Conventional to Virtually Fabricated Implant Guided Surgical Template
Crown and Bridge and Implantology, Seema Dental College & Hospital, Rishikesh, Uttrakhand, India
ABSTRACT
One of the challenges of implant placement is planning the correct position of the implant in bone to achieve a prosthetic solution that fulfills biologic, esthetic, and biomechanical requirements. Prosthetically driven implant prosthesis assures good aesthetics, function and more importantly hygiene maintenance enabling long time success. Accuracy in treatment planning and implementation of planned treatment is vital for this success. Following advancements that have occurred in treatment planning (virtual software) for implant prosthesis; an equal rise is to be expected in transferring the planned therapy to surgical fruition.Various techniques have been proposed for the fabrication of surgical guide templates in implant dentistry. The objective of this paper is to review the associated literature and recent advancements in this field, based on design concept.
KEYWORDS: Surgical template, Computer softwares, CAD-CAM prosthesis, Stereolithography, implant placement, implant dentistry.
INTRODUCTION
Dental implants have proven to be a new horizon and a field of specialty where the horizons have been broadened with different treatment modalities surgically and prosthetically. Appropriate placement of the implants has always been essential. The correct implant position is so important that this factor alone may outweigh the advent of complex surface technology, advances in surgical techniques, or the intricacies of occlusal load factors in many clinical situations.1 Nevertheless, the inadvertent association of most surgical and prosthetic complications with improper diagnosis and implant placement has also been documented. These factors play a crucial role in the long-term predictability and success of implant prosthetics. Surgical guide templates not only assist in diagnosis and treatment planning but also facilitate proper positioning and angulation of the implants in the bone.2
Glossary of prosthodontic terms-9 defines surgical template as a guide used to assist in proper surgical placement and angulation of dental implants.3 Surgical template is the link between what,s in mind (treatment planned) and what will be executed (treatment).Hence, increasing demand for dental implants has resulted in the development of newer and advanced techniques for the fabrication of these templates.Here, the authors have genuinely attempted to review the evolution and recent advances in the fabrication of surgical templates used in the placement of dental implants.4
HISTORICAL OVERVIEW
To precisely transfer the plan to the operative site, customized conventional radiographic or computer image-guided surgical templates have become the treatment of choice.
Stumpel was among the initial workers who thought of the usage of surgical stents. On the basis of the amount of the surgical restriction offered by the surgical guide templates, his research ended up with the identification of basic three-fabrication design concepts; (1) nonlimiting design, (2) partially limiting design, (3) completely limiting design.5,6Nonlimiting designs only give an initial indication to the surgeon as to where the proposed prosthesis is in relation to the selected implant site. This design fails to emphasize on the correct angulations of the drill, thus, may result in the too much flexibility in the final positioning of the implant. Partially limiting designs allows only the first drill for osteotomy wherein the remaining osteotomy and implant placement is finished freehand by the surgeon.Completely limiting designs restricts, all of the instruments used for the osteotomy in a bucco-lingual and mesio-distal plane.5
Engelman et al. showed a technique in which the guide pin hole was drilled through a clear vacuum-formed matrix. However, the angulations were actually determined by the use of adjacent and opposing teeth.7Later on, it was realized that these templates may serve as imaging indicators during the surgical phase of implant. These radiographic cross checking measures not only confirm the final positioning of the implant, but also confirm about the relative parallelism with adjacent and opposing dentitions.
Adrian et al used auto polymerizing acrylic resin to fabricate radiographic cum surgical template. He molded lead foil over the maxillary and mandibular incisors and used lateral cephalogram to cross verify related parameters.8Tarlow employed the use of acrylic resin duplicate denture wherein he adapted vacuum-formed thermoplastic matrix (0.02 inch) over duplicate denture.
