Open AccessPeer ReviewedPublished Monthly Since 2007 Vol. 19, Issue 12 · November 2026Media Kitinfo@guident.net
Open AccessCase ReportProsthodonticsSubscribe now

Prosthodontic and Periodontic Rehabilitation of a Mobile Tooth in Esthetic Zone

  • Dr. Himanshu AeranDirector Prof. & Head
  • Dr. Sagrika ShuklaSenior Lecturer
  • Dr. Saba Jamil Department of ProsthodonticsP.G Student

Seema Dental College & Hospital, Rishikesh, India

Guident · Volume 9, Issue 3 (February 2016)Published February 20168 min read8 figures

Abstract

Aim- To treat and prostheticallyrehabilitate mobile lateral incisor having apalatogingival grooveand abony defect.

Method and material – A male patient with a palatogingival groove and intrabony defect reported to the department of priodontology with grade II mobilityin relation to (i.r.t) 12. Upon examination, a palatogingival groove along with a type III vertical defect was diagnosed. The defects were treated with glass ionomer cement (GIC) and a bone graft.

Results – Patient showed improvement, though recession could not be treated, the mobility reduced to zero and bony defect showed marked improvement in terms of bone density and defect fill in the period of 6 months. Pocket depth reduced from 8 mm to 5mm and clinical attachment level (CAL) from 10 mm to 8mm. FPD was fabricated i.r.t 11,21 and 22 which acted as a splint and improved the esthetics of the patient.

Conclusion- Patient showed marked improvement in oral health as evidenced by reduction in pocket depth, CAL and increase in bone density along with defect fill.

Key words – Palatogingival groove, Vertical defect, Bone Graft.

INTRODUCTION

The area of the maxillary lateral incisor is an area of embryological hazard. A great number of major and minor malformations occur. One such notorious anomaly or variant occurring in this region is the palatogingival groove and can be defined as “a developmental groove in a root that, when present,is usually found on the lingual aspect of maxillary incisor teeth”and is considered to be a rare entity1.

The anomaly has also been termed as the radicular anomaly, distolingual groove, radicular lingual groove, palate radicular groove, radicular groove and cinguloradicular groove2-5. As the name implies, this malformation is a groove shaped defect, which starts near the cingulum of the tooth and runs towards the cementoenamel junction in an apical direction at various depths and distances along the root surface2,3.It is thought to represent an infolding of the enamel organ and Hertwig’s root sheath6, leading to an external defect adjacent to the gingival crevice6, where as other workers claim this to be a resultant attempt of the body to form another root on the affected tooth7. However, more recently, the etiopathogenesishasbeen related to the recent concept of alteration of genetic mechanisms8.

It is the funnel shaped appearance which formsa niche for bacterial plaque and calculus accumulation9 and then provides the site or pathwayfor bacteria to penetrate into the periodontal ligamentarea and bone, resulting in a periodontal pocket along the length of the groove and a bony defect. According to the American Academy ofPeriodontology (AAP) 1999 classification system, thedevelopmental and acquired deformities andconditions were grouped together as an entity thatcould lead to periodontal destruction. As a result it becomes paramount to treat the groove and the defect caused by it6.

METHOD AND MATERIAL/CASE REPORT

A male patient aged 29 years reported at the department of periodontology for mobility i.r.t 12 and dirty teeth. Upon examination he was diagnosed with grade II mobility, class III recession, pocket of 8 mm, CAL of 10 and recession of 2mm,(fig 1a) and radiographic interpretation showed a periapical pathology in previously endodontically treated 12 ( fig 1b) and type III vertical defecti.r.t 12

Patient was informed regarding the defect and the surgery that it would require. After complete prophylaxis, coronoplastyandRe-endodontic treatment, surgery was commenced after 4 weeks. After anesthetizing the area a crevicular incision was given involving 11 to 14 and a conventional flap was raised in the labial and palatal region. After complete debridement of the granulation tissue a moat type of III- walled vertical bony defect was identified.( fig 2). Thepalatogingival groove was filled with GIC and the defect was debrided, cleaned and filled with Demineralised bone matrix (DMBM Osseo graft). (fig. 3 and 4). 3-0 silk sutures were placed, (fig 5) and patient was put on medication, Augmentin625mgBD for 5 days and analgesic Diclofenac50mg BD for three days, along with chlorhexidine mouthwash (CHX) 0.2% BD for 15 days.

