The Role of Orthodontics as an Adjunct to Periodontal Therapy in Adult Patients
Vyas Dental College, Jodhpur, India, Jodhpur Dental College General Hospital, Jodhpur, Rajasthan, India, Department of Orthodontics, Jodhpur Dental College General Hospital, Jodhpur, Rajasthan, India
Abstract
Orthodontic- Periodontic interactions are mutually beneficial. This combined approach can greatly enhance periodontal health and dentofacial esthetics in periodontally compromised patients. Now a day there is increased demand of esthetic in adult patients. Adult orthodontics is difficult because these patients with soft and hard tissue defects. This article presents different problems related to periodontally compromised patients.
Key words: Periodontal diseases, osseous defects, pathological migration.
INTRODUCTION
Periodontal and orthodontic interactions are in vogue since years and are mutually beneficial. Combined periodontal and orthodontic treatment can greatly enhance periodontal health and dentofacial esthetics. Interrelationship of Orthodontic and periodontic treatment can be discussed in two ways: 1) Adjunctive orthodontic treatment for periodontally compromised patients. 2) Adjunctive periodontal treatment for Orthodontic patients. In this article we will discuss about adjunctive orthodontic treatment for periodontic patients. In this category mainly adult patients are involved, having multiple problem with their dentition like pathological migration, rotation of teeth, fractured teeth, missing teeth, tipped abutment teeth, inadequate pontic space along with periodontal problems, which require periorestorative treatment. In the past 2-3 decades there is greater focus on dentofacial esthetics in the adult population with an increasing demand for orthodontic treatment to improve the dental and facial appearance.1,2
Adults seeking for Orthodontic treatment can be grossly divided into 2 groups. First group involve younger adults, typically patients in their 20s. Second group is older group involve patients in their 40’s & 50’s. Reason for seeking treatment is different in both the groups. Group I usually seek comprehensive orthodontic treatment to improve their quality of life, most importantly their esthetics. While the second group require orthodontic treatment to maintain what they have and improvement of function. Esthetic mostly is not bthe primary goal of orthodontic treatment in group II.3
Because adults presents with a different set of challenges including some underlying osseous and soft tissue defects, which can not be corrected with periodontic or orthodontic treatment alone. These cases require a combined approach of orthodontic periodontic interaction.
Benefits of orthodontics for periodontally compromised patients: There are many ways in which orthodontics can influence the adult periodontal patient. When crowded teeth are aligned, it provides better access to adequately clean all surfaces of the teeth. It is especially advantageous in patients who are susceptible to periodontal disease. Certain types of osseous defects which are very common in adults can be improved by orthodontic treatment, sometimes eliminate the need for resective osseous surgeries. Esthetic relationship of gingival margin especially maxillary arch can be greatly improved by Orthodontic treatment. In patients with open gingival embrasure in case of lost papilla, orthodontic treatment can improve these open embrasures. In patient with missing teeth missing for a long time, adjacent teeth drift in edentulous space and in patients who want prosthetic replacement (implant supported prosthesis or bridge work) for missing teeth may require orthodontic treatment to gain the space.1,2,3,4,5
Mechanics for treatment is same for adults and adolescent, but there are many changes that make the adult orthodontics different than orthodontics for younger patients. In adults there is lack of growth and development changes in occlusal levels by the eruption of posterior teeth. In adults alveolar surface adjacent to teeth is aplastic, which results in delay in osteoblast migration followed by less osteoid and bone formation. Rapid tooth movement can not be carried out in adults, because it causes even more harm as resorption is taking place but compensatory bone deposition is not present. One of the major considerations in orthodontic treatment of adult is that almost every adult has already have experienced some periodontal disease, so special consideration must be given to periodontal condition of the adults. There is a greater incidence of periodontal disease in patients with a history of the disease.6,7 So all these factors must be carefully considered while carrying out orthodontic treatment in adults. The different problems in adults can be broadly categorized as follows:
a. Hard tissue problems such as Incisal wear, Interproximal craters, One-, two- and three-wall defects, Furcation involvement, and Horizontal bone loss.
b. Soft tissue problems such as Gingival margin discrepancies, Missing papillae, Mucogingival defects, gummy smile.
c. Pathological migration.
