Open AccessPeer ReviewedPublished Monthly Since 2007 Vol. 19, Issue 12 · November 2026Media Kitinfo@guident.net

The Surgery First Approach - What, Why and How- a Literature Review

  • Dr. Anjali UttwaniP.G. Student
  • Dr. Siddharth MehtaProfessor
  • Dr. Kamal BajajProfessor & Head

Department of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics, Mahatma Gandhi Dental College and Hospital, Jaipur

Guident · Volume 14, Issue 5 (April 2021)Published April 202114 min read2 figures

ABSTRACT

Clinicians are predominantly influenced by objective findings, but patients are more biased toward their perception of their needs and values. This gives rise to the dilemma of what would one treat first, the profile or the occlusion. The surgery first approach treats facial esthetics (the skeletal malrelation) first and then occlusion, i.e., orthognathic surgery antecedes orthodontic therapy. This poster emphasizes the importance of SFOA protocol over orthodontics-first approach and focuses upon model surgeries in individual cases to help orthodontists with the predictions of the future occlusion of the patient.

Key words:Surgery first orthognathic approach

INTRODUCTION

Orthognathic surgery is a procedure carried in order to work on the sagittal, vertical and transverse discrepancies of the maxillary and mandibular jaws that cannot be treated using orthodontics alone. It has been used by multiple plastic surgeons and maxillofacial surgeons through years to improve the esthetics and function of the patients. It commonly comprises of three stages: pre-surgical orthodontics followed by surgery followed by minor corrections and finishing using post-surgical orthodontics. Many newer techniques and protocols have been developed to benefit the patients and operators in carrying out orthognathic surgery, one of them being the surgery first orthognathic approach.

Surgery-first orthognathic approach (SFOA) is a technique that roots back to the 1960s. An overview of surgery-first orthognathic approach shows the evolution of SFOA. ‘Jaw surgery’ pioneers and predecessors thought process and ideas are what shaped surgery-first orthognathic approach (SFOA). SFOA was revived later with a procedure and patient selection technique which was better planned.

Pre-surgical orthodontics and surgery-related orthodontics, in general, were not deemed important components on the overall management of the orthognathic patient. Jaw surgery was performed either before orthodontic treatment or after the removal of orthodontic appliances. Jaw surgery was carried out without presurgical orthodontics, which gave rise to surgery-first approach.

History of SFO 1 :

Year and Author

Conclusion

1963 Poulton al

Mandibular set-back

1973 Bell et al

Minimal orthodontic treatment before the surgery proposed

1977 Epker and Fish

Anterior open bite managed with SFOA

1988 Behrman et al

SFOA could be done

2009 Nagasaka et al

Significant reduction of treatment time.

2010 Sugawara et al

Recommended orthodontics just before surgery

2010 Villegas et al

Facial asymmetry cases were treated with SFOA

2010 Wang et al

Transverse dental corrections do not require pre-surgical orthodontics

2010 Kao et al

SFOA Skeletal stability was comparable to conventional surgery

2011 Liou et al

‘Transitional occlusion’ is established post-surgery

2011 Hernandez et al

Emphasise is laid on diagnosis and case selection

2010 Villegas et al

Facial asymmetry cases were treated with SFOA

2015 Yu et al

SFOA is regarded as an ideal and valuable

2015 Choi JW

Long term outcome of SFOA and conventional surgery compared

2016 Huang et al

Quality of life significantly improved in SFOA cases compared to conventional surgery

2017 Yang et al

A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis on SFOA

THE CONVENTIONAL ORTHOGNATHIC SURGERY

Steps:

  1. Pre-operative orthodontic treatment
  2. Orthognathic surgery(Figure 1)
  3. Post-operative orthodontic treatment
  1. Pre-operative orthodontics

Purpose:

  • Decompensate the dentition in a three dimensional way.
  • Correct the dentition form and lateral displacement
  • Solve the crowding and align the dentition correctly
  • To show the true skeletal discrepancy pre-operatively and to fit the maxilla and mandible into a solid occlusion after surgery.

Period of pre-operative orthodontic treatment

Presurgical orthodontic treatment time

It differs according to the researchers.

  1. Dowling and his collegues2: on average, they reported it would take 15.4 months.
  2. Luther and his colleague3: on average, they reported it would take 17 months.

The period of pre-operative orthodontic treatment of extraction case is longer than that of the non- extraction case.

  1. In the non-extraction case, the reported period was 14.5 months on average.
  2. In the extraction case the reported period was 19.1 months on average.

