COVID-19 Hits Orthodontics: A Questionnaire Based Learners and Teachers Perspective
Department of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics, Mahatma Gandhi Dental College and Hospital, Jaipur, Rajasthan.
ABSTRACT
Introduction- It has been two years since covid-19 pandemic began, with India seeing three deadly waves. With multiple lockdowns, dental colleges have seen reduced number of OPD. As orthodontic treatment is considered as an elective procedure, various orthodontic departments suffered from reduced number of new patients, loss of follow up of old patients, etc. There is hesitance among recent dental graduates from taking up orthodontics.
Aims and objectives- To assess the impact of Covid-19 on the orthodontic PG curriculum, problems faced by PG students of every year, the opinion of orthodontic faculties and popularity of orthodontics among dental graduates. We aim to assess the impact of any future covid-19 wave or lockdown on orthodontics and hope to find solutions for them.
Material and method- Two questionnaires, one for PG students of orthodontics and one for Faculty of orthodontics were prepared. These questionnaires were circulated to 75 PG students and 75 faculties of orthodontics from various dental colleges in India and their responses were recorded and analyzed.
Results- Post Graduate Students- 53% Pg students were dissatisfied with the number and variety of new patients and procedures. 59% faced difficulties while carrying out their in-vivo dissertations and research projects. 65% reported that lockdown affected the treatment time and prognosis of their patients. 75% students felt that orthodontic curriculum should be changed to accommodate any future pandemic. Orthodontic Faculties- 83% faculties agreed that there is reduction in the number of new patients in their departments of their dental colleges, 92% agreed that the batch of PG students during covid has suffered significant loss in their education during covid. 66% felt that there should be a reformed curriculum to accommodate any future pandemic and to make MDS in orthodontics more productive.
Conclusion- Post graduate students and orthodontic faculties agreed that there was significant loss in education and clinical work due to covid-19 pandemic and there is a need for a reformed curriculum for post graduation in orthodontics to make it more productive incase of any future pandemic.
Key words- Covid-19, Orthodontics, orthodontic education, MDS Students, Post-graduate students
INTRODUCTION
It has been three years since covid-19 pandemic began, with India seeing three deadly waves. With multiple lockdowns, dental colleges have seen reduced number of OPD. As orthodontic treatment is generally considered as an elective and esthetic treatment among general public, it was classified as non-essential service during lockdowns.1 Patients were hesitant to start their orthodontic treatment during the pandemic or come for their follow up because of fear of being exposed to the virus. Because of this, the orthodontic OPD was completely shut during the pandemic which lead to significant loss in academics and clinical work for post graduate students. Various orthodontic departments and clinics across the country suffered from reduced number of new patients and loss of follow up of old patients.2
Therefore, we researched the problems faced by the post-graduate students during lockdowns and impact of Covid-19 pandemic on post-graduate curriculum. We also analyzed the various measures taken by the faculties of orthodontics to make sure that MDS students remained productive during Covid-19 pandemic and how they tried to compensate the loss of clinical hours in an efficient way. We took suggestions from post-graduate students and faculties of orthodontics in different dental colleges across India on how to make best use of their time during any future covid-19 wave or pandemic.
AIMS AND OBJECTIVES
- The aim of this study is to assess the impact of Covid-19 on the MDS in Orthodontics curriculum, problems faced by post graduate students of every year and the opinion of orthodontic faculties.
- We aim to assess the impact of any future covid-19 wave or lockdown on orthodontics and to find solutions for them.
MATERIAL AND METHODs
This study was conducted in the Department of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopaedics at Mahatma Gandhi Dental College and Hospital. Ethical approval was granted by the Institutional Ethical Committee of Mahatma Gandhi University of Medical Sciences and Technology, Jaipur.
We devised two questionnaires, one for post graduate students of Orthodontics and one for faculties or staff of orthodontics. Pilot study and expert interviews were carried out to ensure reliability and validity of the questionnaires. 75 post graduate students and 75 orthodontic faculties participated in this survey from various dental colleges across India.
