm of labralesuperius retraction, there was change of 0.800 (R2= 0.27) in the nasolabial angle.
The mean change in mentolabial angle was 6.47 (6.23, 6.70), indicating an increase after treatment. According to Simple linear regression test, for every 1mm of incisor retraction, there was change of 0.380 (R2= 0.25) in the mentolabial angle. Similarly for every 1mm of labralesuperius retraction, there was change of 0.770 (R2= 0.26) in the mentolabial angle.
The mean change in the upper lip thickness was 1.69 (1.44, 1.94), indicating an increase after treatment. The mean change in the lip strain was -3.90 (-4.07, -3.73), indicating a decrease after treatment.
DISCUSSION
Great majority of earlier studies tried to explain the complex nature of soft tissue profile change in response to orthodontic tooth movement by establishing numeric ratios between changes in some soft tissue measurement and changes taking place in some dental and skeletal parameters as a result of orthodontic treatment.13Some studies have reported a high degree of correlation between upper incisor and lip retraction, suggesting a close relationship between soft tissue and the underlying hard tissue 4-7. Others have found that a definite proportional change in the soft tissue does not necessarily follow changes in the dentition 8-13.
The traditional way of looking at the upper lip retraction was to relate it directly to the amount of maxillary incisor retraction that took place during orthodontic treatment. In agreement with all previous studies, the present study showed that orthodontic treatment, including an average retraction of the maxillary incisors of 5.59 mm, caused the upper lip to retract by an average of 3.26 mm. The ratio between the upper incisor retraction and labralesuperius retraction was 1.7:1. This means that for every 1.7mm of upper incisor retraction, the upper lip falls back by 1mm.
These results agree with previous study by Caplan and Shivapuja30 where the ratio was 1.75:1. Study by Lo and Hunter31 showed a higher mean retraction ratio of 2.5:1. However this study did not agree with Diels7 who found that the upper lip retracted approximately 1mm for every 3mm of upper incisor retraction. Another study by Waldman25 showed a ratio of 3.8:1.
The low predictability of the upper lip response to orthodontic tooth movement may be attributed to the complex 3-dimensional anatomy of the upper lip – nose complex that cannot be well analysed on an image such as cephalogram. Also the influence of body fat on lip thickness might also be a factor in lip response. Statistical assessment of this postulate was beyond the scope of the present investigation but warrants further investigation.
Burstone8 mentioned that the layman was likely to observe the facial balance in terms of upper lip protrusion in relation to the nose. He thought that it might be useful to measure the protrusion of the upper lip relative to the inferior border of the nose. This can be assessed in terms of changes in the nasolabial angle. This is the angle formed between a tangent to the lower border of the nose and a line joining the subnasale with the labralesuperius.
In this study, nasolabial angle increased significantly (6.450), which is in agreement with the previous studies by Talass13, Waldman25, Ramos26, Lo and Hunter31, Lew32, Kusnoto and Kusnoto33, and Conley34. However, this should be dealt with caution since there is great individual variability which is found in most of the aforementioned studies.
When the upper lip follows the incisors it actually pulls the subnasale areas forward and downward slightly causing an increase in the slope of the lower nasal border.31 According to Subtenly9, as the nose grows the lower border tends to tip forward and downward slightly which may decrease the nasolabial angle. Although the nasolabial angle does not change significantly with growth, it increases with the amount of maxillary incisor edge retraction.The present study revealed that orthodontic treatment opened up Mentolabial angle (MLA) by6.470 which is less than Kusnoto and Kusnoto33 where MLA increased by 7.250.
Change of the protrusive lower lip could achieve facial ‘‘balance’’ and ‘‘harmony’’ by bringing about a change in the MLA. However, the behavior of lower lip change mainly depended on the upper incisor position, compared to the lower incisor. Thus, the retraction of upper incisor and subsequent retraction of upper and lower lip may have remarkable influence on the MLA.
A better understanding of the role that lip thickness and lip strain play in the relationship of osseous, dental and soft tissue changes subsequent to orthodontic treatment could be obtained by studies aimed at separating growth factors from orthodontic treatment. Soft tissue may vary in thickness and postural tone to allow the response of soft tissue to hard tissue retraction to be different in different patients. Maxillary lip thickness and postural tone might play a role in predicting soft tissue changes subsequent to orthodontic retraction of maxillary incisors20.
A mean change of 1.69mm in the upper lip thickness was noticed. The same was reported by Ricketts17. On the other hand, Talasset. al.13 reported greater value (2.3 mm), whereas Hershey18 and Ramos et. al.26, noticed decrease in the thickness. However no correlation was found between upper lip thickness and incisor retraction norlabralesuperius retraction.