2. Post-operative orthodontics

Purpose4,5

  1. Erupt the molar teeth and improve the open bite relationship of premolar area
  2. Align the teeth
  3. Achieve a tight occlusion

Period of the post-operative orthodontic treatment

  1. Dowling and his colleagues2: On average, they reported it would take 5.9 months.
  2. There is no difference between the extraction and the non- extraction cases.
  3. In the non- extraction case, the reported period was 6.0 months on average.
  4. In the extraction case, the reported period was 5.5 months on average.

Comparison between COS and SFOA:

Parameter

COS

SFOA

Stages involved

Three stages

• Pre-surgery orthodontics

• Jaw surgery

• Post-surgery orthodontics

Two stages

• Jaw surgery

• Post-surgery orthodontics

Patient cooperation

Patients tend to cooperate better due to initial improvement in esthetics.6

Impact on facial profile

Worsening of profile before surgery.

Immediate improvement.

Average treatment time

3–4 years.

1–1.5 years.

Stability

No immediate post-surgical instability but good stability in long term as occlusion settles.

Comparable stability.7

Oral complications

Studies have found that complications like gingival recession, gingival hyperplasia, dental caries, root resorption, deterioration in occlusal function, masticatory and speech discomfort increase as the orthodontic appliance is kept for longer time.8

Lesser treatment time leads to less chances of oral complications.9

Patient satisfaction rate

Patients cannot appreciate the immediate corrections due to pre-surgical orthodontics phase.

High patient satisfaction rate is associated with improved cooperation during postoperative orthodontics.

Functional complications

Non-critical, complex cases can be managed with appropriate pre-surgical decompensation stage.

Critical for the success of treatment as the baseline dental relation is unable to guide the post-surgery occlusion. The orthodontist’s experience in assessing and predicting accurate post-surgery tooth movement plays a vital role.

Clinical figure

Fig 1. Different stages of COS and SFOA (depicted by Dr. Roopal Gupta)

Challenges associated with conventional orthognathic surgery cases

  1. Long time period

The longer pre-operative treatment phase can potentially aggravate the dental caries and periodontal problems and negatively influence patient compliance.11

  1. Worsened facial profile

The worsening of facial profile prior to surgery which results from dentoalveolar decompensation is also a great disadvantage. This is more prominent in Class III patients.

  1. Unsatisfying effect of the pre- orthodontic treatment

Despite the long duration of pre- orthodontic treatment, there are many cases where decompensation cannot be fully achieved and the teeth cannot be moved completely.12

  1. Compliance of the patient decreases

Because of the increase in treatment time and the presurgical orthodontic phase the patient compliance decreases.

The challenges involved with the conventional three stage model of orthognathic surgery have given rise to new concepts such as what is known as "Surgery First" orthognathics. In 1991 Brachvogel proposed this approach with the goal of reducing some of the disadvantages and inconveniences of pre-surgical orthodontics.14

Steps

  1. Orthognathic surgery without pre-operative orthodontic treatment
  2. Post-operative orthodontic treatment

Orthodontic procedures, such as alignment, leveling, incisor AP position, arch compatibility, molar expansion and decompensation leveling, are performed pre-operatively in the conventional orthognathic procedure. However, in this new treatment concept, the need of some of these procedures is eliminated and some are displaced by maxillary posterior impaction (MPI), occlusal plane rotation (OPR), anterior segmental osteotomy (ASO) or segmental surgery. Moreover, in order to predict the degree of post-operative orthodontic treatment, a set-up model is fabricated at a dental lab.

Diagnosis and treatment planning

Diagnosis and treatment planning forms the basis of successful treatment planning. Orthodontists play a pivotal role from the beginning and, together with the surgeon.

Clinical figure

Indications:

The SFOA is indicated in highly motivated patients with minimal arch length discrepancy, mild to moderate transverse, vertical and sagittal discrepancies, with normal incisor inclinations and minimal dental compensations, to avoid interferences during the surgical correction.6

Limitations:

SFOA should not be considered for patients with cleft related deformities, patients with high probability of development of CR-CO discrepancy and unilateral or bilateral crossbite or scissor bite post-surgery.13

Biological Responses to Surgery-First Orthognathic Approach

SFOA utilizes the sudden surge of cyclical sequence of bone modelling and remodelling events that ensues subsequent to osteotomy cuts made for the correction of jaw deformity. The osteotomy-assisted tooth movement is thought to accelerate significantly orthodontic tooth movement. It also reduces the total orthodontic treatment duration by using the RAP period to facilitate the orthodontic treatment phase.

