Biomechanical Considerations in Endodontically Treated Teeth. a Successful Endodontics Treatment Is Not Game over!
Academy of Advanced Endodontics, Bangalore
A Successful Endodontic treatment is not Game Over!
Abstract
There is a preponderance of literature assessing and comparing the advantages and drawbacks of post endodontic restorative materials including intra radicular posts, core materials, alloplastic restorative materials and full crown prosthesis. However, there has been inadequate documentation regarding the changes occuring within the hard tissues of the tooth subsequent to root canal therapy, inspite of it being an equally important factor in selecting the choice of restoration and long term prognosis. This lack of correlation has led to the restoration of endodontically treated teeth being a completely empirical approach rather than being based on biomechanically driven concepts. The aim of this article is to review the literature for assessing the biomechanical changes occuring within the hard tissues of an endodontically treated tooth, which notably affects the choice of materials used subsequently and the final prognosis.
INTRODUCTION
Endodontic treatment is chiefly performed on teeth significantly affected by caries, multiple repeat restorations and/or fracture. Already impaired structurally, such teeth are often further weakened by the necessity to provide an optimal access and by the numerous restorative procedures undertaken to bring the tooth back in function. Hence, not much doubt exists in accepting endodontically treated teeth weaker, with a lower lifetime prognosis and requiring special considerations for its final restoration, particularly where there has been extensive loss of tooth structure. The special needs involve ensuring both adequate retention for the final restoration and maximum resistance to tooth fracture. This, in turn, entails detailed knowledge of the factors affecting the individual tooth, both at the macroscopic and microscopic level, following endodontic therapy.
METHODS
This article is a review of literature published in various indexed and peer reviewed journals and is the author’s interpretation of the same. The purpose of this review is to organize this topic into its component parts and provide evidence-based principles that are sound from a restorative as well as an endodontic perspective. The literature was digitally searched in dental journals using PubMed and MedLine. This particular review article focuses primarily on recent publications, although some of the classic literature also has been considered and discussed.
DISCUSSION
For dentists practicing root canal treatment, the bulk of the focus shifts to the periapical region, elimination of infection and achieving the perfect apical and coronal seal to prevent reinfection. Once the subjective symptoms have disappeared and periapical pathology shows signs of healing, the treating dentist has a tendency to become lax and dismiss the case as a success. However, the true success depends on the long term stability of the tooth in the oral cavity, with regards to form, function and esthetics.
In a study conducted in a busy military clinic over a period of one year to analyse the reason for all extractions of endodontically treated teeth, it was revealed that almost 60% of these were unrestorable tooth fractures, 32% involved periodontal problems and only 7% were endodontic failures. This clearly implies that post endodontic restoration is as vital to the long term prognosis of a tooth as endodontic therapy per se.
Another survey of dentists’ philosophies and techniques of restoring pulpless tooth conducted in the United States of America (U.S.A.) revealed that approximately 50 per cent of the respondents believed that a post would reinforce an endodontically treated tooth. Although many professionals strongly believe that posts could strengthen teeth, contemporary studies have proved time and again that root posts are used only to retain a core when coronal structure is unable to do so.
But what this study brings to the limelight is that many practical questions and controversies still exist in the practioner’s mind regarding many clinically vital elements of the treatment plan and the availability of widely diverse published opinions is unfortunately confusing and may lead to less than optimal treatment plan selections. In such a case, the dental professional may be wise in assessing each individual tooth and its biomechanical properties to arrive at an individualized treatment plan rather than rely on erroneous interpretations and algorithms for treatment derived under different controlled circumstances.
ARE ENDODONTICALLY TREATED TEETH DIFFERENT?
To correctly answer the above question, it is imperative to have a look at the macroscopic and microscopic changes occuring in the tooth after endodontic therapy.
Macroscopic Properties
Coronal tooth structure
Root canal treated teeth often have extensive restorations and are also further weakened by access preparation which destroys the pulpal roof and allows for greater flexing of the tooth under function. The decreased strength observed in root canal treated teeth is because of this loss of coronal tooth structure and not directly as a result of the endodontic treatment. There is a direct relationship between the amount of remaining tooth structure and the ability of a tooth to resist occlusal forces. As the remaining tooth tissue decreases, the possibility of fracture increases. Coronal tooth structure should be preserved to provide resistance and retention form for the crown.