After 10 days patient was recalled for suture removal. During the 10 days period patient did not report for any pain or swelling or anyother discomfort and the healing was uneventful. Patient was recalled for scheduled check-ups at 1, 3 and 6 months and his pocket depth, CAL and bone fill was measured. (fig6). The fabrication of bridge i.r.t 11,21 and 22 was made with better and acceptable esthetics to the patient. To enhance esthetics pink ceramic was used in gingival area. This prosthesis provided good esthetics on one hand and splinting of periodontically compromised tooth on the other hand.

RESULTS

The healing was uneventful and during the 6 month scheduled checkups at 1, 3 and 6 months patient did not report for any pain, swelling or any other discomfort. Patient’s pocket depth, CAL and bon fill along with arbitrary assessment of bone density was measured at 1, 3 and 6 months. There was 3 mm reduction of pocket depth from 8 mm to 5mm reduction of CAL from 10 mm to 8 mmat the end of 6 months. Mobility reduced from grade II to grade 0. Table 1.Showsmonth wise reduction in pocket depth and gain in CAL. Arbitrary assessment of bone density was done on the basis of radiographs which shows bone graft was well tolerated and increased the bone density of the patient i.r.t 21.( fig 7).

Gain in pocket depth and CAL

Baseline

1 month

3 month

6 month

Pocket Depth

8mm

6mm

5mm

5mm

CAL

10mm

8mm

8mm

8mm

Clinical figure Clinical figure
1.Fig 1(a)- preoperative view 2. Fig 1(b)- preoperative radiograph
Clinical figure Clinical figure
Fig 2- flap reflected , circumferential defect seen Fig 3 – GIC used to seal the defect
Clinical figure Clinical figure
Fig 4- placement of bone graft Fig 5- sutures placed
Clinical figure Clinical figure
Fig 6 – post operative 6 months Fig 7 – post operative radiograph

DISCUSSION

Historically, the presence of this palatoradicular groove is mentioned right from thedevelopment of mankind and its prevalence was saidto be 12-21% during the megalithic period5.The groove was first mentioned in a dental anatomy text in 1917, later described by Zeisz-Nuckolin9,10. In 1965, Prichard described this as a defect predisposed to the formation of periodontal pockets. Lee et al11 named this as the palatogingivalgroove.The prevalence and different morphologic conditions of the palatogingival groove were evaluated by Albaricciet al12 wherein 376 maxillary lateral and central incisors were examined. Results showed a higher prevalence in lateral incisors with higher prevalence in proximal localization, origination from central fossa (57.1%) and predominance in oblique trajectory (62.8%). Of all these teeth, only 8.6% of palatogingival grooves reached the root apex, while 97.1% were considered as flat (<1mm).
Thus a palatogingival ,groove is nothing but a developmental anomaly, and as aforementioned it is present as a funnel shaped defect, where pathologic bacteria accumulate and travel along the groove on the root surface till the periodontal ligaments and bone, causing various degrees of defects. Its treatment becomes challenging due to its identification and formation of a combined endodontic-periodontic lesion. When it occurs in bone, it causes various osseous defects, in this case it caused a moat-shaped vertical defect.

Vertical bone loss with a resultant intrabony defect results in a Moat-shaped defect13. And as the name suggests it’s a defect circumferential bony defect around the tooth caused by inflammation and in this case via palatogingival groove. The treatment is the same as treating any three-walled defect that is, with the use of bone grafts, with or without a membrane13.

Ballalet al14stated that the vertical bone loss due to the periodontal lesion can be treated using bone graft materials and a resorbable membrane can also be used for guided tissue regeneration as used by Anderegget al15. In the present case report, axenograft, which is a graft taken from a donor of a different species, namely Demineralised bone matrix (DMBM Osseograft) was used. It is a bone inducive sterile bioresorbablexenograft composed of type I collagen and is prepared from bovine cortical bone samples, resulting in nonimmunogenicflowable particles of approximately 250μm that are completely replaced by host bone in 4-24 weeks.

The treatment apart from filling the defect with a bone graft also involves closing the groove with the help a restorative material. The response of periodontal tissues to adhesive restorative materials has been studied by a number of investigators, and keeping all the factors into consideration, GIC becomes the material of choice while covering the groove as it aids in adhesion of fibroblasts and connective tissue to the restorations. GIC is recognized as an important biocompatible material used in retro-filling restorations and subgingival restorations. Dragoo16 and White17 found a favorable periodontal response to these subgingival restorations.

Breault et al18 showed reduction in probing depth and in the percentage of bleeding upon probing after the replacement of subgingival resin-modified glass ionomer cement (RMGIC) restorations. A clinical and histological evaluation performed on healthy dogs by Gomes et al19 demonstrated a better periodontal response to subgingival GIC restorations than to Amalgam. Another advantage according to Santamariaet20 and Alkanet al21of GIC is that it facilitates fibroblast adhesion.These results were particularly noticeable when supragingival plaque control was performed. Nevertheless, it should be kept in mind that the susceptibility to periodontal disease may influence such a response to these restorations.