Justus et al have reported increased blood flow levels during the healing process after surgery. This would result in increased bone turnover, a process similar to regional acceleratory phenomenon, that enhances the post-surgical orthodontic tooth movement.14 Moreover, Behrman and Behrman15 have presented the concept that when the underlying jaw deformities are corrected with SFOA, the normalized surrounding soft tissues accelerate the orthodontic tooth movement, which is also a factor responsible for decreased overall treatment duration.

SFOA Protocol

Apart from basic surgical protocol followed in COA, a few additions are made in SFOA keeping in mind the comfort of the patient. All SFOA practitioners (both orthodontist and surgeons) have their own individual technique and treatment philosophies that suit them as a team. No universal agreement exists on the choice of orthodontic appliances; however, the guiding principles of SFOA (i.e. minimal pre-surgical orthodontics) prevail. A few thing that must be kept in mind during the treatment that include:

  • Several authors have reported placing fixed orthodontic bracket 1–6 weeks before the scheduled surgery date with the objective of placing passive arch wires or passively ligating the brackets with ligature wires.16,17,18,19,20 Advantages of passive SS ligation are:
  • No undue tooth movement before or during surgery as the wire is passive, unlike active arch wires
  • All brackets are secured with no possibility of dislodgment, even if the
  • brackets dislodge, the passive ligature will not allow the bracket to release and accidental drop into open surgical sites
  • No additional use of rubber ligature tie, hence avoidance of oral hygiene deterioration due to rubber ties
  • Avoidance of complex wire bending in order to adapt to malocclusion
  • Saves chairside time
  • Intermaxillary fixation was suggested by a few authors while others believed that rigid fixation of the bone segments with miniplates was sufficient.
  • Surgical splint was kept in place to stabilise the jaws for a period of 1-4 weeks.
  • Orthodontic treatment is commenced 1-2 weeks post-surgery.
  • In mandibular setback surgery patients, chincup therapy is advised for 3 months following the surgery in order to avoid relapse.
  • Elastics can be used according to treatment requirements during the orthodontic phase.

PRE- AND POST-SURGERY PATIENT CARE CHECKLIST AND PATIENT INSTRUCTION

Pre-Surgical patient care1

Category

Conditions

Systemic evaluations

• Cardiovascular conditions

• Respiratory and airway

• Bleeding diathesis

• Chronic systemic illness

• Occult disorder

• Allergy

Patient’s informed consent

• Signed informed consent

• Identify patient’s needs, values, and goals

Medication/

anaesthesia

clearance

• Pain

• Infection

• Swelling

• Gastric emptying/bowel movements

• Infective endocarditis

Preoperative

anxiety

• Previous unpleasant dental experiences

• Sleeplessness

• Nervousness, apprehension

• Helplessness

Social support

• Lack of emotional support

– Empathy, love, trust support

• Lack of guidance/instructional support

– Appropriate instructions, advice, suggestions

• Lack of self-appraisal support

– Basic self-evaluation information

• Lack of instrumental support

– Tangible aid and service

Orthodontic

assessment

• Bracket and band breakage

• Orthodontic ligation

• Surgical splint fit

• Surgical hooks/K-hook robustness

Surgery

• Third molar

• Bone conditions

• TMJ evaluation

• Ulcers, lip drying

Post surgical patient care

Category

Condition

Mental/cognitive

assessment

• Mental health condition

• Emotional problem

• Body dysmorphic disorder (BDD)

• Comparing body parts to others’ appearance

• Camouflaging body parts

• Suicidal thoughts/tendency

Postoperative pain

management

• Face—lips, cheeks, muscles

– Bruised face, tightness of jaws muscles, dry/

cracked lips, sore lips

• Ear, nose, throat

– Nasal congestion, earache/irritated throat

• Teeth, alveolus, TMJ

– Sore teeth

– TMJ pain

Oral prophylaxis

requirements/

guidance

• Foul odour

• Excessive plaque accumulation

• Food and beverage unable to clean

• Bacteraemia

• Gingival and periodontal inflammation

Postoperative

nutrition (fluid and

electrolyte balance)