Part 1- The questionnaire for post-graduate students consisted of the following questions
- Do you agree that covid-19 pandemic has impacted your MDS curriculum?
- Do you agree that you will be able to reach the quota of self-started patients in your curriculum ?
- Do you agree that you will not be able to/were not able to do a variety of patients or different types of procedures due to less number of new patients?
- Do you agree that you are satisfied with the number of patients that you were able to do?
- Do you agree that the present curriculum should be changed to accommodate future Covid-19 waves and to make MDS in orthodontics more productive?
- Do you agree that Covid-19 pandemic lead to disruptions in proper conduction of your in vivo thesis/dissertations/research projects?
- Do you agree that Covid-19 lockdown affected your ongoing patients/cases or will affect their prognosis in future ?
- Do you agree that online conferences/conventions/webinars are the future of education and will soon replace the offline mode ?
- What changes would you recommend in your curriculum?
Part 2- The questionnaire for faculties or staff of orthodontics consisted of the following questions
- Do you agree that there has been reduction in number of new patient in your college out patient department?
- Do you agree that the current batch of MDS students in your department have suffered some loss in their education due to Covid-19?
- Do you agree that the post-graduate curriculum should be changed to accommodate any future Covid-19 waves ?
- Do you agree that online conferences/conventions/webinars are the future of education and will soon replace the offline mode ?
- What changes in the MDS curriculum would you recommend to make MDS more productive during covid19?
All responses were recorded on a 5-point Likert scale with the options being 1. strongly agree, 2- agree, 3- neutral, 4-disagree, 5- strongly disagree. All suggestions were recorded in a descriptive way.
RESULTS
Part 1- Post-graduate Students
- Among post-graduate students, for question one, 51.4% of participants strongly agreed and 28.6% of participants agreed that Covid-19 pandemic has impacted their MDS curriculum. (Graph 1)
- For question two, 5.7 % of participants strongly disagreed, and 40% disagreed with the fact that they will be able to reach quota of self-started patients in their curriculum. (Graph 2)
- For question three, 25.7% of participants strongly agreed, and 60% agreed that they will not be able to/or were not able to do a variety of patients or different types of procedures due to less number of new patients. (Graph 3)
- For question four, 2.9% of participants strongly disagreed, and 48.6 % disagreed that they are satisfied with the number of patients they were able to do. (Graph 4)
- For question five, 40% of participants strongly agreed and 34.3% agreed that the present curriculum should be changed to accommodate future covid-19 waves and to make MDS in orthodontics more productive. (Graph 5)
- For question six, 28.6% of participants strongly agreed and 57.1% agreed that Covid-19 pandemic lead to disruptions in proper conduction of their in vivo thesis/dissertations/research projects. (Graph 6)
- For question seven, 11.4% of participants strongly agreed and 65.7 % agreed that Covid-19 pandemic affected their ongoing patients/cases or will affect their prognosis in future. (Graph 7)
- For question eight, 8.6% of participants strongly agreed and 28.6% agreed that online conferences/conventions/webinars are the future of education and will soon replace the offline mode. (Graph 8)
Part 2- Faculties of orthodontics
- For question one, 33.3 % of faculties strongly agreed and 50% agreed that there was a reduction in the number of new patients in their college out patient department. (Graph 9)
- For question two, 50% of faculties strongly agreed and 41.7% agreed that the current batch of MDS students in their department suffered some loss in their education due to Covid-19 pandemic. (Graph 10)
- For question three, 50% of faculties strongly agreed and 16.7 % agreed that the post-graduate curriculum should be changed to accommodate any future Covid-19 waves. (Graph 11)
- For question four, 16.7% of faculties strongly agreed and 25% agreed that online conferences/conventions/webinars are the future of education and will soon replace the offline mode.