a) Hard Tissue Defects: adult patients often show bony defect such as horizontal bone loss, vertical bone loss, osseous/ Interproximal craters, one, two and three wall defects, Furcation involvement. Orthodontic treatment in adult often aims to attain more favorable bone levels and contours in periodontally involved cases. Improvement of periodontal condition and pocket depends upon the architecture of underlying bone. Orthodontic treatment can induce changes in bony topography by moving teeth away from osseous defect into the area of greater volume of bone. Intrusion, extrusion and uprighting can be carried out to eliminate the defect.6
Ossous or Interproximal craters: Ossous craters are interproxmal, two-wall defects. Attachment loss occurs on the interproximal side (mesial and distal surfaces of the roots), while labial and lingual walls are still intact. Orthodontic treatment alone is not successful in eliminating these types of defects. Shallow Osseous creaters around 4-5 mm pocket depth can be improved by orthodontic treatment without surgical intervention. Deeper defects can be treated by reshaping the defects and reducing the pocket depth.3
One-/two-wall bony defects: these are also called as hemiseptal defect, mostly seen in teeth which are mesially tilted or supraerupted teeth. These are difficult to treat with periodontal therapy alone. Such defects can be efficiently treated with orthodontic treatment combined with periodontal treatment. Before starting orthodontic treatment, a through cleaning and debridement is required to reduce the amount of inflammation present and reduce the pocket depth which is present. Brown8 and Ingber9 recommended that if uprighting of mesially tilted teeth is done, it eliminate the hemiseptal defect around these teeth. It can be done by placing the bracket perpendicular to the long axis of the tooth. In cases with supraerupted teeth, orthodontic intrusion can be performed to level the tooth and correct the defect. Three wall defects are the bony defects, where three walls are absent and only 1 wall is present.3 wall defects must be dealt before starting the orthodontic treatment because three wall defects can not be corrected with orthodontics alone. Three wall defect are best corrected with regenerative procedures which include either autogenous or alloplastic grafts to eliminate the osseous defect.
Furcation defects:Patients with furcation involvement must be given special attention before and during Orthodontic treatment.Furcation defects can be classified into Class I (incipient), Class II (moderate), and class III (severe). Molar tube and other attachments are often used with band on molar. It makes the home care of oral hygiene very difficult. Thorough supra and subgingival scaling instrumentation should be done before starting Orthodontic treatment to prevent further breakdown. Class I furcation area can undergo orthodontic treatment because they can be maintained by patient after conservative periodontal therapy. Usually class 2 and Class 3 furcation defects are typically not maintainable by patients during orthodontic therapy. Periodontal surgery along with endodontic treatment is performed to retain the tooth. Sometimes in Class III furcation defect, the treatment option for tooth with furcation involvement is hemisection or root resection, once the orthodontic treatment is completed. Teeth where the hemisection is not possible, treatment option involve extraction of tooth followed by implant placement which can aid in orthodontic treatment also.3
(d) Horizontal bone loss: One of the very common problems in adult patients is horizontal bone loss particularly in anterior region. In patient with horizontal bone loss, bone level at different teeth has receded to different level, altering the crown to root ration. In advanced bone loss, this ratio is unfavorable. In such case if brackets are placed normally for aligning the crown of the teeth, by doing this sometimes bone discrepancies increas. In such problem, treatment should be done by keeping the bone level as a guide to place the brackets. Crown equilibration (to reduce the clinical crown lengths of these teeth to achieve improved crown/root ratio) should be planned. It should be done keeping the vitality of teeth in mind. If teeth are vital, then crown height can be reduced slowly to produce formation of secondary dentine. This equilibration process help in maintaining the bony architecture and maintaining the crown root ratio more favorable.10
B). Soft tissue or esthetic factors: Soft tissue concerns mainly involve. gingival margin discrepancies, missing papilla, mucogingival problems.
Missing papillae/ open gingival embrassures: The presence of interdental papilla between the upper incisors is very important from esthetic point of view. The open gingival embrasure between anterior teeth is due to missing papilla. Treatment of missing papilla depends upon the cause of it. Interproximal contact between teeth has 2 parts. One part is tooth contact and other half is soft tissue papilla. Patients with open embrasure either have problem with tooth contact or papilla. When tooth contact is the problem, then orthodontic treatment should be carried out to correct the contact. Open embrasure or missing papilla can be because of the following reason: faulty tooth angulation, tooth shape and periodontal bone loss.