• Weight loss

• Constipation

• Hypovolaemia

• Depression

• Vomiting

• Oliguria, confusion, and tachypnoea

Orthodontic

assessment

• Dental occlusion

• Guiding elastics difficult to place

• Positioning of surgical splint

• Bracket and band fixation evaluation

Surgery

• Bone plating incorrect

• Damage to alveolar segments

• TMJ malposition

• Excessive facial swelling

• Bleeding

• Intermaxillary fixation (IMF) needs to be removed

Instructions for Patients and Care Givers1

•Wear the elastics as directed, if in doubt, inform the clinic;

• If the bite wafer is in place, follow the instructions on how to manage the wafer

Diet

• Immediate post-surgery to 1 week

Liquid diet

Drink plenty of water

Maintain sufficient hydration

• Week 1 to week 3

Follow soft diet (semi-solid)

• Weeks 3-4 onwards

Soft to normal diet (avoid eating hard and chewy food)

• Warm saline rinses using syringes

• Anti-bacterial, antiseptic mouth rinse (Chlorhexidine, Listerine)

• Use a child-size tooth brush until mouth opening is limited

• Apply generous amount of lip balm or petroleum jelly on lips too keep it from drying and bleeding

• Use tongue cleaner, preferably a small size

• Use additional oral swabs to keep your mouth clean

• Stock enough dental wax to protect raw wound from arch bars or surgical wires

• Consider using automatic teeth cleaner/irrigators after one-week of surgery

• Use interdental brushes

• Powered toothbrush after one-week of surgery

• Immediately after surgery minimal movement such as attempting to open mouth

• Short walks, strength return activities are encouraged during hospital stay

• One week after surgery

• Open and close your mouth more often

• Move jaw side to side and place one to two fingers in between front teeth

One month after surgery

• Place two to three fingers in between front teeth

• Move jaw freely

• Commence gentle exercise, climbing a flight of stairs

• Strong positive mental attitude

• Seek family/friends support

• Make an attempt to seek answers

• Inform the clinic of unusual bleeding or tightness around the face even after one week

• Use ice packs for the first 2-3 days

• Sleep with head elevated and pillow propped

• Intermittent moist heat could be used after 1-2 days post-surgery

• Gentle massage could be commenced after 2-3 days to relieve muscle spasms

POST-SURGICAL COMPLICATIONS

The orthodontist must be well aware of the post-surgical complications and be prepared to manage these. These include:

Orthodontic Complications

1. Occlusion instability

2. Limited mouth opening

3. Decreased chewing efficiency

4. Excessive dryness of lips

5. Open bite

6. Dental damage

(a) Teeth broken or chipped off

(b) Pulp necrosis, root resorption

(c) Decalcification

7. Periodontal complications.

(a) Dehiscence

(b) Gingival recession or fenestration

Surgical complications:

  1. Haemorrhage
  2. Proximal segment fractures
  3. Oro-antral communication
  4. Trauma
  5. Infection
  6. Neurosensory disturbance
  7. Vascular compromise/aseptic necrosis
  8. Postoperative gingival recession
  9. Extensive facial swelling
  10. Delayed bony segments union
  11. Unfavourable segmentalization/ fracture
  12. TMJ resorption
  13. Prolonged intense pain
  14. Reduced nutrition

CONCLUSION

Patients who are well informed about the possible complications of the treatment by a well coordinated team of orthodontist and surgeon receive satisfactory and stable function and esthetics through both approaches. The clinician must weigh the pros and cons of both and make the best decision for the patient. Surgery first approach should be preferred if indicated as it is shown to reduce the treatment time significantly and thus preventing complications like white spot lesions, caries, and periodontal problems while working early on the esthetics of the patients resulting in better compliance.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

We would like to acknowledge the contribution of Dr. Roopal Gupta (BDS,Intern, Mahatma Gandhi Dental College and Hospital) in making of illustrations for this article.