DISCUSSION
The Covid-19 pandemic has had a significant impact on teaching and learning both nationally and internationally. Since then the pandemic has altered life as we know it. The educational system took a hit and it was significantly redesigned as part of measures to lessen the spread of the virus.3
It has been established that Covid-19 spreads through aerosols and droplets which are commonly generated through dental procedures, hence dentists were at a great risk of transmission, therefore only emergency dental procedures were carried out during the pandemic. This directly affected dental practice and education.4,5,6
As orthodontic treatment is usually considered as an aesthetic procedure and not an emergency, it was classified as non-essential service during lockdown and hence patients deferred their treatment until the restrictions were lifted. Hence orthodontic post-graduate students suffered a huge loss in their education during the pandemic for almost six months.
Therefore, it was imperative to find out the impact of Covid-19 pandemic on the education of orthodontic post graduate students in various dental colleges across India and also to list down measures to make post graduation more productive during any future pandemic. Hence, we designed two questionnaire, one for post graduate students and one for faculties or teachers of orthodontics. We recorded the opinion of 75 post graduate students and 75 faculties and took their suggestions.
Post-graduate students faced many difficulties during the pandemic. Approximately, 80% of post-graduate students responded that Covid-19 pandemic impacted their MDS curriculum, 46 % responded that they might not be able to reach the quota of self-started patients in their curriculum, 86% agreed that they were not able to do a variety of patients and clinical procedures due to less number of patients, 52% were not satisfied with the number of patients they were able to do, 77% reported that the pandemic affected their ongoing patients and affected their prognosis. These findings correlate well with the study done by vakili et all2 who also reported that the COVID-19 pandemic had significantly affected the clinical education in orthodontics for the predoctoral and postdoctoral orthodontic programmes. Overall, less patient care was provided, which could delay treatment for some patients and limit learning opportunities for others, especially predoctoral dentistry students who had less opportunities for clinical observation and assistance. These findings also agree with that of kumar et al7 who also reported that there was a dramatic reduction in the number of patients and recalling and follow up was also severely affected. Isiekwe et al8 also reported that 60% of participants felt that Covid-19 would lead to reduction in the number of patients in the future.
Approximately 74% agreed that the present curriculum should have provisions to make MDS in orthodontics more productive in case of any other future pandemic or lockdowns, 85% of participants faced difficulties and disruptions in efficient conduction of their in-vivo thesis or dissertation and other research involving patients, and 37% participants agreed that online conferences, conventions and webinars are the future of dental education. Patano et al8 also concluded that orthodontic students had a good attitude and view of e-learning, which is an efficient technique of training that complements traditional teaching methods.
Among the faculties or orthodontic teachers, almost 83% of them agreed that there was a reduction in new orthodontic patients in their institutes, 92% agreed that their post graduate students have suffered a significant amount of loss in their orthodontic education due to the pandemic, 67% agreed that the present syllabus or curriculum should have provisions for any future covid-19 waves or any other pandemic, and 42% agreed that online conferences, conventions and webinars are the future of dental education.
In our study, we asked for suggestions from post graduate students and orthodontic faculties on what changes they would like in the MDS curriculum in order to make MDS orthodontics more productive in the event of any future Covid-19 waves, lockdown or any other type of pandemic and suggestions to make best use of that time for post graduate education. Many faculties and post graduate students suggested online webinars and lectures to help students learn basic concepts, they suggested post graduate students can give their seminars and journal club presentations online, old existing cases could be discussed online to help new post graduate students get exposure to a variety of cases, also these case discussion could be inter-college or on national or international level. Post graduate students could focus more on their thesis, dissertations, and research work. Literature club activities, typodont exercises could be carried out to increase fine motor skills and teach practical aspect of orthodontics. Many post graduate students suggested to make college clinics as digitized as possible, to practice teleorthodontics, online consultations, use of aligners etc to reduce working time on patients. Some students suggested that quota of patients should be modifies in the event of any pandemic. Last but not the least, online conventions, conferences, webinars should be encouraged so that students can learn from experts, socialise with other post graduate students and other expert professionals in orthodontics.