Stellino etal demonstrated acrylic resin provisional fixed restorations with the use of guttaparcha as redio-opaque marker.9Takeshita et al were the first to introduce the concept of mixing acrylic resin with radio-opaque material to fabricate surgical template (instead of pure acrylic resin). They meshed barium sulate powder with acrylic resin in 4:1 ratio.10Sicilia et al used orthodontic wires and auto polymerizing acrylic resin.Cehrelisuggested the fabrication of a bilaminar dual-purpose stent that facilitates implant placement with improved verification of implant positioning. The outer lamina is designed for use in the CT evaluation using radio-opaque markers.11
CLASSIFICATION OF SURGICAL GUIDES
Based on the area of operation Guides for partially edentulous sites (tooth supported or bone supported‑depending on amount of the edentulous space) and Guides for completely edentulous sites (mucosa or bone supported).12
Based on the support the surgical guides derive
Tooth supported, Bone supported, and Mucosa supported. Rules for planning usage of different types of surgical guides:13
- Tooth supported guides Minimum three stable teeth should be present to support the guide during surgery.
- Mucosa supported guides It is used in fully edentulous sites. Advantage less or no tissue reflection is required, so less postoperative discomfort. Will require scan prosthesis and surgical guides during surgery.
- Bone supported guides They are used in partially edentulous sites and completely edentulous sites. When used in partially edentulous sites, it should possess at least 3 cm of supporting bone or 3 teeth would need replacement. Bone guides are especially used when edentulous sites possess thin bone. Raised flap should provide a good view to implant sites and insertion of guides.13
Based on the accessibility
Surgical guides can be open sleeve or closed sleeve (increased accessibility).12
Based on material
Self/light cure acrylic resin, metal reinforced acrylic templates; vacuum formed polymers, milling, CADCAM prosthesis, stereo lithographic models. The surgical accuracy of manually processed resin and vacuum formed guides is less in comparison to the latter mentioned milling, CADCAM prosthesis or stereo lithographic models.13
EVOLUTION OF COMPUTER AIDED ADVANCES RADIOGRAPHIC TEMPLATES
The surgical templates are fabricated primarily on dental casts or models, which are a rigid, nonfunctional surface without the knowledge of underlying soft tissue resiliency and bone topography.14 Moreover, the anatomical landmarks are not exactly located, it does not confirm the underlying blood supply. Hence, the overall approach is two-dimensional. Even the panoramic radiography has its diagnostic limitations, such as expansion and distortion, setting error, positional artefacts, and there is no information regarding the dimension of bone in bucco-lingual direction. The final treatment outcome may be greatly influenced and thereby more chances of miss-positioning the implants during placement. Even if conventional surgical templates allow the placement of the implant guiding, they do not provide exact three-dimensional guidance.15
COMPUTER AIDED DESIGN/ COMPUTER ASSISTED MANUFACTURING BASED SURGICAL GUIDE
To overcome the limitations associated with conventional radiographic surgical template, computer-generated surgical template have been evolved. Computer-aided design/computer-assisted manufacturing (CAD/CAM) technology uses data from CT scan to plan implant rehabilitation.15This surgical guide is made using stereolithography process. Stereolithography, a rapid prototyping technology, a newer outcome in dentistry allows the fabrication of surgical guides from 3D computer generated models for precise placement of the implants.The surgical templates fabricated by this technology are preprogrammed with Individual depth, angulations, mesio-distal and labiolingual positioning of the implant.16
Fabrication of stereolithographic templates requires patient′s computed tomography (CT) image. In CT, multi planar reformatting allows one to reformat a volumetric dataset in sagittal, axial, and coronal cuts and also helps in building multiple cross-sectional and panoramic views. Shaded surface display and volume rendering methods generate 3D reconstructions of the entire dental arch and their relevant structures, including nerves, which makes dental CT the most precise and comprehensive radiologic technique for dental implant planning. Software′s specially planned has been adapted to allow practitioners to virtually view the implant site and plan location, angle, depth, and diameter of virtual implants, which are superimposed on the 3D data. Following backward planning, the diagnostic wax up has to be visualized through CT scan with radiographic templates in place.1,17
PROCEDURES IN FABRICATION OF STEREOLITHOGRAPHIC TEMPLATES
- Radiographic template
- CT scan procedure
- 3D computer simulation
- Fabrication of templates