Radicular tooth structure
Gates-Glidden burs and several other root preparation files, recommended for preparation of the coronal 4 mm of the root canal may also cause unnecessary loss of tooth structure. Preparation of a post space by Peeso reamers should necessitate minimal removal over the conventional preparation of radicular dentin. Further enlargement only weakens the root and renders it susceptible to fracture even with the most ideal of the posts recommended for that clinical situation. Fatigue studies have clearly demonstrated the importance of tissue conservation and presence of ferrule effect to optimize tooth biomechanical behaviour; therefore when enough tooth structure is present, a post is not needed. Thus, when meticulous attention is placed on conservative preparation of the tooth, posts would not be unneccesarily needed.
FERRULE EFFECT
In clinical situations where greater coronal tooth structure has been lost and a post is necessary to retain a core, the presence of vertical tooth structure will provide a ferrule effect that is important to long-term success, contributing to load distribution, improving stability and rotation resistance. A minimum sound dentin height of 1.5-2 mm is required between the core and crown margins. This ensures that the final restoration provides a bracing, casing or hugging action which improves the integrity of the endodontically treated tooth.
Where inadequate ferrule exists, occlusal stresses are transferred directly to the core and/or post with high likelihood of tooth, root or post fracture or post dislodgement. In cases where inadequate ferrule is noticed, any heroics to perform elective endodontic treatment and anticipate retention from the root only, should be avoided. Such cases are doomed to fail unless measures such as crown lengthening, forced orthodontic eruption or re-estabilishment of biologic width procedures, in an attempt to gain vertical tooth structure are incorporated in the treatment plan.
CUSPAL DEFLECTION
As discussed above, root canal treatment may be the result of previous extensive restorative procedures that have weakened the tooth. A study carried out in vitro showed that a conventional access preparation reduced cuspal stiffness by only 5%, whereas cutting a mesio–occlusal–distal (MOD) cavity, thereby involving both marginal ridges, reduced stiffness by 63% suggesting that root canal treatment per se does not weaken the tooth. The extent of cuspal deflection following restorative and endodontic procedures related directly to tooth fracture. This emphasizes again the importance of sound tooth structure and more importantly, the preservation of the marginal ridge in posterior teeth, for the long term resistance of both tooth and restoration and ensuring long term stability to the tooth.
MICROSCOPIC PROPERTIES
Brittleness
Several classic studies have proposed that the dentin in endodontically treated teeth is substantially different than dentin in teeth with “vital” pulps. It was thought that the dentin in endodontically treated teeth was more brittle because of water loss and loss of collagen cross-linking. However, more recent studies dispute this finding.
A study comparing the physical and mechanical properties of dentin specimens from teeth with and without endodontic treatment at different levels of hydration, concluded that neither dehydration nor endodontic treatment caused degradation of the physical or mechanical properties of dentin.
In another study, the moisture content of vital and endodontically treated teeth was compared in matched pairs of contralateral human teeth extracted for prosthodontic reasons. It was found that vital dentin had a moisture content of 12.35% whilst dentin from endodontically treated teeth had a moisture content of 12.10%. These results indicated that there was no significant difference in the moisture content between endodontically treated teeth and vital teeth.
Compressive strength
In one study, the values of compressive strength of wet dentin from normal vital teeth ranged from 37,200 to 46,700 psi for crown portions and 28,500 to 49,000 psi for root portions. The values of compressive strength of dentin from treated pulpless teeth ranged from 31,600 to 54,000 psi for crown portions and 25,200 to 48,900 psi for root portions. There was no significant difference in the compressive strengths between the treated pulpless teeth and normal vital teeth based upon the evaluation of the ranges and the statistical tests.
Tensile strength
In the same study, indirect tensile strength was measured. The values of indirect tensile strength of root dentin from normal vital teeth range from 6,440 to 10,650 psi. The values of indirect tensile strength of root dentin from treated pulpless teeth range from 5,830 to 11,530 psi. In this study, the statistical analysis revealed no significant difference between the two groups.
Plastic deformation
The Young's modulus and proportional limit in compression appeared to be lower for pulpless dentin samples. An interesting phenomenon observed in this study was that the stress-strain curves in compression of the wet dentin specimens from treated pulpless teeth exhibited greater plastic deformation than did those from normal vital teeth. These wet dentin specimens could be compressed in length by 15 to 25% before failure.
This phenomenon may lead to the assumption that, after the endodontic treatment, some of the teeth may become more plastic and hence have lower strength. However, this factor played a minor role in reducing the tooth strength as compared to extensive tooth destruction.
Some common myths and beliefs debunked
1. Endodontic treated teeth are weaker.
Fact – As has been suggested in the article above, teeth that require endodontic intervention are weakened by the caries and restorative procedure before the root canal treatment rather than the endodontic treatment per se. The endodontic access, if done conservatively, has little effect on the strength of the tooth, almost insignificant in comparison to the restorative procedures.