Wisth12 found that lip response to the increasing lip retraction was increasingly weaker, i.e, the lips is decreasingly influenced by the retraction of the incisor after a certain point. A study by Looi and Mills35 noted that thickness of upper lip reduced slightly during the follow up period. This corresponds to the amount of relapse of the incisor teeth that were presumably slightly over retracted relative to the soft tissue. He also suggested that thin lips follow changes in hard tissues more closely than thick lips.
According to Oliver BM20, lip strain is the incompetency present as the patient closes his lips over protrusive teeth. Holdaway’s15 studies have shown that retraction on the maxillary lip does not follow tooth retraction until the factor of lip strain has been eliminated. Lip strain being assessed by evaluating the difference in lip thickness of upper lip compared to that at the vermillion border.
In this study the mean change in the lip strain is found to be -3.90mmand no correlation was found between lip strain and thickness and incisor retraction norlabralesuperius retraction.
The interlabial gap exhibited minimal mean change of -1.57 mm, but was statistically significant. This could be explained due to minimal average pretreatment interlabial gap (1.87mm). Little profile change is expected when there is small interlabial gap to start with regardless of the amount of tooth retraction.36If the patient has short upper lip, the amount of change in the interlabial gap after incisor retraction is minimal.
CONCLUSION
According to the study the following conclusion can be drawn;
- Definite positive correlation exist between maxillary anterior teeth retraction with upper lip change. For every 1mm of maxillary incisor retraction, the upper lip falls back by 0.6mm.
- Significant change was found in the pre-treatment and post-treatment nasolabial angle following maxillary incisor retraction with a moderate correlation between the two. For every 1mm of labralesuperius retraction, there was change of 0.800 (R2= 0.27) in the nasolabial angle.
- Significant change was found in the pre-treatment and post-treatment mentolabial angle following maxillary incisor retraction with a moderate correlation between the two. For every 1mm of labralesuperius retraction, there was change of 0.770 (R2= 0.26) in the mentolabial angle.
- Significant change was found in the pre-treatment and post-treatment upper lip thickness, vermillion lip thickness and lip strain following maxillary incisor retraction, with no correlation between these parameters and incisor retraction.
- Significant change was found in the pre-treatment and post-treatment interlabial gap following maxillary incisor retraction with a weak correlation between the two.
REFERENCES
- Rains MD, Nanda R. Soft tissue changes associated with maxillary incisor retraction. AmJ Orthod 1982; 81:481-8.
- Brock RA. Ethnic differences in upper lip response toincisor retraction. Am J OrthodDentofacialOrthop 2005;127:683-91.
- Kasai K. Soft tissue adaptability to hard tissues in facialprofiles. Am J OrthodDentofacialOrthop. 1998;113:674–684.
- Riedel R. Esthetics and its relation to orthodontic therapy. Angle Orthod. 1950; 20: 168-178.
- Rudee DA. Proportional profile changes concurrent with orthodontic therapy. Am JOrthod. 1964; 50: 421-434.
- Bloom LA. Perioral profile changes in orthodontic treatment. Am J Orthod. 1961; 47:3 71.
- Diels MR, Kalra V, DeLoach N, Powers M, Nelson SS. Changes in soft tissue profile ofAfrican-Americans following extraction treatment. Angle Orthod1995;(4): 285-292.
- Burstone CJ. The in tegumental profile. Am J Orthod. 1958; 44: 1-25.
- Subtelny JD. The soft tissue profile, growth and treatment changes. Angle Orthod1961;31: 105-122.
- Neger M. A quantitative method for the evaluation of the soft tissue facial profile. Am JOrthod. 1959; 45: 738.
More References are available on request
Disclaimer from Guident
The views and opinions expressed in articles published in Guident are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the editors, the editorial board or the publisher, Ivory India. Guident does not endorse any product, technique or treatment described. Clinical content is intended for qualified dental and medical professionals and is not a substitute for individual clinical judgement. Guident, its editors and the publisher accept no liability for any consequence arising from the use of information published in the journal.
How to cite this article
Dr. RINKOO JOSE, Dr. AKHIL SHETTY, Dr. U.S. KRISHNA NAYAK Department of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics. Soft Tissue Profile Changes Associated with Maxillary Anterior Retractionsoft Tissue Profile Changes Associated with Maxillary Anterior Retraction. Guident. 2016 Feb;9(3). Available from: https://ivoryindia.in/articles/orthodontics/soft-tissue-profile-changes-associated-with-maxillary-anterior-retractionsoft-tissue-profile-changes.html