A radiographic template fabricated using radio opaque marker is kept in patient mouth while performing CT scan procedure.16,18During the scan, this indicates the position of the teeth and gingival tissues.7During fabrication, a diagnostic wax up is established, representing the outline of the final restoration, and is then transferred into a radiographic guide.16
DOUBLE SCAN PROTOCOL
The first scan is a scan of the patient wearing the radiographic guide. The second scan is a scan of only the radiographic guide. Based on the spherical markers visible in both scans, the scans are superimposed onto each other, resulting in a 3D bone model of the patient together with a 3D model of the radiographic guide.4,14
Converting raw data to 3D information is done by various software′s available or by just sending to master site of the particular software manufacturers. CT or Cone beam scan data thus obtained is sent from the radiology site to Master site nearby. Master site will convert the CT or Conebeam scan data into a file that contains reformatted images in 2D and an insightful 3D representation of patient′s anatomy. On finally the file contains cross-sectional images, panoramic views, axial images, and a 3D representation of the patient′s anatomy.16
The combination of a 3D bone model, including the 3D radiological dataset and the 3D radiographic guide model, enables clinician to place implant locations according to anatomical, functional and esthetics needs and demands.In order to achieve this, the clinician virtually positions the implants, with the optimal length and diameter. Any of the modifications in 3D location and implant type, size or shape can be done in the 3D setting or in the reslice viewer. After finalizing the planning, the corresponding surgical template is designed.14
MAKING A COMPUTER AIDED TEMPLATE
CAD-CAM a rapid prototyping technique in which after the generation of a 3D treatment plan, software slices from the file is sent to a machine that fabricates the part slice by slice. Two main methods of rapid proto typing are11
- Additive - widely used
- Subtractive - less effective
Stereolithographic apparatus consists of a vat, which contains a liquid photo polymerized resin. Corresponding to slice intervals, laser that is mounted on top of vat moves in sequential cross sectional of 1 mm increments, to produce template. Polymerization process of photo polymerized resin occurs in layers. Once, the surface layer of the resin on laser contact gets polymerized, a mechanical table immediately below the surface layer moves down 1 mm, carrying with it the previously polymerized resin layer. The laser now polymerizes the next layer over the previously polymerized layer of the model. In stereolithography Apparatus (SLA) only 80% of the total polymerization is completed in the vat, whereas the remaining 20% can be completed in a conventional ultraviolet light curing unit.16
The so produced surgical template is provided with surgical grade stainless steel tubes with sleeves that are 5 mm in height, 0.2 mm wider than osteotomy, and also with drill limiting angulation deviation to 5°. Buccal window is made so that it enhances retention during surgery. Usually, three 2 mm holes are placed into the buccal surface of each side of the denture.4
ADVANTAGES OF CAD/CAM TECHNOLOGY
- Correct management of the tissues with minimal trauma and minimization of the need for decision making at the time of implantation.
- 3D technology allows a precise evaluation of anatomic points such as the size of the maxillary sinus in the upper jaw and location of the alveolar nerve in the lower jaw.19
- Precise analysis of Osseous Topography.
- Provides information about size, direction, and bone location for accurate positioning of implants.20
- When it is fabricated on diagnostic study casts, the soft tissue is a rigid, non-functional representation and it does not provide information on the varying thickness of the mucosa, topography of underlying bone, or vital anatomical structures that lie within. In addition, the limitations of conventional dental radiography with regards to dimensional accuracy and inability in visualizing anatomical structures in parasagittal sections further hinders accurate evaluation.21
CONCLUSION
Improvements in surgical reconstructive methods, as well as increased prosthetic demands, require a highly accurate diagnosis, planning, and placement. Identification of the bony anatomy with respect to the teeth, prior to surgery, allows the clinician to place implants in areas where the implant-bone interface can be maximized, and the prosthetic result is optimized. The clinician can provide a treatment plan that reduces the operating time, surgical trauma, and postoperative recovery period which result from conventional freehand implant surgery, but which maintains a precise, stable, and a biomechanically sound outcome. The time which is saved with this revolutionary procedure is remarkable. This is a significant advancement in implant dentistry and prosthodontics.