In many cases, the open space is due to faulty tooth contact. Faulty tooth contact can be due to improper angulation of tooth or abnormal tooth shape. When anterior teeth are mesialy angulated, roots are diverging distally. Intraoral periapical radiograph of incisor can be used to confirm this condition. It can be corrected by correcting the angulation of incisors. It is done by placing brackets perpendicular to the long axis of the affected incisor. As the tooth aligns, roots come closer and open contacts are closed and interproximal gingiva moves incisally toward. If the roots are aligned parallel to each other, then the open embrasure can be because of abnormal tooth shape. The crowns of many centrals are triangular in shape, much wider at their incisal edge than at the cervical region. The best method of correcting this problem is to giving incisor normal shape by recontouring the mesial surfaces of the incisors. Space created is then closed. As this occurs, the contact is lengthened and moved toward the papilla which takes its normal space and shape.11
In long standing crowding cases with incisor overlapping, the contact point is located too incisally on triangular crown that did not have normal interdental wearing. In patients with advanced periodontal loss and crestal bone loss, papilla is missing. These problems can be corrected by recontouring the mesiodistal surface of the incisors. Contact area move apically and the papilla can fill out the interdental space more easily.12,13 When the problem is not well resolved with orthodontics then selective cosmetic bonding can be done with direct-bonding resin. Papillae creation procedure has been a predictable approach of improving the condition, but requires great skill.11,14 5
The relationship of gingival margins of the anterior teeth is very important for esthetic point of view. Gingival margin discrepancy becomes very obvious on smiling. Gingival margin discrepancy is either due to delayed migration of the gingival tissue or wear of the incisal edges. Optimum treatment depends upon the cause. Orthodontic movement can be planned to reposition the gingival margin or surgical correction can be carried. In cases of abraded incisal edge of anterior tooth, the abraded tooth extrudes taking the gingival margin also occlusally, creating the gingival margin discrepancy. In this situation, the best method of correcting the gingival margin discrepancy is the intrusion of the abraded/ extruded tooth. This moves the gingival margin apically and reduced crown height can be corrected by restoration of the incisal edge. In some cases, even without the abrasion, there is gingival margin discrepancy. In such cases, the gingival sulcular depth is evaluated over the adjacent teeth. If the tooth with short clinical tooth has a deeper sulcus, excisional gingivectomy for crown lengthening can be performed.16,17 In case where discrepancy is due to overeruption of tooth then intrusion can be carried out. it facilitates apical migration of the gingival margin.11,14
Mucogingival defects: An adequate amount of attached gingiva is necessary for gingival health and to allow orthodontic tooth movement without causing bone loss and gingival recession. Normally areas of mouth with lack of attached gingiva shows signs of inflammation as compared to areas with a wider zone of attached gingiva. During orthodontic treatment when labial bodily movement of teeth is planned, incisors showed apical displacement of the gingival margin, but no loss of connective tissue attachment was apparent where there were no signs of inflammation. Where inflammation was present, loss of connective tissue attachment occurred. Therefore if the tooth movement is expected to result in a reduction of soft tissue thickness and an alveolar bone dehiscence may have occurred in the presence of inflammation, gingival recession is a risk. Thin, delicate tissue is far more prone to exhibit recession during orthodontic treatment than in normal or thick tissue. If a minimal zone of attached gingiva or thin tissue exists, a free gingival graft that enhances the type of tissue around the tooth helps control inflammation. This should be done before any orthodontic movement is begun.
When lingual movement/ retraction of anterior teeth are planned, labial bone will show new bone formation even in the areas of dehisecence. So it is common to observe the bone formation along with reduction in amount of recession or dehiscence, when retraction is planned to move the teeth to their correct position in alveolar bone. It also results in an increased buccolingual thickness of the tissue at the facial aspect of the tooth. So whenever tooth movement is planned in patients with thin gingiva and/or inadequate zones of keratinized gingiva (specially labial movement), there are chances of developing areas of dehiscence. In such cases Preorthodontic mucogingival surgery might be considered to prevent further mucogingival involvement postorthodontically. The decision should be carefully taken after determining the tooth position, type and direction of the anticipated tooth movement, oral hygiene, tissue type, presence or absence of inflammation, muscle pull, mucogingival and osseous defects.4,18,19
C). Pathological migration: Most common clinical sign of periodontal disease is pathological migration of teeth involving a single tooth or a group of teeth. The sequelae may be tipping labial movement, irregular spacing, rotation, extrusion of anterior teeth, development of a single diastema or multiple spacing of the anterior teeth. The long lasting inflammation causes the destruction of periodontial tissues resulting in loss of support and pathological migration. Pathological migration is more common in anterior segment because anteriorteeth have no anteroposterior and occlusal contact. In such cases orthodontic treatment may be required for cosmetic reasons to attain an aligned front tooth segment by orthodontic intrusion, bodily tooth movement, derotation, and extrusion. This orthodontic phase also helps in periodontic, conservative and prosthetic intervention to restore normal oral functions and now days importantly to improve esthetics in adult patients. At the same time if orthodontic treatment is not done carefully, it can even exacerbate the periodontal disease and may aggravate the hard and soft tissue defect. Thus, Orthodontic treatment can be referred to as a debatable issue in periodontally compromised patients, which may be sometimes very meaningful in increasing the periodontal health status, and may be sometimes a harmful procedure, which can be followed by several types of periodontal complications.4,5,20
CONCLUSIONS
Adjunctive orthodontic treatment for patients with periodontal disease is definitely an advantage. Orthodontic treatment if carried out properly in a healthy, or height-reduced but clinically healthy periodontium can improve soft and hard tissue defects. Dental health education in patient, enhanced oral hygiene instruction and regular periodontal care are essential before and during orthodontic treatment. A better treatment outcome that could be maintained for long-term may be achieved through close collaboration between the
periodontist and orthodontist.