Once the restrictions are lifted, more awareness programs, campaigns can be conducted to increase the number of new patients. Patients can be made aware about the protective measures in place to avoid transmission and they can be assured about their safety.
Therefore, Covid-19 or any other pandemic doesn’t have to cause loss of education or clinical skills during post graduate education. Even though number of patients are reduced during a pandemic, this time could be best utilized using the measures listed above.
CONCLUSION
Both post graduate students and orthodontic faculties agree that due to Covid-19 pandemic there was reduction in the number of patients which caused loss of important clinical skills, loss of follow up of old patients, disruptions in conduction of in vivo research projects, and inability to do a variety of procedures. This had a detrimental affect on the post graduate education during the pandemic.
Measures like online webinars, conventions, conferences, journal clubs, seminars, case discussions, literature clubs could be carried out during a pandemic to make that time more productive. Typodont exercises, hand-on workshops could be conducted to incorporate clinical skills. Both post graduate students and faculties agree that MDS curriculum should be modified and mention provisions to make MDS in orthodontics more productive in case of a future pandemic.
REFERENCES
- Karobari MI, Marya A, Venugopal A, Nalabothu P, Parveen A, Noorani TY. The state of orthodontic practice after the outbreak of COVID-19 in Southeast Asia: the current scenario and future recommendations. Asia Pac J Public Health. 2020 Nov;32(8):517-8.
- Iyer P, Aziz K, Ojcius DM. Impact of COVID?19 on dental education in the United States. J Dent Educ. 2020 Jun;84(6):718-22.
- Fallahi HR, Keyhan SO, Zandian D, Kim SG, Cheshmi B. Being a front-line dentist during the Covid-19 pandemic: a literature review. Maxillofac Plast Reconstr Surg. 2020 Dec;42(1):1-9.
- As some states consider reopening, ADA offers PPE guidance to dentists American Dental Association Available at: https://www.ada.org/en/press-room/news-releases/2020-archives/may/as-dental-practices-resume-operations-ada-offers-continued-guidance Accessed February 3,, 2022
- COVID-19—hazard recognition Occupational Safety and Health Administration Available at: https://www.osha.gov/coronavirus/hazards Accessed February 3,, 2021
- Kumar A, Sharma A, The impact of covid-19 pandemic on orthodontic practice in India: A questionnaire based study. Int J Appl Dent Sci 2021;7(4):245-247.
- Patano A, Cirulli N, Beretta M, Plantamura P, Inchingolo AD, Inchingolo AM, Bordea IR, Malcangi G, Marinelli G, Scarano A, Lorusso F. Education technology in orthodontics and paediatric dentistry during the COVID-19 Pandemic: A systematic review. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health. 2021 Jun 4;18(11):6056.
- Isiekwe IG, Adeyemi TE, Aikins EA, Umeh OD. Perceived impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on orthodontic practice by orthodontists and orthodontic residents in Nigeria. J. World Fed. Orthod. 2020 Sep 1;9(3):123-8.
Disclaimer from Guident
The views and opinions expressed in articles published in Guident are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the editors, the editorial board or the publisher, Ivory India. Guident does not endorse any product, technique or treatment described. Clinical content is intended for qualified dental and medical professionals and is not a substitute for individual clinical judgement. Guident, its editors and the publisher accept no liability for any consequence arising from the use of information published in the journal.
How to cite this article
Dr. Akshataa Joshi, Dr. Siddharth Mehta, Dr. Kamal Bajaj. COVID-19 Hits Orthodontics: A Questionnaire Based Learners and Teachers Perspective. Guident. 2023 Feb;16(3). Available from: https://ivoryindia.in/articles/orthodontics/covid-19-hits-orthodontics-a-questionnaire-based-learners-and-teachers-perspective.html



