REFERENCES
- Misch CE. 3rd ed. St. Louis: Mosby Publications; 2007. Contemporary Implant Dentistry.
- Petrikowski CG, Pharoah MJ, Schmitt A. Presurgical radiographic assessment for implants. J Prosthet Dent. 1989;61:59–64.
- The glossary of prosthodontic terms. J Prosthet Dent. 2017.
- Christopher HJ. The use of radio-opaque templates for predictable implant placement. Quintessence Int. 1995;26:609–2.
- Stumpel LJ., 3rd Cast-based guided implant placement: A novel technique. J Prosthet Dent. 2008;100:61–9.
- Babbush CA. 1st ed. Philadelphia: WB Saunders Company; 2001. Dental Implants: The Art and Science.
- Engelman MJ, Sorensen JA, Moy P. Optimum placement of osseointegrated implants. J Prosthet Dent. 1988;59:467–73.
- Adrian ED, Ivanhoe JR, Krantz WA. Trajectory surgical guide stent for implant placement. J Prosthet Dent. 1992;67:687–91.
- Stellino G, Morgano SM, Imbelloni A. A dual-purpose, implant stent made from a provisional fixed partial denture. J Prosthet Dent. 1995;74:212–4.
- Takeshita F, Tokoshima T, Suetsugu T. A stent for presurgical evaluation of implant placement. J Prosthet Dent. 1997;77:36–8.
- Cehreli MC, Aslan Y, Sahin S. Bilaminar dual-purpose stent for placement of dental implants. J Prosthet Dent. 2000;84:55–8.
- Ramasamy M, Giri, Raja R, Subramonian, Karthik, Narendrakumar R. Implant surgical guides: From the past to the present. J Pharm BioalliedSci 2013;5:S98‑102.
- Lal K, White GS, Morea DN, Wright RF. Use of stereolithographic templates for surgical and prosthodontic implant planning and placement. Part II. A clinical report. J Prosthodont 2006;15:117‑22.
- Brief J, Edinger D, Hassfeld S, Eggers G. Accuracy of image-guided implantology. Clin Oral Implants Res. 2005;16:495–501.
- Edge MJ. Surgical placement guide for use with osseointegrated implants. J Prosthet Dent. 1987;57:719–22.
- Kraut RA. Interactive radiologic diagnosis and case planning for implants. Dent Implantol Update. 1994;5:49–55.
- Pesun IJ, Gardner FM. Fabrication of a guide for radiographic evaluation and surgical placement of implants. J Prosthet Dent. 1995;73:548–52.
- Sicilia A, Noguerol B, Cobo J, Zabalegui I. Profile surgical template: A systematic approach to precise implant placement. A technical note. Int J Oral Maxillofac Implants. 1998;13:109–14.
- Burns DR, Crabtree DG, Bell DH. Template for positioning and angulation of intraosseous implants. J Prosthet Dent. 1988;60:479–83.
- Espinosa Marino J, Alvarez Arenal A, PardoCeballos A, Fernandez Vazquez JP, Ibaseta Diaz G. Fabrication of an implant radiologic-surgical stent for the partially edentulous patient. Quintessence Int. 1995;26:111–4.
- Minoretti R, Merz BR, Triaca A. Predetermined implant positioning by means of a novel guide template technique. Clin Oral Implants Res. 2000;11:266–72.
Disclaimer from Guident
The views and opinions expressed in articles published in Guident are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the editors, the editorial board or the publisher, Ivory India. Guident does not endorse any product, technique or treatment described. Clinical content is intended for qualified dental and medical professionals and is not a substitute for individual clinical judgement. Guident, its editors and the publisher accept no liability for any consequence arising from the use of information published in the journal.
How to cite this article
Dr. Geeta Arya Dr. Jyotsna Seth Dr. Yogeshwari KRishnan Department of Prosthodontics. Conventional to Virtually Fabricated Implant Guided Surgical Template. Guident. 2017 Oct;10(11). Available from: https://ivoryindia.in/articles/implantology/conventional-to-virtually-fabricated-implant-guided-surgical-template.html