REFERENCES

  1. Chng, Chai & Gandedkar, Narayan & Liou, Eric. Introduction to Surgery-First Orthognathic Approach (SFOA). 2019, 10.1007/978-3-030-18696-8_1.
  2. PA Dowling, L Espeland, O Kroqstad, A Stenvik AK. Duration of orthodontic treatment involving orthognathic surgery. Int J Adult Orthodon Orthognath Surg. 1999;14(2):146–52.
  3. F Luther, D. O. Morris CH. Orthodontic preparation for orthognathic surgery: how long does it take and why? A retrospective study. Br J oral Maxillofac Surg. 2003;41(6):401–6.
  4. H. Asuman Kiyak, Thomas Hohl, Roger A. West RWM. Psychologic changes in orthognathic surgery patients: A 24-month follow up. J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 1984;42(8):506–12.
  5. Proffit, W. R., Fields, H. W., & Sarver, D. M. (2013). Contemporary orthodontics. St. Louis, Mo: Elsevier/Mosby.
  6. Peiró-Guijarro MA, Guijarro-Martínez R, Hernández-Alfaro F. Surgery first in orthognathic surgery: a systematic review of the literature. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 2016 Apr; 149(4):448-62.
  7. Baek, S., Ahn, H., Kwon, Y., & Choi, J. Surgery-First Approach in Skeletal Class III Malocclusion Treated With 2-Jaw Surgery: Evaluation of Surgical Movement and Postoperative Orthodontic Treatment. Journal of Craniofacial Surgery, 2010, 21, 332-338.
  8. Jacobs JD, Sinclair PM. Principles of orthodontic mechanics in orthognathic surgery cases. Am J Orthod. 1983 Nov; 84(5):399-407.
  9. Jeong WS, Choi JW, Lee JY, Kwon SM. Can a surgery-first orthognathic approach reduce the total treatment time? Int J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2017 Apr; 46(4):473-82.
  10. Pelo S, Gasparini G, Garagiola U, Cordaro M, Di Nardo F, Staderini E, et al. Surgery-first orthognathic approach vs traditional orthognathic approach: oral health-related quality of life assessed with 2 questionnaires. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 2017 Aug; 152(2):250-4.
  11. Al. KO et. Prospective, multi-center study of the effectiveness of orthodontic/orthognathic surgery care in the United Kingdom. AJODO. 2009;135(6):709–14.
  12. Jin-young choi, Seung-hak baek , Yoon-hee kwon. New paradigm in orthognathic surgery and orthodontic treatment- surgery first orthognathic approach and minimum pre-surgical orthodontic approach. 2014. 3-18 p.
  13. Choi JW, Bradley JP. Surgery first orthognathic approach without presurgical orthodontic treatment: questions and answers. J Craniofac Surg. 2017 July; 28(5):1330-3.
  14. Justus T, Chang BL, Bloomquist D, Ramsay DS. Human gingival and pulpal blood flow during healing after Le Fort I osteotomy. J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2001 Jan; 59(1):2-7; discussion 7-8.
  15. Behrman SJ, Behrman DA. Oral surgeons’ considerations in surgical orthodontic treatment. Dent Clin North Am. 1988 July; 32(3):481-507.
  16. Uribe F, Janakiraman N, Shafer D, Nanda R. Three-dimensional cone-beam computed tomography-based virtual treatment planning and fabrication of a surgical splint for asymmetric patients: surgery first approach. Am J Orthod Dentofac Orthop. 2013; 144:748–58.
  17. Hernández-Alfaro F, Guijarro-Martínez R, Peiró-Guijarro MA. Surgery first in orthognathic surgery: what have we learned? A comprehensive workflow based on 45 consecutive cases. J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2014; 72:376–90.
  18. Aristizábal JF, Martínez Smit R, Villegas C. The “surgery first” approach with passive self-ligating brackets for expedited treatment of skeletal Class III malocclusion. J Clin Orthod. 2015; 49:361–70.
  19. Choi JW, Lee JY, Yang SJ, Koh KS. The reliability of a surgery-first orthognathic approach without presurgical orthodontic treatment for skeletal class III dentofacial deformity. Ann Plast Surg. 2015;74:333–41.
  20. Yu H, Mao L, Wang X, Fang B, Shen S. The surgery-first approach in orthognathic surgery: a retrospective study of 50 cases. Int J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2015; 44:1463–7.

Disclaimer from Guident

The views and opinions expressed in articles published in Guident are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the editors, the editorial board or the publisher, Ivory India. Guident does not endorse any product, technique or treatment described. Clinical content is intended for qualified dental and medical professionals and is not a substitute for individual clinical judgement. Guident, its editors and the publisher accept no liability for any consequence arising from the use of information published in the journal.

How to cite this article

Dr. Anjali Uttwani, Dr. Siddharth Mehta, Dr. Kamal Bajaj. The Surgery First Approach - What, Why and How- a Literature Review. Guident. 2021 Apr;14(5). Available from: https://ivoryindia.in/articles/orthodontics/the-surgery-first-approach-what-why-and-how-a-literature-review.html

Related articles

More in Orthodontics

All 135 articles
Call for papers

Publish your clinical work in Guident

Original research, case reports and review articles are welcomed from clinicians and researchers worldwide. Every submission is assessed by the editorial board.