2. Full crown coverage after endodontic treatment guarantees successful treatment.
Fact – Coronal coverage only prevents cuspal deflection and doesn’t improve tooth strength if the tooth structure has been destroyed carelessly. Many studies have shown that the maximum amount of fractures post endodontically, in teeth restored with crowns, occur in the tooth portion above the crestal bone and below the marginal gingiva. This part is not frequently destroyed by caries but rather iatrogenically by over zealous access preparation and over preparation of coronal one third of the root canals. Care should be taken to preserve this important portion of the tooth by preventing unnecessary removal of tooth dentin.
3. Access filling can be delayed and has no effect on the long term success of the tooth.
Fact- According to modern endodontic principles, post endodontic restoration is the fifth major principle in endodontic treatment. Prognosis of the RC treated teeth in which a permanent restoration was placed immediately following endodontic therapy was much higher than those receiving temporary restorations. Key factor here to be considered is the prevention of root canal contamination between completion of treatment and restoration of tooth.
4. Any of the restorative materials can be used for post endodontic restoration.
Fact- The choice of restorative material to be used depends on the interplay of a large number of factors including the amount of tooth structure remaining, the tooth strength requirements, esthetic demands, need for any retentive features, etc. The treating professional should wisely consider all the biomechanical considerations of the tooth as well as the material and only then select the best material well suited to that particular situation.
CONCLUSION
The review of the contemporary literature supports the interpretation that the loss of structural integrity of a tooth, either at the radicular or coronal level, lead to a higher occurences of fractures in endodontically treated teeth, rather than changes in the dentin microstructure. Loss of structural integrity is associated with extensive access preparation or tooth structure destroyed due to caries or existing restorations, leading to increased cuspal deflecion during function and increased possibility of cusp fracture as well as marginal microleakage. Post space preparation should also be limited, both in size as well as indicated teeth.
These studies indicate that for the true success of an endodontically treated tooth, the reins lie in the hands of the operator. Conservative restorations and endodontic preparations along with cervical conservation of tooth structure (ferrule effect) are the need of the hour. Also, these studies indicate that restorations that enhance structural integrity of the tooth would be expected to increase the prognosis of endodontically treated teeth exposed to heavy masticatory loading forces.
A successful three dimensional obturation of the root canal system, along with apical and coronal seal, though vital for success, do not guarantee successful treatment. Incorporating sound biomechanical principles for endodontic and post endodontic treatment, will ensure teeth remain in function for a prolonged period of time, and ensure ones patients remain happy patients.
REFERENCES
- Cheung GS, Chan TK. Long-term survival of primary root canal treatment carried out in a dental teaching hospital. Int Endod J, 2003.
- C M E Tait, D N J Ricketts, A J Higgins. Restoration of the root-filled tooth: pre-operative assessment. British Dental Journal , 2005.
- Helfer AR, Melnick S, Schilder H. Determination of the moisture content of vital and pulpless teeth. Oral Surg, Oral Med, Oral Pathol 1972
- Hunter AJ, Feiglen B, Williams JF. Effects of post placement on endodontically treated teeth. J Prosthet Dent 1989
- Kishen A. Mechanisms and risk factors for fracture predilection in endodontically treated teeth. Endodontic Topics, 2006
- Morgano SM, Rodrigues AH, Sabrosa CE. Restoration of endodontically treated teeth. Dent Clin North Am. 2004
- Reeh, E.S., H.H. Messer, and W.H. Douglas, Reduction in tooth stiffness as a result of endodontic and restorative procedures. J Endod, 1989.
- Robbins, J.W., Restoration of the endodontically treated tooth. Dent Clin N Am, 2002.
- Sorensen JA, Engelman MJ. Ferrule design and fracture resistance of endodontically treated teeth. J Prosthet Dent., 1990.
- Torbjorner, A. and B. Fransson, A literature review on the prosthetic treatment of structurally compromised teeth. Int J Prosthod, 2004.
Disclaimer from Guident
The views and opinions expressed in articles published in Guident are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the editors, the editorial board or the publisher, Ivory India. Guident does not endorse any product, technique or treatment described. Clinical content is intended for qualified dental and medical professionals and is not a substitute for individual clinical judgement. Guident, its editors and the publisher accept no liability for any consequence arising from the use of information published in the journal.
How to cite this article
Dr.Vinnie Mehta Department of Endodontics. Biomechanical Considerations in Endodontically Treated Teeth. a Successful Endodontics Treatment Is Not Game over!. Guident. 2016 Feb;9(3). Available from: https://ivoryindia.in/articles/endodontics/biomechanical-considerations-in-endodontically-treated-teeth-a-successful-endodontics-treatment-is-not-game.html