References
- Proffit W. Special considerations in comprehensive treatment for adults. In: Proffit W, Fields HW, editors. Contemporary orthodontics. 3rd ed. St. Louis: Mosby; 2000. p. 644-74.
- Marianne M. A., Hom-Lay Wang; Periodontic and orthodontic treatment in adults; Am J Orthod Dent Orthop 2002;122:420-8.
- Kokich V. The role of orthodontics as an adjunct to periodontal therapy. In: Newmann MG, Takei HH, Carranza FA, editors. Clinical periodontology. 9th ed. Philadelphia: WB Saunders; 2002. pp. 704–18
- Lijian Jin; Periodontic-orthodontic interactions—rationale,sequence and clinical implications; Hong Kong Dental Journal 2007;4:60-4.
- Aous Dannan; An update on periodontic-orthodontic interrelationships; J Indian Soc Periodontol. 2010 Jan-Mar; 14(1): 66–71.
- Matthew Kessler; Interrelationships between orthodontics and periodontics; A~IL. J. Orthod.Azcl/ust 1976; 70 (2); 154-172.
- Reitan, K.: Biomechanical principles and reactions. In Graber, T. M. (editor): Current orthodontic concepts and techniques, Philadelphia, 1969, W. B. Saunders Company, vol. I, pp. 56-159.
- Brown IA; The effect of orthodontic therapy on certain types of periodontal defects; J. Periodontology:1973:44:742.
- Ingber JS. Forced eruption. Part I. A method of treating isolated one and two-wall intrabony osseous defect-rationale and case report. J Periodontol. 1974;45:199–206. [PubMed]
- Mathews D, Kokich V. Managing treatment for the orthodontic patient with periodontal problems. Semin Orthod. 1997;3:21–38. [PubMed]
- Kokich VG. Esthetics: The orthodontic-periodontic restorative connection. Semin Orthod. 1996;2:27–30.
- Lang N.P., Lindhe J.; clinical periodontalogy and implant dentistry; 5th edition. Blackwell publication; page1248.
- Luverson D.L; Anterior interdental relationship: Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop; 1980:78:361-393.
- Keim RG. Aesthetics in clinical orthodontic-periodontic interactions; Periodontol 2000 2001;27:59-71.
- Zetu L, Wang HL. Management of inter-dental/inter-implant papilla. J Clin Periodontol 2005;32:831-9.
- Kokich V, Nappen D, Shapiro P. Gingival contour and clinical crown length: Their effects on the esthetic appearance of maxillary anterior teeth. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop; 1984;86:89–94.
- Kokich VG. Anterior dental esthetics: An orthodontic perspective. III. Mediolateral relationships. J Esthet Dent. 1993;5:200–7.
- Karring T, Nyman S, Thilander B, Magnusson I. Bone regeneration in orthodontically produced alveolar bone dehiscences. J Periodontal Res. 1982;17:309–15. [PubMed]
- Engelking G, Zachrisson BU. Effects of incisor repositioning on monkey periodontium after expansion through the cortical plate. Am J Orthod. 1982;82:23–32. [PubMed]
- Melsen B, Agerbaek N, Markenstam G. Intrusion of incisors in adult patients with marginal bone loss. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop 1989; 96:232-41.
Disclaimer from Guident
The views and opinions expressed in articles published in Guident are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the editors, the editorial board or the publisher, Ivory India. Guident does not endorse any product, technique or treatment described. Clinical content is intended for qualified dental and medical professionals and is not a substitute for individual clinical judgement. Guident, its editors and the publisher accept no liability for any consequence arising from the use of information published in the journal.
How to cite this article
Dr. Jitendra Bothra, Dr.Yashpal Pachori, Dr. Sumeet Sharma. The Role of Orthodontics as an Adjunct to Periodontal Therapy in Adult Patients. Guident. 2013 Mar;6(5). Available from: https://ivoryindia.in/articles/orthodontics/the-role-of-orthodontics-as-an-adjunct-to-periodontal-therapy-in-adult-patients.html