Splinting in such cases is required to improve the prognosis of the tooth. Literature states that provisional splinting can also be used when treating periodontally compromised patients with conventional fixed prosthodontics and are placed only after the completion of periodontal therapy once occlusal stability has been achieved in order to eliminate or prevent occlusal trauma, increase functional stability, and improve esthetics on a long-term basis22.Patient wasfurther treatedin the department of Prosthodontics for fabrication of FPD i.r.t 11, 21 and 22 along with pink ceramic to mask recession. Such prosthesis improves prognosis,aids in stability to the tooth via splinting and improved esthetic concerns of the patient.

CONCLUSION

Aforementioned case report shows that treating PGG is like treating any other typeIIIvertical defects.According to the treatment protocol, vertical defects can be successfully treated with a bone graft which was evident in the results of this case report. FPD can be fabricated on periodontically treated teeth to improve stability, prognosis and esthetics when treatment is done in esthetic zone.

REFERENCES

  1. Kishan KV, HegdeV,PonnappaKC,Girish TN, Ponappa MC. Management of palato radicular groove in a maxillary lateral incisor. J Nat SciBiol Med. 2014;5:178–181.
  2. N.P. Kerezoudis, G. J. Siskos, Tsatsas V. Bilateral buccal radicular groove in maxillary incisors: case report. IntEndod J: 2003; 36: 898-906.
  3. Carlos Estrela, Helio Lopes Pereira, Jesus DjalmaPecora. Radicular Grooves in Maxillary Lateral Incisor: Case Report. Braz Dent J 1995; 6: 143-146.
  4. Everett FG, Kramer GM: The distolingual groove in the maxillary lateral incisor, a periodontal hazard. J Periodontol1972; 43:352-361.
  5. Robison SF, Cooley RL: Palatogingival groove lesions: recognition and treatment. General Dentistry1988;36:340-342.
  6. Ram S,Sudhakar U, Pramod V, Radhika A. Palatogingival grooves. Indian J Dent Adv 2010;2:229-33.
  7. Kerezoudis NP, Siskos GJ, Tsatsas V: Bilateral buccal radicular groove in maxillary incisor: Case Report. Intel Endod J2003;36:898-906.
  8. Ennes JP, Lara VS. Comparative morphological analysis of the root development groove with the palate-gingival groove. Oral dis 2004;10:378-82.
  9. Bhatsange A, Japatti S, Attur K. Palatogingival Groove: Management of an Innocuous Culprit of a Perio-endo Lesion. People’s J Sci Res 2012:5;43-6.
  10. Zeisz RC, Nuckolin J: Dental Anatomy.St.Louis, CV. Mosby Co.1949;p.65.


More references are availabe on request.

Disclaimer from Guident

The views and opinions expressed in articles published in Guident are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the editors, the editorial board or the publisher, Ivory India. Guident does not endorse any product, technique or treatment described. Clinical content is intended for qualified dental and medical professionals and is not a substitute for individual clinical judgement. Guident, its editors and the publisher accept no liability for any consequence arising from the use of information published in the journal.

How to cite this article

Dr. Himanshu Aeran, Dr. Sagrika Shukla, Dr. Saba Jamil Department of Prosthodontics. Prosthodontic and Periodontic Rehabilitation of a Mobile Tooth in Esthetic Zone. Guident. 2016 Feb;9(3). Available from: https://ivoryindia.in/articles/prosthodontics/prosthodontic-and-periodontic-rehabilitation-of-a-mobile-tooth-in-esthetic-zone.html

Related articles

More in Prosthodontics

All 386 articles
Vol. 9, Issue 3 · February 2016

Acupuncture in Prosthodontics

Authors : Dr Rohit Raghavan , Dr Shreshta Sathish . Abstract Acupuncture has been accepted to effectively treat chronic pain by inserting needles into the specific ‘‘acupuncture points’’…

Dr Rohit Raghavan

Vol. 9, Issue 3 · February 2016

Access to Better Dentures

Preservation of alveolar bone is the main aim of conventional tooth-retained overdenture. Preservation of teeth for overdenture can improve retention and stability. In this case report…

Dr. Rubina tabassum

Call for papers

Publish your clinical work in Guident

Original research, case reports and review articles are welcomed from clinicians and researchers worldwide. Every submission is assessed by the editorial board.